5 ms·
The original title of this submission was 'Linus to Nvidia: "Fuck You"', which was renamed by someone (the moderators? can the submitter change the title?) afte
by saurik 14y ago
The original title of this submission was 'Linus to Nvidia: "Fuck You"', which was renamed by someone (the moderators? can the submitter change the title?) after a ton of people had upvoted and commented on it, and despite the link being not to the entire video but instead to a specific point in the video for which the title of the entire video is probably not even an appropriate description.
So, when people are reading the comments of this submission in the future, please keep this in mind as a historical note. (This, humorously, was actually the kind of situation that caused the complaint[1] that itself turned into a massive hullabaloo recently regarding what can be discussed on HN and what the policies regarding hell-banning are; to view the reference you will need showdead.)
[1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4102013 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4102013
- flabbergasted 14y agoI guess the moderators were offended by a four letter word. "People who get offended should be offended!" - Linus http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MShbP3OpASA#t=3672s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MShbP3OpASA#t=3672s
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- aurelianito 14y agoI really agree with Linus on this one. I usually say that when one person offends other person, the one who is wrong is the offended person.
- kitsune_ 14y agoThat was a great line by him. "I like offending people because I think people who get offended should be offended."
- JoeCortopassi 14y agoThe new title completely changed what I was expecting when I clicked this link, which was much appreciated when I opened it at my in-laws with the volume on :-/. I honestly thought this was a follow up to the "Linus to Nvidia: 'F*ck You'" post for some commentary, and now feel like I just got Rick-Rolled... Edit: Seriously though, is the new rule that we aren't allowed to submit anything other than the page's title?
- Devilboy 14y agoCan we get a mod to clarify the title rules please? This is getting annoying.
- detst 14y agoThis is really unfortunate and takes away from HN. I'm fully in favor of defaulting to maintaining the original title but often it's so vague to be completely meaningless. Most people don't have time to click on every link so we simply pass on content that we would have read with a descriptive title. Generally I just pass the first time and check it out if it's still on the front page later; thinking it might be worthwhile if it's popular enough to still be there. Of course, in this case, it is a descriptive title for the talk but completely takes away the specific thing the submission is about. This is slightly less bad but still bad.
- SkyMarshal 14y agoThe current moderation system isn't scaling. This post is a good example to illustrate the problem. At first glance it appears to be a flamebait title, and hence a mod who sees it may feel it's a no-brainer - correct it and move on. However, there's a nuance to it - that is exactly how Linus Torvalds expresses himself, and the original title ("Linus to Nvidia: Fuck You!", or something close to that) captured his sentiment accurately, so maybe it's not flamebait after all. Or maybe it is flamebait even despite that, since Linus's SOP is to sometimes start flamewars to make a point, break through the red tape, or otherwise just make a command decision and move on. Clearly plenty of room for moderation error, a nd that's just one submission. What's a mod to do? So on the one hand, there has been a spate of godawfully-titled submissions in recent months: 1. "X things you should ... whatever" type titles (clearly banned in the HN posting guidelines) 2. Too short and uninformative (like a word or three). 3. Sensationalism, flamebait, miscategorized comparison results, etc. 4. more I'm sure... But on the other hand, the mod system has problems as well: 1. Nobody even knows what the mod system is 2. Nobody knows who the mods are. 3. There's no way to give feedback on moderations, for the ones that were incorrectly modded. 4. Too many false positives (posts that shouldn't be modded but are, resulting comments like saurik's above, and entire threads complaining this problem). 5. Too many false negatives that slip through anyway. And of course, not part of the mod system, but too many submitters just don't know how to descriptively, accurately, concretely title submissions anyway, increasing the volume a seemingly too-small group of mods has to deal with. HN isn't the first social media site to have problems like this, but most others have a full-time dev team working on solving them, and they evolve certain solutions like Slashdot's meta-moderation or Reddit's user-run/modded subreddits. So I don't think the mod system in its current form can scale with those problems, but on a more meta level I'm not sure that PG can scale as the developer of the mod system, given that YC takes 110% of his time. Just trying to identify the problem before attempting to solve it, any thoughts?
- mcav 14y agoIt's been like this for a long time. It's by far the least transparent moderation in a community I've ever seen. For a long time I thought of HN as a generally smart, reasonable community (less so these days with the masses here) but the completely opaque moderation has always seemed extraordinarily, unnecessarily restrictive and elitist. It's unlikely to change at this point. The minority who care don't matter enough. Personally I'd love to see another smaller, more refocused community spin off where better, more open and reasoned tech/startup discussions can take place. Keep it invite-only perhaps.