14 ms·
Intel's Immiseration
- PaulHoule 2y agoThe biggest problem I've seen with Intel is that they are "getting high on their own supply" and the whole tech press enables them with the sole exception of Charlie Demerjian. They should pick a few random people out of the phone book and pay them handsomely for their advice, this way they might start to "see themselves as other see them". Most of all they need to recognize the phenomenon of "brand destruction" which has manifest in clueless campaigns such as "Ultrabooks", brands that should have been killed off years ago ("Celeron", sorry, low performance brands have a shelf life, there's a reason why Honda is still making the Civic but GM is not making the Chevette) and that they should write it in their bylaws that they are getting out of the GPU business permanently (they've made so many awful products it will take 15 years for people to get the idea that an Intel GPU adds value, instead it's this awful thing you have to turn off so that it won't screw up graphics in your web browser when you're using a Discrete GPU.) People might get their heads around the idea that an Intel CPU is a premium brand if it had a GPU chiplet from a reputable manufacturer like AMD or NVIDIA. (Oddly when Intel has had a truly premium brand, as in SSDs, they've ignored it. Hardly anybody noticed the great 95% latency performance that of Intel SSDs because hardly anybody realizes that 95% latency is what you feel when your computer feels slow. Intel SSDs were one Intel product that I would seek out by name, at least until they sold their SSD division. Most people who've run a lot of Intel SSDs swear by them.)
- is_true 2y agoDoes the new owner provides the same performance?
- christkv 2y agoThe CEO had only been in charge since 2021 bringing an engineer back to the helm. How long does it take to bring a big ship like Intel around and undo decades of internal rot? It will be interesting to see who is let go in the coming months.
- akira2501 2y ago> How long does it take to bring a big ship like Intel around and undo decades of internal rot? If it takes that long, then this is your actual problem, and not how many engineers are in the loop at the board level.
- soulbadguy 2y ago>If it takes that long, then this is your actual problem Most IC design life cycle are 5+ years. Expecting to turn over in less is part of the problem intel is having currently.
- macintux 2y agoI'm skeptical. Big company, design & manufacturing cycles on the order of years because chips are that sophisticated these days, I don't know what you'd expect to see within 3 years of a new CEO.
- barkingcat 2y agoto be honest, they should have done a layoff 3 years ago, as soon as Pat Gelsinger came onboard, and fired 2 entire layers of management. No engineers or support people, but just pure middle managers - fire 2 or 3 layers. if they did that 3 years ago, they would be in a better position now.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 2y agoGelsinger would be shooting blind and in order to cut enough to force compliance he would ultimately be sabotaged as the entire workforce unites against him unless he had the ability to bring in a few thousand loyal soldiers to manage every unit. He’s got the much harder job of ferreting out deep corruption and incompetence that perniciously hides in corners protected by knowing whose buried what bodies. Rough job that he cannot possibly accomplish. Instead he’s probably trying to root out these toxic messes and quarantine them in safe environments where they can be productive enough to realize ROI but disempowered and segregated while he works on fixing the broken systems and teams that got Intel to this point. Maybe this layoff was in his back pocket waiting for the right time to cut the shit loose with cover or maybe he failed to realize that should have been his first order of business and this was a desperate move to stop the hemorrhaging and Intels books are going to be even worse two years out when the consequences of firing qualified staff begins to manifest.
- Miraste 2y agoA lot of these are symptoms of the root cause: a bad product. Ultrabooks aren't a terrible concept; they're the Wintel version of Macbook Airs. Making a non-Apple Apple device is a fine business strategy, and Samsung has made plenty of money off of it. The problem was that Intel chips continually crippled them, making them hot and slow with no battery life. People don't like Celerons and iGPUs because they all run at the speed of molasses. Any of these branding decisions would have worked fine, if the products did. But no amount of marketing will fix bad engineering.
- soulbadguy 2y agobad product is a symptoms of a even deeper cause... Lack of competition. The decline of intel started long ago. The financial results here are just very very lagging indicator of that. The lack of competition combined with very agressive anti competitive practice allow them to survive on pretty bad product line. In a healthy market, competition would have force intel to improve well before the point we are now
- jakobson14 2y agoThey are only moving because AMD is finally providing that competition, but it's not fair to say that "if only AMD had gotten their act together sooner, intel would be a better comapny." Ultimately, intel chose to let intel rot while AMD was out of the picture. (ignoring that intel's backroom deals with Dell and co. are a big part of what pushed AMD out)
- PaulHoule 2y agoAMD and ARM-based solutions too. I can't picture wanting to run Windows on ARM for a few product generations but for server use I'd have no problem w/ Linux on ARM.
- adrian_b 2y agoWhile the Intel laptop CPUs may have been not good enough, that is not where Intel has lost money. The current financial results have shown decent profits for the consumer CPUs, which could have been greater if Intel had succeeded to produce more Meteor Lake CPUs. Intel could not produce as many Meteor Lake CPUs as the demand because their new Intel 4 manufacturing process has low production yields. While Intel lost money in their foundry, that was unavoidable due to the high expenses needed for catching up with TSMC. Where Intel had great losses was in server CPUs. The reason for these losses must have been that Intel had to grant very large discounts to the big buyers of server CPUs, in order to convince them to not buy superior AMD server CPUs. These losses in server CPUs were easily predictable, because even if Intel has succeeded to reach in time all the publicly announced milestones of their roadmap, their roadmap itself does not hope to reach parity with the AMD server CPUs before H2 2025 (and that assuming that AMD will not introduce Zen 6 during 2025, which would move the target). It looks like Intel has made a PR mistake. Even if their public roadmap has shown all the time that they will continue to have big losses for at least one more year, that was obvious only for technical people, who could compare the future Intel products with the AMD products, because Intel has not said any word in their roadmap about what the competition will have at the same time. For non-technical people, the Intel press releases sounded more optimistic than they should have been, leading to disappointment caused by financial results that should not have been surprising.
- impossiblefork 2y agoBut don't they need to get into the GPU business? Surely GPUs or similarly very parallel machines for things like ML training are very needed and will remain very needed. Seeing as firms such as Groq have done fine, surely Intel can do something of that sort without much difficulty? Since their GPU business has been unsuccessful perhaps they can go for whatever makes sense, as there's nothing of this sort that they can release that will compete with their own products.
- pradn 2y agoThe AI boom is, in theory, a godsend for Intel and AMD. You can focus on creating good tensor computation hardware, without having to worry about getting gamers on board. No need for "Game ready drivers" or compatibility with complex legacy graphics APIs. Of course, there's the elephant the room for general purpose tensor machines, which is CUDA - famously closely guarded Nvidia. But with the new wave of "above-CUDA" APIs like TensorFlow, PyTorch, and Keras, there's an opportunity to skip the CUDA layer altogether.
- Sparkyte 2y agoAI doesn't exist with the right amount of collected data, we're going to hit a wall very soon where we just get bad AI data constantly because we are throwing data to the wall and hoping it sticks. Businesses should not be investing in AI right yet maybe 2-3 more years. The businesses that should are the startups and businesses who are helping define the model, like ChatGPT and Microsoft, but the adoption is still too early. If I was McDonald's or Wendy's and I wanted to use AI to help promote sales to customers I would need to be able to grab demographic data which may not be appropriate PII data. All of the lawsuits happening right now for data collected without permission of the data provider is going to all change the landscape.
- nullc 2y agoI think there is still a good business to be made taking the AI stuff we have right now and making it highly performant. Stable diffusion models are awesome and super useful. I don't necessarily mean the simplistic text->image stuff (though it's clearly useful)-- but denoising, in painting, animation from stills, 3d from stills.... style changes, etc. LLMs are at least somewhat useful. We can radically improve image and video compression with performant enough AI. Plenty of other applications of AI right now are already useful or would be useful if inference were made more efficient or more local (thus private). No more data needed. You don't need some grand vision of an AI future to get a total addressable market for high performance AI that is in the same ballpark as high performance GPUs for non-AI usage.
- Sparkyte 2y agoIntel has always been an echo chamber of fiscal earnings and cutting corners to appease investors. For the longest time they stagnated on Mac hardware improvements because it would cost money, they would not have lost Mac as a business customer if they continued to innovate.
- PaulHoule 2y agoAlso they should have had a policy of "not one transistor for the national labs" and "not one transistor for hyperscalers", particularly because anything they do to appease hyperscalers just saves them money that they'll spend on their custom silicon transition. There's something prestigious about HPC but the story of how commercial data processing went parallel in the oughts shows how out of touch the HPC community is. In the meantime Intel has botched the deployment of SIMD, slowplaying to the point where maybe 7 or 8 years from now some mainstream software might support AVX512, maybe. Somebody should be tarred and feathered for introducing the idea that features should be fused off for all but the highest paying customers. If the customer is not paying for the fused off functionality, the shareholders are. It sounds really ruthless and avaricious and might impress some business analysts as a form of vice signalling but it's pure waste.
- Sparkyte 2y agoRight it is wasteful. The reason some businesses are so successful is that they look at the common denominators rather than trying to perpetuate worth. Fewer variants and don't wall off features. AMD did this for the longest period getting back on it feet, but I am seeing a failure of them continuing down this path. They need to stop making variants and focus on 3 or 4 sets of consumer processors.
- PaulHoule 2y agoYep, “too many SKUs” killed off the consumer HDD a few years faster than it had to die. If these companies had focus groups that reached out to ordinary people they’d realize it sounds absolutely incredible to most people that you need one hard drive for a 3-5 bay NAS, another for a 6-9 bay NAS, another if you are recording from video cameras. Even if there was a real benefit from optimizing firmware and saving a few cents with cheap washers for drives in a low vibration environment there is a much more certain cost in that you have to qualify the firmware, risk introducing errors, etc. I can imagine that Best Buy might have been able to stock one model of high capacity HDD but no way were they going to stock more colors of WD drive than there are on the rainbow flag. That lack of product sense locked manufacturers out of the retail market. (Makes me think of the cringe monthly hard drive roundup in Anandtech where an enterprise drive produced in huge numbers in a single SKU would usually be $80-100 cheaper than prosumer drives that, according to the spec sheet, consumed about 0.5W less and were about 3db quieter… And I have plenty of those enterprise drives still spinning after all these years, the only time I think about the noise is when the machine boots and the drives emit a throaty chirp that makes me think of a Ferrari spooling up.)
- immibis 2y agoI have an Arc A770 and it seems to work fine so far... though I've only had it for a month. There are some tolerable teething problems: I can't set the fan curve from Linux so I had to duct tape some extra fans, and it's incompatible with BIOS boot (requires UEFI) which should be considered acceptable in 2024. For presumably the same reason, there's no graphics output in early Linux boot until the GPU driver is loaded. The IGPU in my previous machine's i7-6700K (Skylake) was also just fine. Intel Graphics Media Accelerator, yeah that really sucked, but that was like 15 years ago?
- Jochim 2y agoThe main issue with ARC seems to be driver support in specific games, DX11 being particularly problematic. Intel basically have to catch up on the ~10-20 years of kludges that AMD, Nvidia, and game devs had already implemented when the games were released. They've been making strong improvements to their drivers though. Their iGPU is great for home media servers. Low power draw, QuickSync can handle multiple 4k transcodes, and one less part to buy. iGPUs still aren't a great choice for gaming on desktops, even the latest AMD APUs perform poorly in comparison to the cheaper dGPUs.
- immibis 2y agoMy Skylake iGPU ran everything on my PC just fine for me. That ranges from Minecraft to (apparently the most graphically intensive game I own) The Talos Principle. Sure, not always at the ultra high settings, but that's not something I care about. Once I upgraded recently to a Threadripper I threw in an old GTX 760 because Threadrippers don't have iGPUs. The 760 also did fine. Now I finally have a bleeding-edge-ish Sparkle Arc A770, but that's only because I wanted to run a shader coding event and didn't want to force other people to care about the server having a behind-the-curve GPU.
- samstave 2y agoDisclaimer: I used to work at Intel: Specifically, I was the second person on the planet to game on a Celeron Proc. How? Me and my best friend ran the Intel Developer Relations Group Gaming Test Lab in the later half of the 90s. Our job was to specifically test all PC games that were being developed against the Intel Celeron procs and the amd alts... with a focus on Subjective Gaming Performance of the Celeron as an "Optimized" feature leader whereby developers were given handsome marketing monies to optimize the games against latest SIMD instructions to allow for the games to be more performant on the Celeron. THe goal: Show the world that a $1,000 fully capable gaming PC was possible, in their budget, and desirable. --- The Issue at the time was the graphic bottlenecks -- all the pieces had yet to come to fore: AGP, Unreal, OpenGL, ~~NERDS~~ NURBS!, Games, Graphix Chips (VooDoo, 3DFX, blah blah) Celeron should have died long ago - but certainly when the first, actual GPUs came along and did the heavy lifting. I have a lot of thoughts about Intels mess (Transmetta really fucked Intel up in the way an abusive step-relative would) and caused them to lose focus... Then, just the ridiculous amount of marketing over engineering.... (if anyone worked at intel in the DRG circles in SC5 - and has access to emails of that day - search my name and the thread I started asking why we cant just physically stack CPUs on top of eachother... (this was prior to the Voxel timeline) and was laughed at. it wasnt until several years after that I went on a hike with a labs head and found out about the 64-core text CPUs that were only coming out) --- I was just having shower-thoughts about intels future as effectively computing grout -- a mechanism to get data from real-world INTO NVIDIA GPUs and then displayed again real-world. And thats it. Thats the only thing Intel may be doing in the future - is grout to display the data components solely computed, as NVIDIA CEO stated himself "All compute will be done on NVIDIA chips" -- delivery of the data through intel's grout (minimally) then again delivered to an NVIDIA desktop GPU... Intel is like the maintenance staff of a home. NVIDIA is the architect, interior designer, party planner and end user. (Intel was my first ever stock package: $70 with a $125 option price. 10K shares. I left before ever vesting... it was the late 90s and I had to chase the dream intc: https://i.imgur.com/U9PWURv.png https://i.imgur.com/U9PWURv.png )
- gdiamos 2y agoEven then, why is Intel better grout than AMD today?
- spookie 2y agoHaving a third competitor in the GPU is great, for both Intel and the consumer. If one starts blaming newcomers for their shortcomings then we are failing to see the bigger picture. When you talk about web browsers failing to display content because of the iGPUs I fail to even have heard of such a case. Maybe the performance is bad but that's it. Either way, that's more of a failure of the OS and not Intel. Windows is particularly biased to not use your dGPU on a laptop, but I blame the kernel for making badly calculated assumptions based on nothing but !={game, 3D modelling tool} then iGPU, and not the hardware.
- gorgoiler 2y agoYour second quote has always resonated very strongly with me, both as a concept and also from the original-ish verse: Oh would some power the gift He gives us To see ourselves as others see us It would from many a blunder free us And foolish notion What airs in dress and gait would leave us And even in CPU fabrication! — adapted from “To a Louse”, R. Burns
- larodi 2y agofrom https://genius.com/Top-cat-a-friend-in-need-panik-and-m-rode-mix-lyrics https://genius.com/Top-cat-a-friend-in-need-panik-and-m-rode... """ A Friend In Need Is A Friend Indeed But a friend with weed is better So if you want to get high Bring your own supply Or we will know you as a joker smoker """
- roydivision 2y agoIntel should never be directing its branding at the end user in the first place. Joe Public doesn't give a rats ass what is powering his device. Ask anyone off the street if they know who AMD are and what they produce. Concentrate on making good product and the device manufacturers will come to you.
- Rinzler89 2y ago>Ask anyone off the street if they know who AMD are and what they produce. That's why Intel, AMD and Nvidia are super obnoxious with plastering laptop keyboards with their stickers. They want the consumers to know what's inside.
- greybox 2y agoI'm not so sure nobody cares. Because of the apple's M1-3 machines battery life, people already associate ARM chips with power efficiency. People will always want their laptop/tablet/phone batteries to last longer, and if makers of those devices know that consumers associate ARM with power efficiency, they will want to take advantage of that.
- roydivision 2y agoThey know that the latest Apple laptop is the fastest, but they don't know an ARM from a leg, and neither should they need to.
- jakobson14 2y agoapple: "Out latest laptop has <magic maguffin>!" consumer, at the store: "why doesn't this thing have <magic maguffin>!? bring me something that has <magic maguffin>!!!"
- jakobson14 2y agoIntel has spent the last 25 years training consumers to look for the "intel inside" sticker. It's the only thing that's kept intel afloat while they butcher their engineering tallent. People shouldn't care, but they do.
- thaumasiotes 2y ago> instead it's this awful thing you have to turn off so that it won't screw up graphics in your web browser when you're using a Discrete GPU. You can disable integrated graphics chips?
- Gettingolderev 2y agoThey were leader for over 10-15 years. They wiped the floor with Nehalem left and right. The tooling of intel is still better than AMD. The celerons and other types of CPUs are in plenty of notebooks people have who buy laptops below 1k. The SSD topic happened, and went away i guess it was a margen topic. Low margin, ultra mass product lots of other companies happily building them. I think its critical for intel to have knowledge about GPUs for a stable longterm strategy. It was critical 10 years ago when they tried and failed hard with larrabee but they need to do that or buy AMD/Nvidia. With AI and modern workload you can't just have CPUs anymore and with CUDA and ML that was clear a long time ago. The market itself is also totally bonkers. When AMD surpassed intel, intel still sold like cake and still does. The fab capacity in the world is limited. If you can't get an Nvidia GPU for 200-300 because they complelty ignore this price range, than you have only AMD and intel left. Intel took the market of low end gpus already through their iGPUs. Intel knows how to build GPUs and other things than CPUs. It would be a total waste for them to stop. Intel should have bought nvidia or done something else but the Intel CEO is an idiot. He stated publicly that Nvidias position is just luck. That is such a weird idiotic take its bonkers that someone who would say something like this is the CEO of intel. The amount of R&D Nvidia did and still does left and right is crazy. He totally ignores how much Nvidia was doing the right things at the right time. Not sure were intel is heading but with their fab knowledge and capacity, their cashflow and core tech, they should be able to swing back. I was hoping that would happen already, unclear to me why they struggle so so hard
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- kjellsbells 2y agoThe classic moat metaphor that the OP article and others use needs to be fleshed out to match Intel's predicament. A moat protects a castle that adversaries want to take over. The presence of the castle defines what can and cannot be done with the surrounding landscape. But if the castle ceases to protect what people care about, or make meaningful additions to the environment, it becomes irrelevant and the presence of the moat makes no difference. Intel's problem isn't that competitors want to storm the castle and achieve domination over the landscape that x86 controls. It's that the competition have built their own castles on the other side of the river, and a lot of the peasants are tilling the lands around Castle ARM and Chateau NVIDIA. To put it another way, Intel thought the castle was "control of computing" and the moat was "leadership in x86" but irrelevance comes a little closer with each passing chip generation. It is fortunate for Intel that corraling an ecosystem into existence around the alternatives to x86 is an insanely difficult task, but it has been done with ARM, it has been done (albeit for a niche) with NVIDIA and it can be done again with whatever comes next.
- soulbadguy 2y ago>Intel's problem isn't that competitors want to storm the castle and achieve domination over the landscape that x86 controls. IMO it's both. While the importance x86 is declining, AMD is aggressively eating what ever part of it is left. I also think that in the long term, as intel and amd build better x86 chips, the value proposition of ARM will slowly fade in favor of something like risc-v
- apantel 2y agoAsking because I don’t know: what is the value proposition of ARM?
- avidphantasm 2y agoIn PCs, ARM CPUs perform just as good or better than AMD64 but have much better battery life. In the cloud, ARM CPUs are much cheaper (ca. 25% less) for the same or better performance.
- causal 2y agoThe article quotes a mention of Intel getting into the foundry business - this seems like the most obvious good move to make, even if a little late, right? Being able to operate a general fab for chips seems far more important now than the design of the chips, since design has been somewhat commoditized by ARM. Any big downside for this move?
- barkingcat 2y agothe downside is that the foundry process has to work properly, and by all reports, it hasn't started working properly yet.
- causal 2y agoOnly report I saw on it was that Intel said they have tested working 18A chips.
- sct202 2y agoThey have to be able to mass produce on that node for it to save them. Samsung has been claiming technological leadership for that past few years with their 3nm node but nothing has come to market using it. IBM demoed a 2nm test chip in 2021, but has no ability to mass produce.
- JonChesterfield 2y agoThere was lots of talk at the last earnings about "clean sheet redesign" to achieve "world class foundary" and a "world class semiconductor. Sounds like getting the organisation ready to split in two to me. That probably kills the vertical integration that made intel the world leader in the past though.
- BoredPositron 2y agoThey just slept for a decade... I had an overclocked i7 3970k (2012) and there was no need to update for 8 years. The perfomance increase was always marginal. I finally pulled the trigger when AVX happened.
- nikanj 2y agoAnd then you learn AVX is only available on some cores, lowers the operating frequency of the whole cpu when you use it, and generally seems like an unstable prototype
- amiga-workbench 2y agoI was in the same boat with an overclocked 3570K. I only just replaced it last year and grabbed a 5800X3D. I hope this thing lasts me a decade too.
- BadHumans 2y agoWe are coming up on 7 years since the first Ryzen chip. In 7 years AMD went from very behind to a little behind then on-par and finally now market leader. The fact Intel let this happen in such a short time frame is a bit mind boggling.
- layer8 2y agoAMD is not the market leader in any segment, by any approximation: https://www.theregister.com/2024/05/10/amd_gains_on_intel/ https://www.theregister.com/2024/05/10/amd_gains_on_intel/
- BadHumans 2y agoMy phrasing is confusing and I apologize for that. I do not mean market leader in that there are more AMD CPUs than Intel CPU. I'm speaking about hardware performance.
- layer8 2y agoYou are right for multi-core performance, but Intel has still a slight edge in single-core performance, and in idle power usage, which is important to many. Intel also has a stronger offering in the now-popular mini PC segment.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BadHumans 2y agoIf we are mentioning mini PCs then I think it is only fair to mention that every single console went to AMD for chips.
- JonChesterfield 2y agoDidn't they lose the single core lead recently, despite running their chips so aggressively clocked that they're burning out at stock settings? The APU systems from AMD work really well as mini-pc systems, though I'm unfamiliar with Intel products there. Perhaps they're better.
- debatem1 2y agoIntel's main problem is its people. Sorry to say. The management culture there is insanely siloed and toxic, full of scar tissue from previous periods of political turmoil and a few relentless sociopaths who absolutely will not stop climbing just because it's obviously damaging to the company. The engineering culture is full of secrets, moats, and the general sense that while making progress might be your job, stopping it is everyone's job. And there are always more of them than there are of you. Perhaps most fatally, responsibility for decisionmaking is ultimately delegated to the process of decisionmaking rather than the people involved. The resulting proliferation of checkboxes and box checkers have elevated dysfunctions like "the perfect being the enemy of the good" and "none of us is as dumb as all of us" into de facto mottos for large parts of the company. All of this happens against the backdrop of eroding mind and marketshare, a total lack of real product clarity, and a pervasive culture of bullshit that puffs politically convenient non-accomplishments into events worth of companywide applause while spinning, downplaying, or even hiding bad news of calamitous import. Intel has vast reserves of talent but without deep (IMO, impossible) cultural changes it will inevitably fail under its own weight.
- age1mlclg6 2y agoI had to create an account to say that I agree with this comment. I am a former Intel engineer who worked there for 8 years. I left Intel 2 years after the ACT mass layoff in 2016. The culture there is extremely toxic from top to bottom. The VP's and top level executives were out to get stocks and golden parachutes. The middle managers played politics. In addition, they also pulled a blind over leadership on many significant happenings. The engineers / technicians kept secrets as a way of keeping themselves relevant and valuable in case of layoff events. The main and sole money maker for Intel is getting quality silicon out of the door and that should be the number one objective for everyone. However, due to stack ranking, that is getting as many bullet points as possible in order to appear relevant when it comes annual review or mass layoff events, many people come up with bullshit projects that while on the surface look extremely impressive, have nothing relevant to pushing quality silicon out. The middle managers play favorites and push or highlight those bullshit projects. When they fly expensive executives around for the BUM's (Business Update Meetings) or to pitch some bullshit ideas, not many had the courage to ask the relevant questions. The few who asked them were met with canned and non-informative responses that only showed that these expensive suits had no awareness of what was going on externally. At the same time, we were too busy patting ourselves on the back, claiming that we were number one. We were too busy playing political games and competing internally that we forgot about the real external competitions, and then it was too late and they zoomed right past us. I doubt the CEO (past and present) or VP's care or even have an inkling on what has been going on in the culture.
- einpoklum 2y agoI don't know, a lot of these explanations seem more like reading astrological maps in hindsight. Example: > Intel passed on making the System on Chip for Apple’s new iPhone, Instead Apple used an Arm designed processor in an SoC built by Samsung. Too late Intel realised the mistake. Mistake? AMD didn't even try to build SoCs to compete with ARM / Qualcomm / etc. They seem to be doing ok. Now, you could say "Well, throwing 10^10 USD on trying to build an SoC was the mistake" - maybe, but then it's the opposite mistake than the article claims.
- klelatti 2y agoNo it was a both a huge mistake and a symptom of underlying problems. Making smartphone SoCs is a huge profitable market that would have given Intel massive volumes to support R&D etc and slowed TSMC. The fact that they couldn’t manage it with every apparent advantage is very telling.
- talldayo 2y agoFeels like you're rewriting history, to me. Smartphone SoCs are not hugely profitable, and a big point of the past 10 years were Chinese manufacturers entirely ignoring ARM IP to increase profits. The only people that make money off ARM hardware are the export-officiated manufacturers that don't pay per-unit licenses; which is exclusively Apple. Nobody else has a more permissive ARM architecture license, not even Nvidia. Intel at the time was fabless, would have needed to license or design a RISC architecture, and would have ended up just as squeezed as any other part of Apple's supply chain. And if Intel made a serious profit, Apple would have replaced them anyways. It's an all-risk-no-reward scenario.
- talldayo 2y ago> Intel couldn't break into smartphone SoCs with clear process leadership and the financial strength to invest heavily. Why should it be able to break into other competitive markets today when it no longer has those advantages? Maybe because you're looking at it backwards? There must be some conspiracy among Softbank investors to portray everyone that doesn't pay for ARM licenses as a Muppet. Intel has no competitive advantage manufacturing licensed RISC CPUs when their desktop and server markets are hot, and even when x86 dies it will still be less attractive than owning fabs. With how bad the Cortex designs continue to be and how much leeway ARM gives licensees like Apple, even businesses like Qualcomm can't be bothered to take the ISA seriously. It feels disingenuous to say ARM is the panacea when designing ARM cores would have left Intel in an even worse position. Look at Samsung; a company people on this site would describe as misery incarnate, but chances are they're typing their comment from a device using Samsung-fabbed silicon. They're not even that competitive either; they just offer a cheap alternative to TSMC that offers OEMs an economically-minded option for less dense components.
- klelatti 2y ago> It feels disingenuous to say ARM is the panacea when designing ARM cores would have left Intel in an even worse position. Sorry, where does the article say Intel should design Arm cores in 2024?
- scotty79 2y agoI'm buying PCs for myself for three decades and never chose Intel for my build (apart from the Pentium 133 in my first pc computer). Every time I considered it but alternative was just significantly cheaper option at power levels that interested me. The only Intel's I got were in laptops where I was interested only about the price of a whole PC that interested me for other reasons than CPU. Since Internet became a thing I choose CPU by downloading price and benchmark results, drawing price/power chart and choosing a point on a good edge of a point cloud that's not unreasonably expensive. It never happened to be Intel.
- projektfu 2y agoI think referring to bankruptcy is excessive. Intel bulls might be going bankrupt, but the share price doesn't affect most companies unless their only reasonable way to raise money is through the stock market. The Intel bond yields are not too high yet. The question then becomes, is this a low (trading around book value) with recovery in the future, or is it the beginning of a long, dark time, leading to an inability to raise money down the line?
- theparanoid 2y agoIntel's decline was obvious when I worked for them in 2010, their compensation package wasn't competitive with FANG and they consistently missed out or lost their better engineers.
- gumby 2y agoThe "paradox of the x86" is simply the classic Innovator's Dilemma. In fact the history of the last 20 years against ARM could be a case study right out of the book. Worse for Intel, AMD flubbed it time and time again, but now Intel is too weak to defend against a resurgent AMD. Meanwhile they are cutting headcount deeply yet only now suspended the dividend. Madness! They should take a page out of AMD's book and spin off fab. That new company can then be flooded with "strategic" government aid, and maybe the rest of intel can catch up (or not) but it would at least give the shareholders a better chance. Right now the combination is acting like two anchors tied together.
- Wytwwww 2y ago> They should take a page out of AMD's book and spin off fab. It's way too late for that now. But even with the benefit of hindsight if we go back by a few years abandoning their main potential advantage just to compete for limited capacity at TSMC with everyone else wouldn't have been the best decision IMHO.. > flooded with "strategic" government aid, and maybe the rest of intel can catch up (or not) How could that ever possibly help Intel's foundries to catch up if Intel itself switched to TSMC? The "government" doesn't need leading edge nodes so they'd just end up in the same as spots as Global Foundries. To be fair they did outsource their last gen low-power/laptops chips to TSMC which is probably why they now seem very competitive with AMD/Qualcomm.
- gumby 2y agoOne of Intel’s strengths in roughly the 90s and 00s was the tight coupling between its strong fab technology and its strong design team. This this was the model for Motorola, IBM, TI and everybody else. But by now both sides are suffering, and management has to try to fix them both simultaneously. As with other industries, semiconductors evolved as an integrated industry. But now both parts are fiendishly complex, and rather than integration being a strength, it’s more like a conglomerate. You can’t just move your design from one process to another so a spun out fab would start with mostly Intel jobs, just as AMD, IBM etc did when they sold off their fabs. But the standalone fab would possibly find it easier to hire customer-oriented people and change its culture, and the two parts could concentrate better on their needs. It would give the shareholders a better chance too. It’s not a great solution, but the current situation is dire.
- sargun 2y agoI feel like Intel has embarked upon a bunch of good ideas like SDI (https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/manufacturing/software-defined-infrastructure.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/manufacturing/softwa...), IoT / Edison (https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/84572/intel-edison-compute-module-iot.html https://ark.intel.com/content/www/us/en/ark/products/84572/i...), Silicon Photonics (https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/network-io/silicon-photonics.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/details/net...), and SDN (https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/640/intel-to-acquire-fulcrum-microsystems https://www.intc.com/news-events/press-releases/detail/640/i...). But, they manage to fail to capitalize on any of these. What's wrong with them?
- arresin 2y agoAsk them why they sold their ssd division. It’s almost intentionally bad.
- timschmidt 2y agoA new https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xeon_Phi would be killer for AI right about now.
- osigurdson 2y agoI know what to do... a re-org!
- th-miracle-257 2y agoWhen I left Intel, it was already going downhill and this was almost a decade back. Good employees will also see through and make a move and we all know how the negative spiral works. FWIW, my previous comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27597749 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27597749, more than 3 years back. It seems they have hit real rock bottom with no way up!
- diffeomorphism 2y agoThat is very questionable reporting right from the start: - First graph: Yikes, that is going almost all the way to the bottom. Oh, the y-axis is fake. - "Revenue for the quarter was a third lower than in the corresponding quarter three years ago." Wait, wasn't three years ago covid times, which lead to a giant boost in demand for laptops and pcs? https://www.windowscentral.com/canalys-pc-market-2021-report https://www.windowscentral.com/canalys-pc-market-2021-report Maybe the article gets better after that, but that seems not okay.
- nforgerit 2y agoI'll call it the Volkswagen Trap, or more general the ICE one-way street
- sharpshadow 2y agoReading the comments here gives me the impression that Intel is indirectly responsible for the Taiwan conflict. If they would have done their job better they would be on TSMC level now and that inside USA.
- immibis 2y agoWithout TSMC, the west would have no interest in defending Taiwan so it would have already been invaded by West Taiwan.
- deskr 2y ago> Intel passed on making the System on Chip for Apple’s new iPhone Is "passed on" the right term? I seem to remember reading that Intel quoted an extortionate price for making the chips, hence Apple passed on the offer.
- dev1ycan 2y agoI called a while ago this on copium filled people, probably intel employees, about their 1.4 "process" and how they'd surpass TSMC, like buddy, come on, you guys got stuck for 10 years in 14nm, the manufacturing issues nowadays are a showing that Intel is incapable of competing with leading manufacturing companies in the world, they are just too error prone, their GPU business is failing hard because of significant delays, and I don't see a way out, and they are stuck on x86 when ARM is gaining ground. They have become more of a political tool of a company to receive subsidies like Boeing than a real actual competitor to TSMC
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIntel is simply a product of winner take all capitalism when economies of scale are allowed to reign completely. TSMC took all the business at low margin and became so massive that R&D costs were manageable.
- Mindey 2y agoIs Intel poaching TSMC senior engineers in Arizona ( https://tinyurl.com/duvfkrm2 https://tinyurl.com/duvfkrm2 ) related? Cause, I would be really pissed off, if I we'd agreed to build a factory in foreign land out of desire to build good long-term relationships, and then, that country's strategically important corporation would decide take away our key engineers. What's normalized in context of free opportunistic market can be seen as treacherous in context of politics and in the behaviors of strategically important enterprises of countries.