5 ms·
2008 was the year man-made global warming was disproved
- pmjordan 18y agoOh, an article about global warming, let me get my checklist ☑ no useful set of data presented (anecdotal evidence, selection bias) ☑ failure to understand nonlinear, chaotic systems ☑ logical fallacies (we have other issues that have people more worried, so climate change is solved) ☑ sweeping generalisations ☑ a bit of conspiracy theory thrown in for good measure I think I'll pass, and go for a walk outside, where unusually for the season, there is no snow!
- ojbyrne 18y agoIt's a newspaper. Expecting any of those things is misunderstanding what they're about. Though I agree that this article was truly, magnificently, horrendously full of crap. Unfortunately that's what sells newspapers.
- Prrometheus 18y agoI once saw a newspaper website ask readers to email in examples of global warming in their neighborhood. As you can imagine, "I didn't see many squirrels around this year as usual" and other such intelligent commentary topped the list. Way to "educate" the population, mainstream media!
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- Shamiq 18y ago"there is no snow" It was 60 F in Chicago yesterday. That's non-typical for the middle of the winter.
- carbon8 18y agoContext: In Chicago, it was -3 F at the beginning of the week, 38 F (high) the day before yesterday and now it's back to 31 F (current). It also snowed for most of the past week and a half and there was still a thick layer of snow until it melted yesterday. Chicago's weather already has a relatively large swing from season to season, but it also has flukes like yesterday from time to time.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- albertni 18y agoIf you haven't seen how wildly Chicago weather can swing from day to day, you haven't spent enough time in Chicago. There's really no such thing as "non-typical weather" for any specific day in the Windy City.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agotopping off your analytical refutation with an anecdotal quip about climate kinda defeats the theme of your post.
- fallentimes 18y agoIt was a joke.
- gaius 18y agoWhen the data shows a cooling trend since 1998, while we shouldn't be complacent, we should also celebrate that what we're doing is, to the extent that we influence the environment at all, working, and resolve to keep up the good work.
- DanielBMarkham 18y agoIf I understand the counter-argument correctly, when the data shows a day's worth of weather, it's too small to mean anything. When it shows a month's weather, it's still to small to mean anything. When it shows a year, same deal. Now I believe the wisdom is that when the data shows a decade of weather trends, it is also too small to draw conclusions. If the article is true and most of the last decade has canceled out the small increase over the last century, then perhaps the same "wisdom" is true at the century level as well -- 100 years of data for naught. To me this seems a little strange since we only have large-scale climate readings for the last 100 years or so. Past that it's sparse readings, interpolations and projections. The next five years or so will be interesting. If it shows a continued cooling, and if global warming proponents continue to promote their case, I will be curious as to what we mean when we say "climate" -- because I must be missing something.
- DabAsteroid 18y agowe only have large-scale climate readings for the last 100 years or so. Past that it's sparse readings, interpolations and projections. ...And these paintings: . http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maunder_Minimum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maunder_Minimum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age#Depictions_of_winter_in_European_painting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Little_Ice_Age#Depictions_of_wi... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hendrick_Avercamp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hendrick_Avercamp http://images.google.com/images?q=Hendrick+Avercamp http://images.google.com/images?q=Hendrick+Avercamp
- jerf 18y agoThe real thing to be looking at is that if we continue to cool, or even stay steady for a couple of years, we fall off the 95% confidence intervals for the global warming predictions made a few years ago, which all uniformly took the form of lines going straight up (pretty much). That will mean that the models are wrong, and if the models are wrong, the model makers are not entitled to claim that despite the fact they couldn't predict anything, they can still use the broken models to make claims about mankinds contribution to the climate. I can't emphasize the importance of the word "wrong" enough. A wrong model is not sort of correct, it is wrong, and should not be used to determine the fate of trillions of dollars of capital. Further, if climate change can't be demonstrated to be the critical pressing crisis the alarmists claim, then there are other way more important problems facing the environment that need to be addressed, such as the Pacific dead zone and horrible overfishing. If AGW advocates are wrong about the scope of the problem, diverting funds into it anyhow is not a good idea; it is (and I mean this literally) one of the worst ideas ever put forth by mankind. If AGW advocates are wrong, they are not holy, they are the most dangerous threats to the environment in the world today. Trillions of dollars of capital are very important, and if there is any reason to believe the science isn't "settled", it behooves us all to look at the problem with an open mind, not to insist that even though AGW predictions clearly said that the 95% confidence interval doesn't actually encompass what is happening in reality we should still just believe them, despite the scientific evidence that they are (and again I can't emphasize the importance of this word enough) wrong. Making wrong predictions is a big deal in science; only a political mindset can wave that fact away like it's not really a problem.
- speek 18y agoGlobal warming is a terrible term for what's going on in the world. Heck, carbon dioxide isn't even the real culprit for green house gases: it's methane. Methane is a much more potent green house gas, yet we're hearing more about carbon dioxide. There are more cows than there have ever been, because we're eating more of them because there are more of us to eat them. We're going to have the coldest winters and the hottest summers we've had for quite a long time. Yes, we'll have some weird weather mid-season (like now, in northeastern USA its 56 degrees F, 13ish degrees C), but that doesn't change the fact that people are introducing stuff into the atmosphere that shouldn't be there. Global Extreming would probably be a better term for what's going on.
- randallsquared 18y agoI didn't bother with the article, but I'm curious: what temperature circumstances would give you doubts about what's going on? (Not "cause you to disbelieve in 'Global Extreming'" or anything; just make you uncertain that it's well understood).
- dustmop 18y agoWhy do you think Al Gore started using the term "climate change"?
- axod 18y ago"climate change" is ridiculous though. It's not like the climate has been static for millions of years and now suddenly everything is changing. The climate is always changing.
- neilk 18y agoI think that's why you also hear "climate crisis". Still, the relevant people know what it means (whether pro or con). Debating whether they have the right marketing term is supremely pointless.
- jhancock 18y agoSoftware development is always changing, yet we spend great effort managing change. Just because the climate has always been changing does not mean we should not try to understand and manage it better.
- paul9290 18y agoGlobal warming is big business wrapped in a blanket of goodness. Definitely a good business to be in!
- neilk 18y agoAnd what would you call the fossil fuel industry? A mom and pop enterprise? I'm not even sure what this criticism is supposed to be about. Business is omnipresent in Western society. Would you be happier if no businesses were involved? Or would that just make it a government / scientific / European conspiracy?
- paul9290 18y agoActually Im more on the right regarding global warming .... i should have said, "It's big business wrapped in a cloak of goodness!" I mean GreenLand ..well used to be green and now it's covered with ice. Cyclical to me it is, but hey why not create this great movement/cultural change and profit from it! Not that Im against recycling and all that, but the cow methane and other over the top stuff ... please
- GrandMasterBirt 18y agoI paraphrase a critique on google's "submit an idea to make the world a better place"... If you have an idea that could change the world for the better, and implementing that idea takes time and effort, why don't you start a company, develop the idea, help the world, and make a living doing it.
- russell 18y agoMaybe it's all a cycle in the sun's output and in 100 years we'll be burning more coal and feeding our cows beans so they will fart more to prevent an ice age. Meanwhile the prudent course is to assume it's our fault and reduce our carbon footprint.
- newt0311 18y agoNot when that course costs several trillion in lost economic output.
- Anon84 18y agoOr it could be an opportunity to get further and further away from oil and develop a technology that you can later sell to other oil dependent countries.
- jhancock 18y agospending trillions, whether its for cleaner energy, or buying iPhone fart apps, _is_ an economy. Nothing is "lost".
- jonasvp 18y agoWell and concisely put. This is the actually the one fact we should try to get into these people's heads. The only change is in the _distribution_ of wealth. What we should be worried about is not wealth but welfare. And I'm not sure polluting the environment and using up non-renewable resources improves anybody's welfare. Not even that of the people profiting from it.
- dantheman 18y agoYou are incorrect, the distribution of wealth means less money spent on healthcare or drug research, or growing food. If it takes more effort, that effort has to come from somewhere.
- 18y ago
- tokenadult 18y agoOkay, let me try to respond in a different way. Supposing I fully accept the idea that global warming is a genuine phenomenon and that the aggregate of human activities is its main cause, why is it valuable to me to stop it? What benefit do I and similarly situated persons gain from carbon taxes, mandatory sequestration, restrictions on the use of certain technologies, or whatever else is proposed as a means of preventing anthropogenic global warming? Please note that I am not asking "Why would I support reducing global warming if I had magical powers?" but rather, "Given currently foreseeable technology at currently foreseeable costs, are the political and economic arrangements necessary to slow global warming worth as much to humankind as devoting time, effort, and money to solving other pressing problems?"
- mick_m 18y agoThanks for the article, we haven't had any climate change denial for almost two weeks now.