87 ms·
Is it just me, or should we be way more horrified by the fact that the US dropped atomic bombs on civilians? It would be like Russia dropping two bombs in Kyiv
by stavros 2y ago
Is it just me, or should we be way more horrified by the fact that the US dropped atomic bombs on civilians? It would be like Russia dropping two bombs in Kyiv today, which is unthinkable, but it feels the US bombing of Japan is kind of shrugged off.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> should we be way more horrified by the fact that the US dropped atomic bombs on civilians? Not really. Strategic bombing, as a concept, was about killing civilians. The idea that you should try not to kill civilians in war was still an evolving concept around WWII, in part because precision munitions and industrial warmaking were in their infancy and toddlerhood, respectively.
- stavros 2y agoThat's an interesting perspective, thanks.
- markovs_gun 2y agoIt was also a response to the horrors of world war 1, where armies faced each other in open fields and the conflict dragged on for years without lines changing much. The reasoning was that ending the war quickly by completely destroying the enemy's capacity and will to continue fighting was better than letting it drag on and become a meat grinder, even if that meant bombing civilians and civilian industry. Obviously this didn't work since WWII was both longer and more deadly than WWI but that was the thinking.
- defrost 2y agoWe should be as exactly horrified as we are by the fact the US dropped convential high explosives and incendaries on civilians. The firebombing of Tokyo had similar death and injury stats to the atomic bombing of Hiroshima, and there were another 72 cities in Japan completely destroyed by bombing prior to the atomic weapons being rushed into use before the war ended. Cities in Europe were also bombed, and later more tonnage was dropped by the US in SE Asia than they dropped in WWII .. many of those mines dropped remain to this day, still killing and maiming children.
- stavros 2y agoWell, I am exactly as horrified by that as by the atomic bomb.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoWe can probably agree that war itself is horrific.
- _aavaa_ 2y ago> We should be as exactly horrified as we are by the fact the US dropped convential high explosives and incendaries on civilians. Not exactly. Having firebombs at our disposal does not require the head of one country to have unaccountable power over the lives of everyone on earth. Firebombs do not require entire industries shrouded in secrecy, nor the transformation of security clearance, or lack there of, into a weapon for shutting down public inquiry and challenges, nor the creation of parallel government structure both invisible and unaccountable to the public. The effects on the cities may not be that different, but nuke's unmitigated corruption of the democratic system is certainly horrifying.
- jklinger410 2y ago> We should be as exactly horrified as we are by the fact the US dropped convential high explosives and incendaries on civilians. And we should be exactly as horrified for what the Japanese did to mainland China. Or the fact that they allied themselves with one of the greatest genocides in history. We should be exactly as horrified at what the alternative was, which was hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of casualties that would have been caused by a conventional invasion just to get that country to stop doing what it was doing.
- krapp 2y agoThe atomic bombing of Japan didn't happen today, it happened nearly 80 years ago. Plenty of people consider it a war crime to this day, and plenty of people excuse it, but it's difficult to be horrified by events old enough to barely exist within living memory.
- pb060 2y ago80 years are not so far in time for me as I recently realized that when I was born I was closer to the end of the war than my current age. That made me feel somehow more connected to that past event than to the present.
- codewench 2y agoObviously looking at it from today's perspective it's (hopefully) unthinkable, but there is a lot written from contemporary sources which make a fairly persuasive argument. The main concerns were that the Japanese government was simply not in a place where it could surrender, which meant a ground invasion of the Japanese mainland was seen as mandatory. Given the prior experiences of how dedicated Japanese defenders could be (eg Mount Suribachi), it was assumed that any actual attempt to take the Japanese mainland would result in untold deaths, to the point where the US has enough Purple Heart medals created (in anticipation of the casualties am invasion would involve) that they didn't have to restart production until 2008. As horrifying as it is, the first atomic bomb was considered the lesser evil. That said, Nagasaki is much much harder to defend. Unrelated, but I recommend everyone who can to visit Hiroshima and visit the museums there. Hopefully it will instill in everyone a fervent desire to never again see such horrific things enacted again.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- startupsfail 2y agoIt is a bit surprising that so much damage was inflicted on civilians with firebombing and all for the sake of what looks like vindictiveness. Surely after the victory it would have been possible to write the books, stating it was « unconditional surrender » regardless of what kind of surrender it actually was (it is victors who tend to be able to write history books as they see fit.)
- mc32 2y agoDon't worry, the Japanese are pretty good at writing their own history too.
- throw0101d 2y ago> That said, Nagasaki is much much harder to defend. The first bomb was dropped August 6. The Japanese War Cabinet met on August 9 to discuss the situation, and concluded that the US didn't have the resources for more, so they concluded to not surrender. Even after the first bomb was dropped. In the middle of the meeting they learned of the second bomb which was dropped that morning. After the second bomb the War Cabinet was split 3-3. They called in the full cabinet and that was split as well. Two bombs weren't enough to decisively convince them to surrender, and so the Emperor had to be called in to break the deadlock. And yet we are to believe that even though two bombs were barely enough to force a surrender, zero bombs would have sufficed?
- derekmhewitt 2y agoI highly recommend the book 'Flyboys' by James Bradley (also the author of Flags of our Fathers) for help putting this period of WWII into context. A good portion of the end of the book discusses the firebombing of Japan and the dropping of the two nuclear bombs, and how that was rationalized as acceptable in the minds of those who participated.
- coin 2y agoKyiv isn’t the aggressor
- throw0101d 2y ago> Is it just me, or should we be way more horrified by the fact that the US dropped atomic bombs on civilians? What was the alternative? The Japanese leadership knew for a year from their own internal reports that they couldn't win the war, and simply want to grind down US resolve. Imperial Japan wanted the following conditions: * Emperor stays on throne * Japan gets to keep territory * any allegation of (e.g.) war crimes would be dealt with internally by the Japanese themselves Would it be okay for Nazi Germany to surrender if: * Hitler and the Nazis got to stay in government * Germany got to keep Czechoslovakia, Poland, etc * war crime allegations would be dealt by the Nazis themselves The first bomb was dropped on August 6. The Japanese War Cabinet held a meeting on August 9 to discuss the situation, and decided not to surrender as they didn't think the US could create more bombs. So even after the first bomb was dropped, they wouldn't surrender. In the middle of the meeting they learned of the second bomb, which was dropped that morning. The War Cabinet was split 3-3 on whether to surrender. After the second bomb. They called in the full cabinet to discuss things. The full cabinet was split. After the second bomb. They called in the Emperor at that point, and he said to end the war. Though in his announcement that was broadcast over the radio, the word "surrender" was never used: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hirohito_surrender_broadcast#Content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hirohito_surrender_broadcast#C... Seriously: what was the alternative? Invade the main islands (Operation Downfall)? What would have been the US casualties? What would have been the Japanese civilian casualties? Or blockade Japan and starve them?
- defrost 2y agoYou are dot point framing a complex piece of history that has a wide spread of opinion from various historians. It deserves at least an essay on just the situation and the various PoV's, see: The Decision to Use the Bomb: A Consensus View? https://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/03/08/the-decision-to-use-the-bomb-a-consensus-view/ https://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2013/03/08/the-decision-to-u... There's a very good case to be made that the primary motivation to use the atomic weapons was the fact that they existed .. developed at very great expense for a European War that no longer existed, Germany having surrended when the weapons were finally complete - with only one test on a tower in a desert the military side wanted a real world 'battlefield' test and there was already an ongoing campaign to destroy each and every major and minor target in Japan (much much cheaper per city) using conventional HE & firebombs.
- TacticalCoder 2y ago> Is it just me, or should we be way more horrified by the fact that the US dropped atomic bombs on civilians? First Japan was allied with nazi Germany. And nazi Germany was putting jews, handicapped people, romanians, gays, etc. into crematoriums, alive. These weren't soldiers either. Second Japan did the Pearl Harbor attack: up until then the US was still a neutral country in WWII. There were many ways to not get at war in the US. Those two weren't among them. What was the US supposed to do? Not drop the bomb and let Russia annihilate and conquer Japan? These two atomic bombs were horrible but during WWII the US pretty much single handedly saved (most of) the world from both nazism and stalinism. I'm not saying the US have always been acting in good faith lately but during WWII I'm not sure the US can be faulted much. Put it another way: a world war vs fucking evil incarnate is messy.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoNot a lot of nuance in your view of the U.S. role in WWII. For example, your point: > Japan did the Pearl Harbor attack: up until then the US was still a neutral country in WWII. The U.S. Export Control Act (July 1940), freezing of Japanese assets (July 1941) and then the oil embargo (August 1941) are examples of some of the nuance I see.
- ThrowawayR2 2y agoThe US did those things in response to Imperial Japan's invasion, occupation, and looting of other Asian nations. No nuance is needed; Japan was the aggressor pure and simple. Nobody would ever defend the Nazis as victims yet people come out of the woodwork to defend Imperial Japan, their brutal attempt at colonialism, and the equivalent holocaust they committed. As I've said before, the Japanese sure got good marketing after the war.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoWho's defending Imperial Japan? Nuance just means recognizing that actors on both sides were participants in the build up. I dislike the wholesale excusing of one sides actions because the other side was worse. Given that Imperial Japan was so awful I'm wondering how far you would allow the U.S. to go? How about if the U.S. rounded up all Japanese Americans and put them in camps? Also completely okay, I guess, because Imperial Japan.
- JKCalhoun 2y agoIt is horrific. I somewhat purge my feelings of guilt (I was born in the U.S.) by believing they "did not know what they were doing." It's maybe a stretch to compare it to modern Russia bombing Kyiv — because modern atomic weapons are orders of magnitude more horrific.
- retrocryptid 2y agoIt is not unthinkable. That is the problem.
- oneshtein 2y agoUkraine can nuke Moscow as well. Should we?
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoI thought Ukraine gave up all their nukes after the dissolution of the USSR.
- oneshtein 2y agoYes, we gave up everything that can harm USA, including nuclear silos and strategic bombers, in exchange to safety assurances. Is Ukraine safe now?
- pfdietz 2y agoNo one will make that mistake again.
- 05 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine_and_weapons_of_mass_destruction#Debates_about_Ukrainian_renuclearization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukraine_and_weapons_of_mass_de... > However, Mariana Budjeryn, a Ukrainian scholar at Harvard argued that the denuclearization of Ukraine was not a mistake and that it was unclear whether Ukraine would be better off as a nuclear state. She argued that the deterrent value of the nuclear weapons in Ukraine was questionable. While Ukraine had "administrative control" of the weapons delivery systems, it would have needed 12 to 18 months to establish full operational control, and Ukraine would have faced sanctions from the West and likely retaliation from Russia. Moreover, Ukraine had no nuclear weapons program and would have struggled to replace nuclear weapons once their service life expired. Instead, by agreeing to give up the nuclear weapons, Ukraine received financial compensations and the security assurances of the Budapest Memorandum.[29] 12 months seems like a plenty of time for US/Russia to come and take back the nukes.
- UncleSlacky 2y agoThey never had the launch codes anyway.
- _trampeltier 2y agoThe US dropped not just the nuclear bombs on civilians. > The raids that were conducted by the U.S. military on the night of 9–10 March 1945, codenamed Operation Meetinghouse, are the single most destructive bombing raid in human history.[1] 16 square miles (41 km2; 10,000 acres) of central Tokyo was destroyed, leaving an estimated 100,000 civilians dead and over one million homeless.[1] The atomic bombing of Hiroshima in August 1945, by comparison, resulted in the immediate death of an estimated 70,000 to 150,000 people. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo
- a-french-anon 2y agoIn the documentary The Fog of War, former U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara recalls General Curtis LeMay, who relayed the Presidential order to drop nuclear bombs on Japan, said: "If we'd lost the war, we'd all have been prosecuted as war criminals." And I think he's right. He, and I'd say I, were behaving as war criminals. LeMay recognized that what he was doing would be thought immoral if his side had lost. But what makes it immoral if you lose and not immoral if you win? Selden mentions another critique of the nuclear bombing, which he says the U.S. government effectively suppressed for twenty-five years, as worth mention. On 11 August 1945, the Japanese government filed an official protest over the atomic bombing to the U.S. State Department through the Swiss Legation in Tokyo Truth is most people here are hypocrites, might makes right and the end justifies the means, but only for our side! Mind you, I'm no arguing that these obvious truths are wrong, but intellectual honesty shouldn't go to the trash in favour of wishful thinking and posturing.
- pfdietz 2y agoThe final Japanese defense of their home islands would have involved arming every man, woman, and child, for them to act as suicide warriors. "The Glorious Death of the 100 Million" (note the name was an exaggeration of their actual population) This made the entire population a military target (except for very young children, I guess).
- littlestymaar 2y agoIt's still not 100% clear if the nuclear bombing was necessary to force the Japanese to surrender, the Soviet invasion of Manchuria could have been enough, making the civilian casualties in Hiroshima and Nagasaki pointless victims.
- pfdietz 2y agoOf what relevance is that question? Was the US supposed to determine that the use was necessary before it was used? How is that even supposed to be determined, especially in wartime when the inner workings of the enemy are opaque?
- littlestymaar 2y agoHow is that an argument? In all conflicts the inner working of the enemy are someone opaque, why should this lead to assuming that everyone including women and children is a legit military target? That's actually the reasoning of war criminals…
- pfdietz 2y agoThe observation about the militarization of the entire society is a defense against the charge that dropping the bomb was a war crime, even if the decision makers didn't know it at the time. I see you think that even presenting legal arguments in defense against war crime charges is "the reasoning of war criminals". I guess you're not big on the idea of legal defense when charged for a crime. A real fan of justice, aren't you. /s
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- advisedwang 2y agoThe horrifying thing is that the US knew the Japanese wanted to surrender, and knew that demanding abdication of the emperor was both a major impediment, unnecessary and in fact harmful (because it would reduce the number of outposts that would accept the surrender order). The US had broken the codes used with messages to diplomats in the USSR and other traffic and could clearly see the Japanese situation. Despite this they never waivered from ambiguous "unconditional surrender" terminology... likely so they could continue pressing the front in Korea which would also end with a peace. So the US could have had peace earlier, with several hundred thousand less deaths, if they had been willing to put in writing specifically what they actually wanted, and what they got in the end.
- nxm 2y agoWell a surrender (we stop war but current regime stays in power) vs an unconditional surrender is something different. The terms must be agreed on.
- advisedwang 2y agoThe viable alternative would have been demanding a surrender but stating that The Emperor will remain as a constitutional monarch - which is what the US ended up imposing anyway because it was the logical way to forestall resistance from a radicalized population. Such a demand would likely have resulted in a surrender before the atomic bombings.
- otherme123 2y agoWe have records of Japanese high rank military wanting to keep fighting after the dropping of the second bomb. They figured out the USA might have a couple more nukes, so Japan should endure them four and keep fighting. As said in other threads, it was the nukes and the soviets invading what finally forced the surrender.
- keiferski 2y agoThe earliest surrender request wasn't merely just for the emperor to stay in power. Japan also wanted to keep the territories they had acquired and manage all post-war trials of the military in-house. Any American general or politician that agreed to these terms would have been seen as a fool or a coward, especially after Pearl Harbor, Bataan, Singapore, etc.
- 999900000999 2y agoWe heavily debate this and as kid in school I made paper cranes to honor the victims. We don't make Red Envelopes to apologize for Agent Orange.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hnbad 2y agoWhile the horror of the atomic bombings of civilian centers is more obvious in hindsight, it also overshadows what was at least equally horrific at the time: the continuous and deliberate widespread fire bombings of civilian centers. Much of what the US did in Japan would be considered a war crime if it happened nowadays. The Pacific campaign also heavily leveraged existing racist sentiments and explicitly dehumanized Asian people which carried over into the Korean War (where the US did manage to commit more war crimes than either of the two Koreas) and the Vietnam War. This isn't to excuse Japan who to this day refuse to acknowledge the Rape of Nanjing and is orthogonal to the legitimacy of US involvement in the Korean and Vietnamese civil wars (the former of which explicitly contradicted a UN decision and presented a last-ditch effort to avoid an imminent North Korean victory). Japan was the aggressor and did horrible war crimes themselves. But that doesn't mean everything the US did was above the board and it doesn't excuse it. Opinions are still divided on the firebombing of Dresden and even by its most exaggerated retellings it pales in comparison to what happened in Japan. Also what the article doesn't go out of its way to mention but implies: the atomic bombings were part of what led to the Japanese surrender but did not play the critical part Truman would later claim they did (while continously exaggerating the number of American lives saved by it over the years). The Soviet invasion and risk of annexation played a far greater part and surrendering to the US to stop the Soviet advance was preferable to a Soviet annexation that would have at best meant a guaranteed deposition of the Emperor if not an execution. The Japanese Emperor was considered divine. Although the surrender ended up being unconditional the US did not hold him personally responsible and allowed him to remain in a ceremonial function. If there were no off-the-record agreements about this, it was at least a leap of faith with the understanding that the alternative was not an American occupation but guaranteed annexation by the Soviets who were known to not look too kindly on kings, gods or the territorial integrity of Japan (given the Russo-Japanese war preceding WW2). The US wasn't keen on risking the lives of its soldiers by invading the deathtrap that was mainland Japan whereas the Soviets had a reputation (accurate or not) of not fearing meatgrinders.
- themaninthedark 2y ago>This isn't to excuse Japan who to this day refuse to acknowledge the Rape of Nanjing I have often heard that Japan denies or has never apologized for it's actions in China / Korea but there are numerous apologies that have been given. I think this is often repeated to both paint Japanese people as uncaring and also keep divisions between Japanese, Chinese and Korean people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_war_apology_statements_issued_by_Japan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_war_apology_statements... >On August 15, 1995, the fiftieth anniversary of the Surrender of Japan, the Japanese prime minister Tomiichi Murayama gave the first formal apology for Japanese actions during the war.[171] >He offered his apology to all survivors and to the relatives and friends of the victims. That day, the prime minister and the Japanese Emperor Akihito pronounced statements of mourning at Tokyo's Nippon Budokan. Iris Chang, author of The Rape of Nanjing, criticized Murayama for not providing the written apology that had been expected. She said that the people of China "don't believe that an... unequivocal and sincere apology has ever been made by Japan to China" and that a written apology from Japan would send a better message to the international community.[172] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nanjing_Massacre
- croes 2y agoSame with Western drone strikes vs Russian killers