3 ms·
I don't follow. Obviously metabolisms differ widely. But "calories in - calories out" is a simple statement of conservation of energy. I assure you, that hol
by ajross 14y ago
I don't follow. Obviously metabolisms differ widely. But "calories in - calories out" is a simple statement of conservation of energy. I assure you, that holds as true in a person's body as it does in a particle collider.
- capsule_toy 14y agoI'm guessing he's referring to Gary Taubes and the book, Good Calories, Bad Calories. It was a big thing years ago, and I would have also assumed most people knew about it. One of the basic ideas is that calories in - calories out = fat is an oversimplification and ignores the complexities of the way our bodies process different foods. In other words, the argument isn't trying to break the laws of physics, it's just arguing where the energy is actually going in your equation. The book itself is lengthy and comprehensive. He cites a lot of research to make his case, and the citations are available in the book. With that said, I don't think calories in - calories out is wildly inaccurate, and I don't believe Taubes makes that case.
- beagle3 14y ago> But "calories in - calories out" is a simple statement of conservation of energy. At the physical thermodynamical level, yes. But estimating "calories in" from food intake and estimating "calories out" from exercise apparently have +/-50% error if you take the numbers from the food packaging and from an exercise book respectively, if you actually measure them for a specific person (which is exceedingly hard, almost never done properly, and always takes for granted assumptions that are not proven -- see my answer to DanBC down this thread) I should have been more precise: "calories in - calories out = calories stored" is a tautology given conservation of energy, as you alluded. But it turns out to be a very inaccurate prediction if weight gain if you assume "calories in"="what's written on the food label", "calories out=what's written in an exercise book about your exercise", and "calories stored=9kcal/g per body weight gained". All 3 are bad measurements, that somehow work out for the majority (60%-90% of the population, depending on how you set your error bars), but break for a minority. If conservation of energy did not work for 10% of particles, physicists would look for a better description. Somehow, nutrition "experts" are allowed to hand wave the inaccuracies and are given a free pass as scientists. They aren't.