5 ms·
I believe death is a nuisance. I am tired of burying people I love. I already miss the time I won’t spend with my family after I die - with love comes loss, bec
by rbanffy 2y ago
I believe death is a nuisance. I am tired of burying people I love. I already miss the time I won’t spend with my family after I die - with love comes loss, because we know death is unavoidable. Between my wife and I we kind of agree that the one who goes first is the lucky one.
Would I enjoy 10 trillion years of life? I don’t know. My human mind has limits about how much information it can hold. Will I by then have forgotten my first love? Will I forget holding my first child? Will I have forgotten cuddling up in my mom’s lap? Will I miss having forgotten these things? If I can still remember all those moments, so long in the past, will I still be human in any sense?
- VeninVidiaVicii 2y agoYou’re way more likely to stop making any new memories.
- rbanffy 2y agoThen it’d be eternal dementia, a fate probably much worse than death.
- kiba 2y agoWe already forget people, places, events, and things even as young adults.
- cannonpr 2y agoI don’t think you have any evidence to say that. Our understanding of memory and complex evolved neural networks like the mind is fairly poor. On top of that, we have more evidence of the mind still acquiring new memories and choosing to compact or drop irrelevant memories while it remains healthy.
- otikik 2y agoYou must have a very good memory, then. I was made painfully aware of how not great mine was yesterday. I met this woman through my wife. It turns out I already met this person 5 years ago, because we share a common friend. She remembered me quite clearly, but I had completely forgotten her, as well as the event where we met. So far all good, it was 5 years ago after all. However, she also told me that we had met before that! 20 years ago! Through a work acquaintance of mine this time. We apparently did some hiking through the countryside together. I remember nothing of that. I don't remember that second acquaintance either. Apparently it was the same situation 5 years ago; she told me all of this, I apologized for forgetting her and everything around meeting her. And then I forgot her. And that was only the first time. To me my memory is not a "bucket that eventually gets full". It's more like a "dark corridor". Memories are on the walls. As I move forwards, the parts of the corridor behind me get eventually darker, until only the brightest memories remain visible. I have forgotten most of my highschool classmates. I have forgotten most of my past coworkers. I have some memories from my childhood, still. But only the very bright ones. And they are continuously dimming. I am completely fine with this. I am still me. I think forgetting is part of what makes us human. Or at least, of what makes me human. Going back to this person that I forgot twice. Apparently she remembers everyone she has ever met, even if just once. I have met at least another person with this capacity. I can't but consider those people freaks of nature, and in consequence a potential danger for society. We should watch them closely. And perhaps we should watch you closely as well. At least until I forget all of you again. I have no doubt in my mind that my memory will never "fill up". More like the opposite: the danger is that it empties too fast at some point.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rstoien34 2y ago[flagged]
- Filligree 2y agoThere’s no possible way you will live ten trillion years without the human brain becoming well-understood and upgradable. So you’re worrying about an impossible scenario.
- hamhock666 2y agoYou never know, he could be visited by an alien that gives him the power of immortality, we don’t know what’s out there
- makingstuffs 2y agoHe would need to find a new solar system as well
- afpx 2y agoAssuming science and tech improve exponentially, why wouldn't this happen within a century? Unless phenomenon appear that violate our understandings of physics, neuroscience seems on track. If Musk (or others) can get adoption of even simple consumer devices, it's going to be an arms race.
- crystal_revenge 2y ago> Assuming science and tech improve exponentially That's a pretty big assumption to make. Science and tech seem to improve as a direct function of energy available, and in the past few centuries that has been increasing very rapidly (I'm not sure I'd say exponentially though). However we're clearly hitting limits both in regard to human more energy we can harvest as rapidly and the consequences of unsustainable energy usage.
- rbanffy 2y ago> upgradable How human would I be then?
- Filligree 2y agoIdeally? As human as you want, whatever that may mean. Not as human as you're forced to be, or as inhuman as the economy or social forces push you to be... There are many and varied problems we'll be facing. I just don't think "Immortality without any of the supporting technologies" is one of them.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoWhat is missing in this discussion is the notion of finality or end, or telos. Without having a sound philosophical anthropology, we cannot hope to assess the question of death. (Indeed, bad anthropology is at the heart of so many bad political orders. If you misunderstand the nature of Man, then the political order will be pitted against human beings in some manner, by design if not by intention. In the US, the self-interested, hyperindividualistic consumer anthropology construes human beings as selfish beasts whose highest aim in life is to consume, a degradation of the self and a degraded view of others as others become objects for consumption. Communism and socialism suffer from their own grave errors, but an eerie overlap exists between the two.) So we must first know what it means to be human, which is to say, what the actualization of human nature consists of, actualization as the satisfaction and raison d'etre of human activity. It is the nature of a thing to seek to realize itself, to become fully the kind of thing it is. This does not necessarily involve conscious, purposeful act. Bacteria do the same, and this is by virtue of how they are organized and ordered, as well as their operation in accord with this ordering. For human beings, it is to become fully human, which, again, is the question posed: what is the end of a human being? Only in light of human nature can we determine the meaning of death, whether death is to be understood as an aberration needing a solution, or the natural terminus of human existence. If it is the former, then we might ask what, if anything, could or should be done about it. If the latter, then we must accept it as our natural end against which any resistance is not only misguided, but harmful. To answer this question, we must first recognize that what is most essential and definitive about human beings is that we are rational animals. Our rationality is not some thing tacked on to us, but what it means to be human, and our organization, our substance, everything from the operations of the intellect, our ability to choose between alternatives freely, and our bodies, follows from this fact. Then, we must determine what it most means for human beings as rational animals to attain finality. Classically, the highest good is to know and thus experience union with the Highest Good. But the Highest Good is infinite. Perhaps by human nature a certain finite degree of knowledge of the Highest Good suffices, but if the intellect is by its nature open to expansion by the act of the Highest Good, then it could, indefinitely, spend eternity coming to know increasingly better the Highest Good by first becoming indefinitely expanded. This would be transcendence, this expansion of the human person beyond what is merely given by nature, but which, by nature, is open to expansion by the Highest Good. Of course, we cannot attain this condition ourselves, as we cannot engineer our own transcendence. If we could, we would already be in possession of the cause, and thus it would already be part of our nature and therefore not transcendent (the effect is, after all, virtually in the cause; you cannot give what you do not have). This makes transhumanism a fool's errand, as we can only cripple or deform humanity in our quixotic attempts to lift ourselves by our own bootstraps, unlike medicine, which only restores what is already due by nature, but is for some reason missing and in a state of defect. Assuming this is true, then only eternal life would suffice. Anything less, merely life extension, would not change our fundamental condition, only postpone what was always inevitable. Death would remain an obstacle. But nothing in this world attains this eternal state. As I've said, technology cannot attain this end. Only the Highest Good would have this power, and thus something beyond our power to control and use. Furthermore, there is no one on this planet who can be said to have received this eternal state, at least no one walking among us that we can see. So either this eternal state is possible only after death, which means death is not non-existence but some kind of transition, or it cannot be attained. The first gives reason for at least some hope, the latter is world-weary hopelessness, an absurd condition in which Man is condemned to seek an end he cannot possibly arrive at by any means, but must seek if he is to live.
- gknoy 2y agoWill I forget holding my first child? Will I have forgotten cuddling up in my mom’s lap? Will I miss having forgotten these things? If I can still remember all those moments ... will I still be human in any sense? I've already forgotten most of those things, aside from a few fleeting glimpses. I absolutely miss being able to remember details about things like childhood, middle school, the first months of my kids' lives, the smell of their hair etc. But life is still rewarding, my kids and family bring me endless joy _right now_, and I don't feel any less human. If I were able to live another hundred years, I am sure I'd forget things from my time now, forget even more details about my early life, but would still have plenty of things to keep me interested in continuing to live. There are such an abundance of things I can think of that would be worth spending decades mastering, each of which are less important than my current needs, and which I generally have discarded because "it's too late by now...". Swordfighting, glass blowing, painting, creating music, etc. Imagine being able to find something new and interesting, and being able to devote forty or fifty years to developing a (current) lifetime's level of expertise in it. That sounds like science fiction to me, but if such were possible, I'd pick it every time over not having the opportunity. Will I still be human in any sense? I feel like we would redefine what "human" means to include our new selves. I can't imagine not feeling human, even if it is Very Far from my current conceptualization of humanity.
- robotresearcher 2y ago> Between my wife and I we kind of agree that the one who goes first is the lucky one. My wife died. I get to live on with our children, smell flowers, listen to music, even fall in love again. I’m the lucky one, despite the pain.