13 ms·
The only way to stop these large criminal enterprises is to legalize the stuff. Just like alcohol prohibition created some of the most notorious American crimin
by guelo 14y ago
The only way to stop these large criminal enterprises is to legalize the stuff. Just like alcohol prohibition created some of the most notorious American criminals, South American drug prohibitions produce powerful criminals down there. There isn't any large crime related to South American cocoa or coffee imports. Legalize it and then spend money and make laws regulating consumption, it would greatly reduce the misery in our corner of the world.
- paulhauggis 14y agoAt this point, I doubt it will help. Why? The cartels thrive in countries where you can essentially buy off any official. When you legalize drugs, they aren't going to suddenly stop selling it. They will now have a legal business which will continue to fund their criminal empires. We most likely will see an increase in other crimes, like extortion and kidnapping. Drugs are still illegal in the US and we don't really see the same kind of crime in our country because the police actually (for the most part) do their job. If you really want to stop the violence, stop the corruption. I know the recreational drug users of HN don't really want to hear this..
- dsrguru 14y agoPeople who have lived in big cities in the U.S. would strongly disagree with you. There are entire areas that are dangerous to walk in thanks to drug gangs. Legalize the stuff and dealers can't continue forcing out the competition with guns, since that competition will be the local supermarket.
- vlisivka 14y agoAlcohol is already legal, so why gangs are not gone?
- vlisivka 14y ago:-)
- vlisivka 14y ago:-))))
- blazingice 14y agoIt looks like you're being downvoted, so I'll provide a reason. Alcohol is legal. The gangs that formed around producing, smuggling, and selling alcohol (e.g. Capone) are gone. The hope is that once other drugs are legal, the same thing happens to their producers.
- vlisivka 14y agoSo if everything illegal will be legal, like in America before USA, then all gangs will gone?
- vlisivka 14y ago:-)
- bmelton 14y agoOf note, since I was curious as to the answer myself and just found out, there are still 'gangs' (though less the urban variety we're used to seeing) based around moonshining. That prompted me to ask "why is moonshining illegal", and the best (wrong) answer I could come up with was for production and delivery to dry counties. Turns out, it's just a matter of taxation. Moonshiners are welcome to go legit, but they then have to pay $2.14 for each 750ml bottle they make, which cuts into profitability. As they likely don't have reputations and/or massive marketing budgets, they still and distribute illegally, which turns it into a pure profit + overhead scenario.
- MattRogish 14y agoThat's an interesting point that I've never considered (or heard mentioned in the legalize argument). I'm for legalization + taxation of all drugs but will we still see significant folks producing and selling illegally as a tax dodge? May legalization merely get drugs into more hands but still maintain significant illegal production? If so, a lot of the supposed benefits of legalization dry up.
- Androsynth 14y ago
- larrys 14y ago"I know the recreational drug users of HN don't really want to hear this" They are of course part of the problem.
- elorant 14y agoLegalizing drugs means that the street price will drop by 90% and that will eventually make drug trafficking obsolete. This of course doesn't solve the real problem which is consumption.
- vlisivka 14y agoMeth is very cheap already. Any changes?
- mrtron 14y agoFrom what I understand meth is produced really poorly by regional producers. I think it would end up more expensive at your local pharmacy if legalized. The benefit would be you know you won't lose your teeth from the odd chemicals the producer is using. (I could be horribly off on the details)
- refurb 14y agoYou are horribly off. Methamphetamine is currently available at your local pharmacy. It's a generic drugs and costs less than a $1 per dose. You don't lose your teeth from meth because of chemicals used in it's production, you lose them due to a combination of poor oral hygiene and reduced saliva production. The same thing happens if you abuse the stuff you can get at the pharmacy.
- elorant 14y agoNo because Meth can't create huge profits for drug cartels. Street price is too low when compared to heavy drugs. And it's the money that makes cartels invincible.
- dllthomas 14y ago> This of course doesn't solve the real problem which is consumption. I object to your use of the definite article here. We can argue about the degree to which consumption is a problem vs. it leading to problems, moderate use, what particular drugs, etc... but making the police into the enemy of a large swath of our population is itself a real problem, gang violence to control distribution territory is itself a real problem, etc. If people are doing things that hurt themselves that's bad, but it's important we don't cause worse problems (for those people or the rest of us) in trying to stop it, and legalization frees up huge resources that we could put toward educating people about the dangers of various drugs and cleaning up the mess when they don't listen.
- revelation 14y agoCorruption is a tradeoff. Is the risk to lose your safe job and possibly land in jail worth the money? So you need money to corrupt officials on a large scale, a lot of money. Obviously that kind of money is no problem if your profit margin is 80%. Legalizing drugs (hence introducing highly industrialized competition) and helping those who are truly addicted tends to quickly kill that margin. I'm not saying legalization is the golden bullet; obviously you will have to do a lot more to reverse the damage done by millions in prison, impoverished, killed, or corrupted in the government apparatus. But its the starting point to stopping the cancer from expanding.
- jlmendezbonini 14y ago>Drugs are still illegal in the US and we don't really see >the same kind of crime in our country because the police >actually (for the most part) do their job. I strongly disagree with your statement. Police? Mexico is not using your usual police officers to fight drug violence neither Colombia. They are using highly trained military forces. Why? Cartels have very advance military equipment that is, sometimes, even purchased directly from the U.S. government as stated by one of the captured Zetas cartel heads (http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/jul/7/inquiry-of-weapons-smuggling-to-expand/ http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2011/jul/7/inquiry-of-we...). One of the main reasons the U.S. doesn't have the amount drug related crimes that countries like Mexico do is because it's their primary market (in the case of Mexican cartels) so they, obviously, don't want to create that much problems there and mess up their business. This is not about pointing fingers or saying that the police is useless but as someone who was unlucky enough to witness hitman executed individuals (in front of my house) but lucky enough to _not see anything_ useful for the police I have to tell you that is not about an effective police force. The production, distribution, violence, money laundering, and all the other problems that revolve around drugs are shared between: consumers, criminals, and corrupt individuals (private, government, and public service sectors). My point is that this very complicated problem has only gotten worse since the "War on Drugs" started so legalizing drugs to have some regulation could be an alternative.
- objclxt 14y ago"Police? Mexico is not using your usual police officers to fight drug violence neither Colombia. They are using highly trained military forces. Why? Cartels have very advance military equipment" If you read the article, you'd see the reason Colombia and Mexico use the military is mainly because the cartels own the police. Virtually ever person has been bribed. That's the core problem here.
- Uhhrrr 14y ago...and if US users can grow their own, legally, in their backyards, then that bribery money goes away.
- adventureful 14y ago
- mwd_ 14y agoCartels wouldn't have a business selling something like marijuana post-legalization. Just about anybody can grow it almost anywhere so its natural market value is extremely low. I doubt there are a lot of gangs financing their criminal activity off of potato sales or whatever. Extortion and kidnapping must be way less pleasant and much more difficult than dealing drugs. It's very hard to believe that they could scale up to be the same sort of revenue source. As for the US and its supposed success, sure, it's better off than Honduras, but it still spends a fortune on law enforcement and has a massive prison population. I don't want to think of how many lives have been ruined over needless drug-related convictions. US demand and money are also what's fuelling a lot of the violence in Latin America.
- Osiris 14y agoI disagree. I think the cartels or some large agro businesses would set up huge farms just like tobacco farms. I'm fairly certain it's perfectly legal to grow tobacco in your backyard, but no on does because it's so much cheaper and easier to buy it from a farm. So those people with expertise in growing it would continue to do so but out in the open in huge farms and profits would plummet to near at-cost production levels as they compete with similar large farms.
- earl 14y agoIf you read the article, it points out that the price premium is for all the risk various actors bear in the cocaine supply chain. If you derisk it, you kill most of the profits and suddenly the cartels will have to compete with industrialized agriculture. This will not do wonders for the cartels' profits, and once the profits disappear, the ability to pay enormous bribes follows. Also, without making any judgement about whether people should or should not do certain things, banning private, consensual transactions rarely works well or inexpensively. My politics do not trend libertarian, but this is a well established fact at this point, whether it's prostitution, drug use, etc.
- mrbgty 14y agoWhy would the largest consumer (US) purchase drugs from the drug cartels if it were legal in the US and could be sold at every 7-11? The drug cartels would lose a lot of the revenue which makes them powerful.
- vlisivka 14y agoWhy you are worrying about revenues of cartels? If you think that selling drugs is legal, then their business is equally legal to business of Apple or Microsoft. Why you are not worrying about revenues of Microsoft or Apple?
- angli 14y agoBecause Apple and Microsoft aren't using their revenues to kill thousands of people. If cutting off their revenues diminishes their ability to do that, it'd be irresponsible of us not to worry about it, or at least consider it
- vlisivka 14y agoSo why worry about revenues when we need to worry about human lives? Legalization of drugs will kills millions but will save thousands. Nice deal?
- laughinghan 14y agoBecause Microsoft and Apple's retail employees don't do drive-by shootings of each other's storefronts. No one here is claiming that selling drugs is legal. Some of us think that selling drugs should become legal, in the hopes that businesses that are like Microsoft and Apple, i.e., don't assassinate judges, etc, will outcompete the cartels and decrease the cartel's revenues, hence decreasing their ability and participation in such undesirable activities.
- giardini 14y ago"When you legalize drugs, they aren't going to suddenly stop selling it. They will now have a legal business which will continue to fund their criminal empires. We most likely will see an increase in other crimes, like extortion and kidnapping." No. Once a drug is legalized, supply can go up and price plummets. What was once a "criminal empire" now has the cash flow of a 7-11. And because price plummets, addicts no longer need to crawl in your bedroom window to steal money/goods to buy drugs. Crime drops. Drug-related extortion and kidnapping would virtually disappear.
- dsrguru 14y agoWhile that would reduce violent crime, it would also sanction people using recreational drugs besides alcohol, tobacco, and caffeine. Many voters and politicians find it against their religious or moral beliefs to allow other people to do recreational drugs besides the ones they themselves are doing.
- AJ007 14y agoArguably it would take time for the violent crime to subside. A culture of violence does not vanish over night, but rather over generations. My prediction is Mexico's violent crime spilling over to the US resulting in a drug war surge (both already happening to some degree.) In the background, regulators slowly loosen up laws as to not lose face (would explain the toleration of medical marijuana.) I can only imagine that from the outside American appear completely crazy. Regulators and lobbyists write the laws, bankers and the wealthy fund the enforcement, and then both parties consume them in obscene quantities. The exporting country pays the price in blood and corruption. From my perspective as an American, that's not crazy, that's evil.
- sstrudeau 14y agoHomicide and other violent crime rates tracked pretty tightly to the creation (and eventual repeal) of alcohol prohibition laws in the US. Homicide rates dropped dramatically immediately after prohibitions repeal. We likely wouldn't need to wait "generations" to see a benefit. One reference for prohibition homicide data: http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/alcohol-prohibition-was-failure http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/alcohol-pro...
- evoxed 14y agoStill, we should anticipate some delay before decay. Otherwise it could cause cold feet, leading to a pretty strong backlash.
- Osiris 14y agoOne of the articles points is that violence is used because there are no other means to settle disputes. In a legal atmosphere, the legal system could be used instead of violence. In additional, legalization would cause prices to crash because the risk would drop significantly. Even so, in a legal environment there would still be a black market because regulations would still impose restrictions, but it would be more like teenagers paying homeless guys to buy beer and cigarettes.
- vibrunazo 14y agoThey make most of their money from cocaine and methamphetamine (which can be legally acquired, but that didn't stop traffic). 90% of all cocaine in the US come from mexico. [1] Do you mean cocaine should be legalized? Alcohol is a bad analogy to legalizing cocaine, you should probably be comparing to the Opium Wars instead, which didn't really end well. [2] [1] http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34215.pdf http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL34215.pdf [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opium_Wars
- debacle 14y agoWhy isn't cocaine legalized? Honest question - I've never done it nor have a I done a ton of research.
- mrtron 14y agoShould any substance be illegal? If we start banning substances rationally, wouldn't cigarettes top the list.
- astrodust 14y agoCigarettes, while harmful, don't result in instant death. Banning cigarettes would result in the same problem banning other drugs has created. The only things that should be "banned" are those that are so intrinsically harmful they cause severe, immediate, measurable harm to both the abuser and society. There aren't many drugs that people consume that qualify for this standard since to be able to continuously abuse something it can't kill you the first try.
- jlarocco 14y agoI'm in favor of drug legalization, but it's not going to happen any time soon, and I don't think it would reduce crime even if it did It's hard enough to get pot legalized in most states - the "harder" drugs don't stand a chance. And even if they were legalized, it's not even possible for a big illegal drug operation to "go legit". All of the drug cartels will still have long histories of violence, piles of cash, boatloads of weapons, and a ton of smuggling expertise. They'll probably just "pivot" to smuggling the next most profitable thing. Or smuggle untaxed and unregulated drugs.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoPeople stop giving huge wads of money to violent criminals. Drug users stop being legal pariahs and are able to be a part of the criminal justice system other than as just a defendant. The courts stop being crammed full of drug users. Police departments stop being preoccupied by "dope on the table" drug busts and concentrate on things like homicide and violent crimes. No, gangs aren't going to go away, but they will be reduced in capability and law enforcement will be far more effective. Crime will go down. Not instantly, but over a fairly short amount of time.
- dllthomas 14y agoIt would be hard to accomplish, yes. With regards to effect, though, I'm sure it wouldn't magically fix everything. It would, however, mean that the cartels would face competition without the overhead of smuggling, which would drop the profit available substantially. They might well move on to smuggling the next most profitable thing, but obviously the next most profitable thing is not as profitable. The power and wealth of the cartels would thus not be growing as fast as it is, which is a much better situation long-run.
- flatline 14y agoI'm reasonably sure that suitable mechanism design could be performed to make full legalization not only possible but much more desirable than the current scenario. It would require extensive reworking of legal and economic regulations and public policy. The first hurdle is legitimizing this type of research. From casual reading on the subject, I haven't seen any serious research like this in regards to the US, though admittedly I haven't looked very hard, but for obvious reasons the public coffers are not exactly overflowing to fund serious investigation into the matter.
- kia 14y agoThe big difference of drugs from alcohol and tobacco is their addictiveness. While you can't get addicted to alcohol or tobacco after one use, certain drugs cause severe addiction after first dose. Of course you can legalize only mild drugs. But it won't solve the problem because as we see this business is mostly about very addictive ones. EDIT: typo
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe key problem with your argument is the idea that we can reduce drug use by making it illegal. That fact isn't born out by reality.
- Mizza 14y ago[citation needed]
- ojbyrne 14y ago"Scientists have found, for instance, that nicotine is as addictive as heroin, cocaine or amphetamines..." http://www.nytimes.com/1987/03/29/magazine/nicotine-harder-to-kickthan-heroin.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm http://www.nytimes.com/1987/03/29/magazine/nicotine-harder-t...
- vlisivka 14y agoFood and water are even more addictive than nicotine. Drugs are changing your brain by altering it rewarding system.
- jimmar 14y agoI don't think drug legalization is the final answer the problem of cartels. Like the article says, '“The goal of these folks is not to sell drugs,” Tony Placido, who was the top intelligence official at the D.E.A. until he retired last year, told me. “It’s to earn a spendable profit and live to enjoy it.”' If you shut down their income from drugs, they will find another way to make money. I had the opportunity to talk to a former U.S. Border Patrol sector chief in San Diego about the cartels. He said that in San Diego, they achieved some level of success in constraining the drug trade. The cartel response? Kidnap people and hold them for ransom. Like any business, they will find another way to make money when the market changes. As their innovations in finding new ways to bring drugs into the country shows, they can be creative when faced with a business problem.
- schiffern 14y agoThe only reason there were suddenly large numbers of people with the appetite for the high life and a lack of scruples is that you can't exactly put "Regional Drug Cartel Leader" on your resume. This is a transition cost that will fade over time, unlike the costs of prohibition which seem only to mount. You don't see the Kennedys going around kidnapping people, do you? Why should it be any different with modern drug dealers?
- Androsynth 14y agoKidnapping is not nearly as scalable an operation as drug trafficking.
- ippisl 14y agoI think we should do even more: develop new drugs(and processes) with less side effects. Drugs(and processes) that let you escape reality when you want, but still enable you to manage life reasonably well and be relatively healthy. It's clear that the need or desire to escape reality won't change anytime soon. Instead of ignoring and fighting this reality, we should try to find constructive solutions.
- r0s 14y agoSimply regulating dosage and purity would be a huge safety improvement.
- Symmetry 14y agoI think that merely by using objective scales to determine what to ban, like this[1], we would accomplish the same thing. We already have safe opioids and amphetamines from medical research. If those were legal over the counter but Heroin and Meth weren't I expect more people would use them instead. [1]http://drugwarfacts.org/cms/?q=node/28 http://drugwarfacts.org/cms/?q=node/28
- pacala 14y agoHere's an unpopular view: Let's work together to make reality less dreary such that you don't have an urge to escape reality.
- MrScruff 14y agoYou're going to have to work pretty hard to make reality not look a bit dreary compared to the average LSD trip...
- rwmj 14y agoI read this and wonder how bad it needs to get before politicians take legalisation seriously. 50,000 people dead? - check. Billions in profit? - check. Narco-states on the US border? - check. Criminals walk out of prison? - check. Gigantic crack & methaphetamine problem within the US? - check.
- ktizo 14y agoHave you seen Law Enforcement Against Prohibition - http://www.leap.cc/ http://www.leap.cc/ ? They appear to be a rare bastion of sanity on the subject. I keep meaning to buy one of their t-shirts.
- roc 14y agoIt would need to start happening in a country that's in a position of defying the United States, or happening in the United States itself. So long as the policy is perpetuated by people who are elected by those who still sheltered from the worst of it, I wouldn't expect any change. Particularly not now that there's a robust military-incarceration-industrial lobby with a strong incentive to maintain the status quo and no limitation on their ability to make 'campaign contributions'.
- mikescar 14y agoVery well said. The media generally doesn't specify and inter-relate the problems or state them as plainly. Having a gigantic drug war going on right across the US border in Mexico is a crazy thing to begin with. Add to that it's about owning territory to import drugs into the US, to feed a large demand. Plus the cartels make bales of money on marijuana sales, when it could easily be a huge cash crop for so many US counties. Job creation blah blah blah. I'd support legalization and taxation of marijuana, it seems like the honest thing to do since it's everywhere anyway and doesn't seem to destroy people's lives like crack and meth.
- schiffern 14y agoLegalize 'em all. It's unpopular, but it's the only solution that doesn't lead to ever-increasing authoritarianism. Drugs don't destroy lives, addiction does. Prohibition drives addicts underground. This makes the problem harder to solve, not easier. The legal status of tobacco and alcohol are proof-positive that biology isn't the metric that's used. It's politics and big business, pure and simple.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe problem isn't gangs; it's gang violence. Making their crimes less stringently punished (reducing the paranoia within their ranks) as well as doing more to restrict the flow of arms from the United States (a better use of funds than incarcerating college potheads) seems a more sensible experiment to try before full legalisation. Consider the negative externalities of cocaine use (much higher than marijuana's); the healthcare implications and effects on worker productivity are costs that would need to be covered by a heavy tax. That, in turn, would make smuggling profitable. Legalising cocaine would cause its price to plummet. This would cut into cartels' profits but also spur demand. I'm not sure if I want to walk around the street with people high on bath salts and cocaine. Perhaps in a highly controlled environment? That still leaves a profitable opening for illegal distribution. For Mexico it makes sense to decriminalise; the United States would bear the cost of use while it could potentially build a viable industry in cocaine processing. It makes similar sense for the US to pressure Mexico to do otherwise up to the expected public cost of higher cocaine use in America.
- chrischen 14y agoWhat if production and sale were legal, but consumption was illegal?
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe citizens of Monaco are forbidden from gambling at the Monte Carlo casino; I could see Mexico legalising production and transaction of cocaine but keeping consumption strictly prohibited. For the United States, however, this would be putting lipstick on a pig.
- drhodes 14y ago> I'm not sure if I want to walk around the street with people high on bath salts and cocaine. People probably wouldn't be using mystery-chemical-x-mixed-in-some-bro's-tub bath salts if they could get cheap cocaine from a well established business.
- 14y ago
- res0nat0r 14y agoI always see this argument when it comes to drug violence in Mexico but I don't think it is that simple. If the goventment gets involved I'm sure it will want a highly regulated system, just like it does with all of the alcohol regulations on the books now. If the government says that only X supplers or growers are allowed to legally sell drugs then I can't see how this is going to be cheaper than stuff that is out on the street. If the government wants to make drugs on par with high end drug cartels that customers like I see it being overrun in bureaucracy and will cost the buyer much more than if they hit up their local dealer for better product at a cheaper price. If the government can't beat the price + quality then people are going to continue to buy from suppliers in Mexico, which will keep fighting it out for this market.
- xelipe 14y agoLegalizing drugs by itself does not imply that the price of drugs will fall and that the violence will end. Lest not forget that, in Latin American, revolutions have been fought because of the impact of the exploitation of the people and land for the cultivation of commodity products such as bananas (see Banana Wars in Wikipedia) and for which gangs like La Mara are a consequence. Drugs for personal use are legal in Mexico, so the violence itself is not related to the criminalization of drugs, it's related to the profit of drugs. And legalizing drugs only strengthens the cartels grip on that profit (see OPEC). The one key aspect that I often find that is missing from the intellectual reasoning of the drug cartel violence in Mexico is that most Americans don't understand that narco culture that exists in Northern Mexico. For over 30 or 40 years, there has developed a narco culture in Mexico where songs and movies have been influenced by the trade (see Chalino_Sánchez). Basically, Chalino_Sánchez was like the Mexican Jay-Z except he didn't sell out and was gunned down by an unknown assailant.
- Yxven 14y ago"And legalizing drugs only strengthens the cartels grip on that profit (see OPEC)." OPEC is powerful because they are an oligopoly. The current drug situation is an oligopoly because there are a limited number of people willing to risk their life and liberty to produce and sell drugs. By legalizing the production of drugs in the US, you allow honest US citizens to compete with far less risk. This will break the drug cartel's oligopoly. Whether they maintain their power depends on their ability to compete in a fairer market.
- r0s 14y ago> Drugs for personal use are legal in Mexico, so the violence itself is not related to the criminalization of drugs That's a recent development, plenty of violence before that desperate measure. The entire supply chain needs to be legalized before the violence will end. Killing will stop, former murderers will be caught, and the American drug use rates will stay as steady and unaffected as ever.
- kitsune_ 14y agoIs coca that different from tomatoes? I mean, is it, all things considered, harder to produce cocaine than ketchup? If fully legalized, shouldn't the price of cocaine be similar to ketchup? The reason that cocaine is as expensive as it is, stems from its illegality. And subsequently, the only reason that the cartels were able to grow to such monstrous proportions is the amount of money that can be made with the production and distribution of illegal drugs. Remove the money and you'll remove their power.
- antihero 14y agoDo you really think these people are just going to go away? Ironically, I'd imagine the cartels would be for keeping it illegal - it's their market!
- ollybee 14y agonot would be. I'm certain they are lobbying hard on any potential policy change that would affect them. What multi Billion dollar industry does not do this?
- TheGateKeeper 14y agoOr the less popular option is to forcibly remove them from the planet.
- Willy_Wonka 14y agoNo crime, barring [b]child slavery[/b]. http://vision.ucsd.edu/~kbranson/stopchocolateslavery/atasteofslavery.html http://vision.ucsd.edu/~kbranson/stopchocolateslavery/ataste... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children_in_cocoa_production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children_in_cocoa_production Top comment, and many comments totally oblivious to the realities of life. Not surprising for HN, sadly. Keep those libertarian blinkers on boys!
- lolcraft 14y agoSee, the thing is that, when a legal company is caught enslaving children, they get massive political, social, moral and economic pressure to stop. For instance, Nike and its famous sweatshops. If your business is illegal, however, you're neck deep in shit already, so the marginal benefit for stopping is almost zero. Twenty to fourty years added to a life sentence.
- Willy_Wonka 14y agoSee, the thing is... you're completely clueless about the way the real world works. People. Don't. Care. Nike ~ want to dance with me on the number of factory inspections, and the amount of sweat-shop labour they still use? Let's go further back... can you name me the hugely influential book on the meat packing industry in the USA, and what the author was attempting to highlight? And which Government regulatory branches it spawned? Let's do this again ~ name me a single ex-colonial Corporation that's increased worker's rights without the state that they operate under forcing them to do so... Bananas? Good luck with that one. Fact is: You're white, privileged and stupid. If I had my way, you'd be culled.
- joejohnson 14y agoSadly, I think if the US were to decriminalize all drugs, the most drastic changes would be seen in Mexico and central american countries. So, what incentive does the US have to help out poorer nations which supply us with drugs? These countries suffer the majority of the negative externalities associated with the drug trade, and supply for drugs thoroughly meets demand in the US, with minor unpleasantness north of the border.
- marknutter 14y agoWon't they just shift to the next most profitable illegal good or service?
- emiliobumachar 14y agoYes, but it would be less profitable. That's less extra money for turf wars. Also, less incentives for people to become criminals, even if current ones are hopeless.
- dhughes 14y agoI know I'm unpopular for saying this but I doubt it would work and by that I mean people like Guzmán will always exist whether it's drugs, prostitution, stolen merchandise or whatever. Even today tobacco, mostly cigarettes, is smuggled and it is legal, people hate the high taxes implemented to help cover healthcare costs. The majority of legal drug (tobacco, alcohol) users it seems are low income so it would make sense taxes are a large part of the purchase price. It's the same for alcohol easy to make and I think if I remember hearing it correctly from high school teacher that (here in Canada) the cost of alcohol is 99% tax. Then people would say tobacco, alcohol, and probably drugs too if they are legalized should not be taxed so high, it's never ending. If I said I didn't care if someone killed themselves using drugs that sounds callous but if I said I cared and thought people should not be able to use meth or crack then I'm told to mind my own business. And people are living shorter lives due to morbid obesity because they can't manage to eat a healthy diet what would happen if drugs are legalized? People balk at taxing unhealthy food I can't imagine adding legal crack into that mess. People in the US and Canada can't seem to regulate their vices, I foresee massive numbers of deaths if drugs are legalized.
- cbrauchli 14y agoThe issue is less about whether people like El Chapo will profit on drugs and more about the 50,000 people murdered due to illegal trafficking. People might smuggle cigarettes, but they don't usually murder to do so. I also think people would be much more willing to tax drugs than food. The reason food is not taxed more heavily is because of industrial heavyweights lobbying congress extensively. There is relatively little money spent in pro-legalization lobbying. Furthermore, drug legalization in Portugal has made it easier to treat users of particularly dangerous drugs (such as heroin) and has in fact reduced use. Portugal might not have the same drug culture as the US, but it's still a promising result.
- dhughes 14y ago> Portugal might not have the same drug culture as the US, That's what I mean. I often deal with people from Monaco and work with a guy from Portugal and the difference in culture between southern Europe and here (US/Canada) is striking. It's interesting to see how similar Monaco and Portugal are generally speaking. People from each area seem shocked by the excess we take for granted. Food for example eating out and having a near litre container of sugar water plopped down in front of you doesn't raise an eyebrow here yet S. Europeans (as I call them) seem almost nauseated seeing it. Food is the same pounds of meat and lots of everything else, years ago a family would eat what one person eats today. None of the people I speak with eat after 8PM and most meals are small except maybe noontime, Portugal may be later. I can't see the same results here for legalizing drugs we are a culture of excess, me first, I'm better than you, you-can't-handle-it-I-can kind of culture. It couldn't be more different going by what I can gather from speaking to locals from S. Europe. As for cigarette smuggling not causing deaths, a car bomb going off in downtown Montreal killing an 11 year-old boy because rival biker gangs fight over smuggling turf, strip clubs (prostitution front) is pretty similar. Add to that Native American Mohawk warriors on the NY/Quebec border.