3 ms·
> a mid-range gas-powered Husqvarna 562 XP, next to a top-of-the-line battery-powered Husqvarna 540i XP Trying to find some context on energy-storage here, th
by Terr_ 2y ago
> a mid-range gas-powered Husqvarna 562 XP, next to a top-of-the-line battery-powered Husqvarna 540i XP
Trying to find some context on energy-storage here, the store-page doesn't really reveal the information I want, but using other sources and some napkin-math:
1. Gasoline model has a 0.65L fuel tank, so with gasoline that's about ~20 mega-joules of chemical energy.
2. Electric model might (?) use a BLi300 battery, so 9.4 amps * 36 volts * (60*60) = ~1.2 mega-joules.
So I'm not too surprised that either runtime or performance is being sacrificed, if they're similar in weight and consumers don't plan to swap batteries 16 times in the time that would use one tank of gas.
- lazide 2y agoEspecially since it’s just about perfect runtime with gas - so it would be irritatingly short with batteries.
- Maakuth 2y agoThe electric motor is at least four times more economical in converting the stored energy into motion, so make it four battery swaps. Still bad for many uses, but not quite 16-fold.
- Timshel 2y agoEnergy storage is nice but not taking engine efficiency into account is a bit sloppy. If you go with 30% and 90% you end-up with 6 vs ~1.1. A bit less impressive and since; in the context of the law it's only applied to small saw; then electric might make sense if you are doing short burst of work.
- xxs 2y agoSmall 2 stoke engines are far less efficient than 30%. However 36V/9Ah, is 30 li-ion cells, or a bit less than 1.5kg in li-ion. It's possible to improve that (not massively) by using better cells 21700. Baring that - BLi300 is massively overpriced compared to what it costs to be produced.
- jillesvangurp 2y agoBy that same reasoning, a Tesla would need about 8-10 times more battery than it actually has. A common battery size for a Tesla is around 65 kwh. A gallon of fuel is about 31kwh. So by your reasoning, a Tesla should have the range of a car with only a 2 gallon tank. And of course they have quite a bit more range. They do about 4-5 miles per kwh. That's the equivalent of a car that does 120-150 miles per gallon. Good luck finding such a car. ICE cars are super inefficient. Even hybrids that use a generator to power their batteries (as opposed to dual electrical and ICE drive trains) don't come close to those kind of efficiencies. Most of the energy in a gallon of fuel is converted into noise and heat. Most of the energy in a battery gets used by the engine for its intended purpose. So, battery energy density should be a lot closer to what is needed than what you calculate here. It's still not ideal of course. As for the engine, I would expect an equivalent electrical motor (in power output) to actually be smaller and lighter than a petrol engine. If you take electrical semis as an example, you can actually pick up the motor and carry it around because it's small and light. Forget doing that with a typical diesel or petrol engine in even a small car. As for the battery you mention, that was first launched in 2015. It's an old battery design. Hardly state of the art at this point. And probably not even back then. Husqvarna could probably update that with more modern cells and more than double the energy density. Going to solid state they could push it even further. There are some products with solid state batteries coming on the market now. I saw a review of a portable generator recently, for example. I think it's probably more cost constrained than technology constrained. But this stuff is definitely coming now.
- sliken 2y agoKeep in mind a 2 cycle tiny engine puts up 75% or more of the energy as noise and heat. Modern brushless electric motors are 90% or more efficient. Gas is more dense for sure, but not as much as the energy difference. There are other savings as well, electrics turn on and off so quick, with a trigger that you make 100 cuts during an hour, with gas you leave it on to avoid having to pull start it. With an electric you hit the trigger for each cut. Similar for mowing, you often don't need max torque, but gas often runs at max torque/rpm even when not needed.