2 ms·
If an IRC deamon runs on the only server left in the world .. what's the point? Who's going to log in?
by defrost 2y ago
If an IRC deamon runs on the only server left in the world .. what's the point? Who's going to log in?
- fragmede 2y agothe question was if it is self hosting or not, and eg slack and discord are not. so regardless of how many humans are still alive to use it, on the only server still running, the survivors could use something self hosting whereas they could not use one that required a system that was down.
- defrost 2y agoThe answer given was: > If the bombs drop and civilization is over and me, and my home lab are the only survivors, can I still use that software? which rules out any software used to connect to non existant other servers or people. Sure, the software "works" .. it just doesn't do anything .. ie. it can't be "used".
- prmoustache 2y agoYes it does. That ircd servers in the example above can still be used with a bot as an automation tool (at that point as the only survivor the security would be the least of your concerns), as a way to invent imaginary friends to pretend your life is less miserable, whatever. Or say you have a mastodon or pixelfed instance. Sure no other instance will ever connect and no other user will ever be able to see your posts...but you. Which could include some fond memories you want to keep.
- defrost 2y agoIt's a pointless intermediary when you have the bots directly there on your last remaining server though. These semantic games are obfuscating the real issue here; tying the definition of "self hosting" to the "If the bombs drop and civilization is over and me, and my home lab are the only survivors" scenario is less useful than a two handed pit saw to a sole survivor. I appreciate your assist to what I consider to be fragmede's "foot in keyboard" moment of poor definition, I suspect we're all better served with a better definition.