4 ms·
reproductive sex is binary. Dawkins knows better and knows that that humans are born that are not clearly male, not clearly female, and also very clearly neith
by defrost 2y ago
reproductive sex is binary.
Dawkins knows better and knows that that humans are born that are not clearly male, not clearly female, and also very clearly neither male nor female.
That's actual empirical observed science. There are peer reviewed medical papers in respected journals that look at hundreds of thousands of birth records and break the numbers down on distributions of chromosonal variations at birth.
- subjectsigma 2y agoWould you mind linking a study? It seems like that directly contradicts what Dawkins says in his article
- defrost 2y agoI bought a first edition copy of Dawkin's The Selfish Gene in 1978 and a good number of his books since. He understands genetics and these days, when talking to the likes of Piers Morgan et al. he plays a cagey game and talks about reproductive sex, what is required to make a baby outside of a lab the good old fashioned way, when a sperm fertilises an egg. He's well aware there are more than two types of human birth, he glosses over what he knows to keep things simple to avoid contraversy or something. If this is all news to you, rather than something you might have read, as I did, some 40+ years ago, then you might choose to start with: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex IIRC it links to medical papers and meta papers. There are several people here in Australia that were born neither male nor female. That's a fact. One took a valid complaint through the Australian courts that they would be lying on an official document if they checked either [F] or [M] on an Australian passport. Doctors and genetics experts gave evidence, the Australian passport system was changed. This wasn't some "cultural gender" thing based on someone's feelings about gender, it was stone cold genetic reality about "sex" at birth .. which in reality is a lot more complicated than many Fox cable hosts claim it to be on camera.
- subjectsigma 2y agoOk, great. Can you link to the study which shows chromosomal distributions, the one you mentioned in your comment?
- defrost 2y ago[3], [8], [9], and all the numerous other references that appear immediately after a "%" sign in the already provided link. [3] is Selma Feldman Witchel (2018). "Disorders of Sex Development". Best Practice & Research. Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology. 48: 90–102. doi:10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2017.11.005. PMC 5866176. PMID 29503125. The estimated frequency of genital ambiguity is reported to be in the range of 1:2000–1:4500 Those referencess of the 218 references provided are the ones that mainly focus on various aspects of distribution frequency.
- subjectsigma 2y agoThanks!
- blinkedup 2y ago> There are several people here in Australia that were born neither male nor female. That's a fact. One took a valid complaint through the Australian courts that they would be lying on an official document if they checked either [F] or [M] on an Australian passport. Do you have a reference for or link to the details of the court case? It would be very interesting to understand the details.
- defrost 2y agoThere are several Family Court of Australia decisions, along with the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 and its underpinnings that go with the 2003 decision of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade to recommend that Australian passports allow the indeterminate category and for the State of Victoria to change their policy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex_rights_in_Australia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex_rights_in_Australia sketches out a framework, the details can be extracted from the public records for the Department, the State of Victoria, and the decisions of the Family Court.
- blinkedup 2y agoBy chromosomal variations, do you mean sex chromosome aneuploidies? If so, individuals with this particular class of conditions aren't ambiguous with regards to their sex. The Y chromosome still determines if someone is male. For example, XXY (Klinefelter syndrome) is a male condition, X0 (Turner syndrome) is a female condition, XYY (Jacobs syndrome) is male, and so on.
- defrost 2y agoOf all the humans born, some are clearly and unambigiously male and check all the many boxes that make them male, some are equally female, some others are not so clearly male and only check some of the boxes leaving the gate open for the "but they're really male (even if only a bit)" arguments. Some others again are neither male nor female. This is the spectrum of human physical and genetic birth presentations as described by peer reviewed medical papers (a number linked in the intersex wikipedia link). Venn diagrams are not difficult to grasp and anyone taking issue with the categorisation in the field is more than welcome to submit their work and arguments to the relevant journals.
- blinkedup 2y agoThanks for replying. That doesn't directly answer my question but it sounds like you meant to refer to differences of sex development (DSDs) more broadly rather than just those caused by chromosomal variations. Though for competitive sports, and protecting the women's category in particular, it is only a smaller set of DSDs that eligibility policymakers need to be concerned with: those that confer male physical advantage.