3 ms·
I think you need to reread the article: 1) The analysis assumes that John ensures the seat is in the up position before #1; if the seat is up he pays cost 0 an
by aidenn0 14y ago
I think you need to reread the article:
1) The analysis assumes that John ensures the seat is in the up position before #1; if the seat is up he pays cost 0 and if it is down he pays cost C. Furthermore if John performes #1 with the seat down, the question of the final position of the seat is moot compared to the question of "why is John gross?"
2) The article takes the probability p of #1 for John. It notes that if p < 1/2 then Marsha's strategy is actually good, but this is clearly not the case
- omonra 14y ago"Furthermore if John performes #1 with the seat down, the question of the final position of the seat is moot compared to the question of "why is John gross?" That's precisely what I am taking issue with - an implicit assumption that lifting of the seat ONLY benefits John and HARMS Marsh. I think it's more appropriate to characterize it as bestowing equal benefit on both parties (clean seat) and equal work as well (John lifts the seat / Marsha puts it down).