3 ms·
The Ethiopian decision isn't about monitoring, it's about protecting a monopoly. It's the same sort of thinking that has a certain political party opposing free
by briandear 14y ago
The Ethiopian decision isn't about monitoring, it's about protecting a monopoly. It's the same sort of thinking that has a certain political party opposing free trade agreements out of a fear that it will bankrupt manufacturers using inefficient processes. It's a classic case of violating Henry Hazlitt's economics lesson: "The art of economics consists in looking not merely at the immediate but at the longer effects of any act or policy; it consists in tracing the consequences of that policy not merely for one group but for all groups."
While this prohibition has the immediate (apparent) consequence of 'saving' the state-controlled telephone industry and ostensibly the jobs of its workers, it has a long run consequence of raising telecom costs for the rest of the country which results in less money available for other investment, resulting in a net-loss for the economy. This will also result in an expansion of the "industry" of catching illegal Skypers and prosecuting and incarcerating same -- thus magnifying the net economic loss. Instead of diverting government and/or private resources into innovation, those resources will instead be consumed by reactionism.
The Ethiopian policy is entirely about protectionism and has nothing to do with communications security.
- patdennis 14y agoIt's the same sort of thinking that has a certain political party opposing free trade agreements out of a fear that it will bankrupt manufacturers using inefficient processes. If by 'inefficient processes' you mean 'workers who are paid a living wage', then yes. As a general rule I support free trade, but I think you're misrepresenting the concerns coming from the left about free trade.
- cglace 14y agoAs with most things a 'living wage' is context dependent and changes as society changes their ideas of what people need to 'live'.
- batista 14y agoAnd as other things, substinence wages are not context dependent, and are very common in places which "free trade" proponents tout. Plus, their arguments which amount to "working in a sweatshop for our cheap shoes is doing them a favor, because otherwise they'd have no jobs at all" I always found as mere justification for the continuation of slavery and colonization in modern terms.
- dhimes 14y agoThis country is controlled by one man, Meles Zenawi, who is not very nice to his political rivals or to people who disagree with his rule. Protecting the monopoly and communications security are not necessarily mutually exclusive goals. Although I am personally in no position to say with authority, I submit that Zenawi is far more interested in protecting his personal/political interests than in protecting an industry. While the two goals align, he protects the industry. Should they become malaligned, he goes with whatever serves his interest. If you have evidence that the situation is otherwise, please share it.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]