3 ms·
chii wrote: "What happens if it wasn't so obvious?" Is Musk a scammer? Bitcoin? The commission Apple charges on the App Store? The Fortnight monetisation syste
by ben_w 2y ago
chii wrote: "What happens if it wasn't so obvious?"
Is Musk a scammer? Bitcoin? The commission Apple charges on the App Store? The Fortnight monetisation system? Facebook's claim to be able to accurately target adverts? Vaccines and masks? OpenAI?
People on this website have said so about each of those examples.
That is why it's bad to go down that path.
- throwaway7ahgb 2y agoTo answer your question, No they aren't. Until the REAL scammers are brought down, people will take actions into their own hands.
- ben_w 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhetorical_question https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhetorical_question If the question's answer was obvious and resolving false then none would have been described thusly, if it was obvious and resolving true then you wouldn't be denying it. Merely asserting that they are not, in your opinion (though hey, look at those legal cases they have between them…) does nothing to remove the fact that they have been called this. It also does nothing to help with the lack of legitimacy of vigilantes. Nor, in this case, jurisdiction: part of the problem here is international cooperation, because right now the USA (where the victim is) and China (where the gang is) are a bit chilly towards each other. > people will take actions into their own hands. Amateurs sending a bomb their way? That's one way to describe how WW1 started.
- bigallen 2y agoI think the point they’re trying to make is that determining who is a criminal and what kind of punishment they deserve is a very difficult task that depends largely on perspective.
- danaris 2y agoThe existence of a gray area in between "obviously fine" and "obviously wrong" doesn't mean that there is nothing in those outer categories. It is, at least hypothetically, possible to define "scammer" clearly enough that the more egregious and clear-cut types are taken care of more expeditiously. Not sure if there's a way to actually enforce that better, but "it is possible to disagree over whether some things are scams" is not the same as "there's no way to agree on whether anything is a scam".
- ben_w 2y agoIn principle, when the legal system handles the cases, I agree: don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. In this specific case, when it comes to vigilantes in particular? Then no. I think that a society which allows it will end up somewhere between lynching and anarchy. Better law enforcement, which does not even have to mean "more laws"? Good. Batman wannabes? Bad.