20 ms·
Evolution is what has made death mandatory. We'd be living much longer lives if it gave our species an evolutionary advantage. For example, in many species, th
by WalterBright 2y ago
Evolution is what has made death mandatory. We'd be living much longer lives if it gave our species an evolutionary advantage.
For example, in many species, the male dies promptly after mating. Evolution has no further use for him, so his life is forfeit. In fact, survival of the progeny may be advanced by getting rid of the old folks.
The reason people live to be grandparents is grandparents turned out to be useful in ensuring the survival of the grandkids. Beyond that, off to the ice floe.
These ideas are not mine. See "The Red Queen" by Matt Ridley
https://www.amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/0060556579/ https://www.amazon.com/Red-Queen-Evolution-Human-Nature/dp/0... for the various strategies around sex and mortality that evolution has produced.
Nothing says, however, that we cannot tinker with our genes to produce what we want.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Evolution is what has made death mandatory. We'd be living much longer lives if it gave our species an evolutionary advantage. Thermodynamics makes death mandatory. Evolution set the timer to 100 to 120.
- WalterBright 2y agoWe all know about the heat death of the universe. It is irrelevant to this discussion, however. May I suggest taking a look at "The Red Queen". I'd be surprised if you were disappointed in it.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> It is irrelevant to this discussion My point is there is a dial. We have to die. But we don't have to die when and in the manner that we do. > May I suggest taking a look at "The Red Queen" Ordered. Thank you!
- WalterBright 2y ago> But we don't have to die when and in the manner that we do. I believe I made that point with: "Nothing says, however, that we cannot tinker with our genes to produce what we want." > Thank you! Welcs. It's a fun read, and makes you think differently about life.
- vlovich123 2y agofor humans today. Other animals live much much longer (centuries) and arguably there are species that even could be “immortal”.
- adastra22 2y agoThis is not true. First of all, our cosmological models are constantly being updated. There are a ton of unknowns here and we cannot be certain in the heat death outcome. Second, even if the canonical heat death model is right, the minimum required energy usage to sustain thought / simulation will go down as the CMB redshifts to zero temperature. It is unclear at this time which factor decays faster: available energy or cost per compute. Effective lifetime may be unbounded.
- lucianbr 2y ago> Evolution has no further use for him, so his life is forfeit. In fact, survival of the progeny may be advanced by getting rid of the old folks. I think this shows that in species where the male does not die promptly after mating, there is good reason to live longer. > Beyond that, off to the ice floe. Where does the certainty come that you cannot be useful in ensuring the survival of your great-grandkids, or great-great-grandkids? After all, if you're arguing from what evolution mandates, the only thing to do is let everyone do whatever, and see where evolution goes next. You really can't think evolution had the current situation as its target all along, and now the only remaining thing is to not disturb it.
- WalterBright 2y ago> You really can't think evolution had the current situation as its target all along That's not the point. Evolution does not have a target. Evolution favors the propagation of genes. Anything that does a better job of that gets expressed into the next generation. > Where does the certainty come that you cannot be useful in ensuring the survival of your great-grandkids, or great-great-grandkids? I never said certainty. The notion of diminishing returns comes to mind. Also, the percentage of great-great-grandkids genes that are yours would be about 8%, so not a lot of contribution.
- shiroiushi 2y agoAlso, there's very likely big downsides to any adaptations for longer life, such as increased cancer rates, which might make it evolutionarily disadvantageous for humans to live that long. Of course, evolution of humans was all done before humans invented technology and things like hospitals and bandages and antibiotics, so what yielded the best chances for propagating genes 100,000 years ago might not make too much sense to humans today.
- heavenlyblue 2y agoI don't understand, would you rather die earlier than have cancer?
- yieldcrv 2y agoThere is no reason behind evolution, attributing any outcome to an evolutionary benefit is complete folly. Literally the only answer to an evolutionary outcome is that a mutant nutted in a bunch of people. Everything after that is also happenstance. If we are to accept that societies with grandparents propagated some genes better, then we have to do the same about cancer, as if its not a complete random fuckup that we have short telomeres or whatever else. When a different explanation fits the model better: cancer tends to occur after reproductive years and therefore wasnt weeded out of the population by evolution, which would apply to people that live long enough to be grandparents too.
- WalterBright 2y agoIt's no different from water behind a dam that pushes against a weakness, and the trickle through it enlarges the hole and the water then tears the dam apart. There is no sentience or reason behind it, but that's what happens. Life doesn't have a goal, but life that survives and propagates becomes the only life there is. Life also evolves into local optimums that are dead-ends. Sentience has helped humans propagate their genes, but mosquitoes are even more successful.
- thriftwy 2y agoEvolution at the moment tremendously favors these who can bear children late in their lives. That implies being in full health longer as well. That would surely manifest in a few generations, sans some big civilization collapse. Or artificial uterus, for sure.
- WalterBright 2y agoDoes it? The odds of birth defects and disorders increase steadily with age.
- thriftwy 2y agoThose for whom these odds increase faster are at huge disadvantage whereas those for whom it increases slower are at huge advantage. As you can imagine it is variative. Of course I should have said "those who can bear healthy children late in their lives".
- komali2 2y agoI feel like this ascribes too much purpose to evolution. I don't know if I agree - for example, males might live longer even if it's not selected for, so long as their existence doesn't exert negative pressure. And they might anyway so long as propagation continues either way!
- WalterBright 2y agoIt ascribes no purpose to evolution. It's simply that an organism that creates more copies of themselves will replace organisms that fail to do so.