3 ms·
You raise a keyword that is paramount in our time. Dignity. Privacy is a tangible and common talking point. Anyone who wants to flee to a forest hut can obtain
by nonrandomstring 2y ago
You raise a keyword that is paramount in our time. Dignity. Privacy is
a tangible and common talking point. Anyone who wants to flee to a
forest hut can obtain privacy, but not dignity, because escape is
undignified.
While the concept of privacy makes it into laws, it's still just a
minor component of a broader "dignity" that so many technologies seem
set on destroying. A dozen or more major thinkers since the 1900s have
noticed that human dignity is very fragile in the face of technology
(Weber, Marx, Fromm, Freud, Jung, Nietzsche...) Surveillance is just
one modern facet of undignified life with technology.
Question: can technology ever enhance dignity?
We've seemingly built a system (society) in which material and social
success hinge on a willingness to forgo dignity. People who have a
strong sense of dignity are disadvantaged and marginalised. So to
answer your "to where?" To the margins. Unless one is prepared to
embrace indignity in visible opposition. Struggle may be the last
refuge of dignity.
- mdp2021 2y ago> escape is undignified According to what would-be objective judgement? Under a threshold you fight; over a threshold you flee. It is just sensible. Dignity may or may not be impacted, heightened or lowered - it depends on details. > can technology ever enhance dignity Of course tools and devices are meant to enhance dignity, we build them for a purpose - to serve us and assist. > We've seemingly built a system (society) in which material and social success hinge on a willingness to forgo dignity. People who have a strong sense of dignity are disadvantaged and marginalised Very correct. (Careful with those «we».) > To the margins Of what is not your society? Look at reality. It is a procustean coexistence of squirrels and Men. There will probably be societies less vile.