4 ms·
"Fair Source" strikes me as a great idea, but I see many many people misunderstand the intent, and being mad at the company for not using a FOSS license. Howeve
by stavros 2y ago
"Fair Source" strikes me as a great idea, but I see many many people misunderstand the intent, and being mad at the company for not using a FOSS license. However, that was never the choice: The choice was always between "fair source" and "closed source", and I'm glad a reasonably open alternative to closed source exists.
- wmf 2y agoWe're still in the hangover period from when VCs would shovel money into open-source startups that had no business model. Fair source feels like a step down from that.
- stavros 2y agoAnd it's a smaller step down than closing the source completely.
- woodruffw 2y agoI think it’s a great idea, but I’d love to see a little bit more consideration around labeling one’s licensing scheme as the “fair” one. Intuitively: if I named my political party “the party without stinky feet,” it’s clear that I’m indirectly saying that other parties do have stinky feet. In a similar manner, labeling yourself the “fair” one indirectly suggests that other licensing schemes, including OSS ones, are somehow unfair.
- LoganDark 2y agoOpen-source licenses absolutely can be unfair. If a company takes your MIT-licensed software and builds a huge enterprise on it and gives you none of the money? That's unfair for you. But with closed-source software, it's unfair for everyone who uses it. So imagine if there were some sort of middle ground. (I'm not currently aware of a good one, lol) I'm not talking about if someone uses left-pad as part of a billion LOC project, but more like if a company builds its entire stack on top of something like, say, ffmpeg, or ImageMagick, and the original devs never see even a smidgeon of thanks.
- woodruffw 2y agoSure, I wouldn't describe that as fair. But that's my point: OSS licenses don't use phrases like "fair": they talk concretely in terms of rights and guarantees, and they leave it up to both parties to determine whether those rights and guarantees are what they want. I think this can be fair. But I would love to have seen that communicated as "we wrote the license to address the problem of fairness in corporate usage of OSS," not "this is a/the fair license." The latter is a value judgment that isn't universalizable.
- LoganDark 2y agoI read it at first like the usage of fair was as in quantity, as in a middle ground between fully closed and fully open. But calling it a "medium source license" would probably sound weirder than "fair source".
- woodruffw 2y agoKing Solomon has a thing or two to say about middle grounds :-)[1] (I agree that "medium source" sounds very weird. Maybe they could have called it the "Availability License" or something similar to emphasize that this is about finding a sweet spot between monetization rights and exposing the source code to the public eye. I don't think that would carry the same baggage as "fair," but it also certainly doesn't have the same marketing flair to it.) [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judgement_of_Solomon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judgement_of_Solomon
- LoganDark 2y agoAvailability License would probably sound too similar to "source-available" which is often implied to be a lot more restrictive than this model seems to be.
- ThrowawayR2 2y agoUse without compensation is what an author intentionally signed up for by choosing the MIT license or other FOSS licenses. The marketers are trying to sell this as "unfair", "predatory", etc., as if the authors were too ignorant to understand the implications of their own license choice. It is perfectly fine to choose Fair Source as a license; that's the prerogative of whoever is writing the code. But don't let these people marketing Fair Source circulate the idea that FOSS licensing is "unfair". It's just another sleazy tactic they're trying after their attempt to redefine open source to include their proprietary Fair Source licensing got rebuffed by the community.