3 ms·
Your statement is ambiguous, since it confuses "health in totality" versus "a healthy response" to other causes. Compare: "Entertaining the idea that [screamin
by Terr_ 2y ago
Your statement is ambiguous, since it confuses "health in totality" versus "a healthy response" to other causes.
Compare: "Entertaining the idea that [screaming] is a response from healthy individuals cannot be tolerated."
Obviously, such a statement would be a dramatic overreach.
* Screaming because a rubber snake was thrown at your face? That's actually a very healthy response, in the short term.
* Screaming because you got stabbed in the leg with a fork? Also a healthy response, but you'll need to get that unhealthy leg looked at.
* Screaming because you just won the lottery? Healthy response, just questionable financial skills.
* Screaming for no apparent reason? ... Probably not a healthy response.
Anyway, at this point we do not know enough about depression to conclusively declare that it is never serving any adaptive purpose. It would be a shame if the fork-stabbing patient were to be "treated" by sticking a syringe of muscle-relaxant into their voicebox.
- rexpop 2y ago> Screaming for no apparent reason Possibly a rubber snake that's not immediately obvious to others.