3 ms·
Duolingo own marketing does not claim they teach up to fluency. I never seen anyone claim that duolingo can, should or did teach up to fluency. I have seen peo
by watwut 2y ago
Duolingo own marketing does not claim they teach up to fluency. I never seen anyone claim that duolingo can, should or did teach up to fluency.
I have seen people claim that duolingo made them able to consume simple content or have basic conversation (usually they claim it about Spanish which is the longest course).
- oglop 2y ago[flagged]
- watwut 2y agoThat is literally what every physical language school or textbook for beginners have in the materials ... and literally none of them teaches up to fluency. Maybe because I had experience with language learning, but it would not occur to me that "learn language" in a headline should imply that.
- djeastm 2y ago>it would not occur to me that "learn language" in a headline should imply that That's because you've been marketed-to by beginner's courses your whole life, probably. Like I said, this goes back to things like Rosetta Stone, or Berlitz before that, etc. etc. They all have done the same business model. Suck people in with the ambiguity of "learn a language" (and all the sweet social capital it will give you!) teach you a few touristy words and phrases without any way of telling you if your pronunciation is way off (AI might help in the future, but it isn't there yet), and happily blow sunshine up your you-know-what about how well you're doing. If you can't tell, I'm a bit cynical about general audience language apps.
- watwut 2y agoI think that you have unrealistic expectations. Math books have "learn math" on them. Physics books have "learn physics" on them. Drawing books have "learn drawing" on them. You do not expect to be at PhD level after reading them. There is no reason to make exception for language learning. And even there, real life courses have "learn English" or "learn Spanish" on them. Literally none of them can make you fluent. Also, fluency is super far reaching goal. It is absurd as a benchmark. You will reach fluency only after you consumed huge amount of content, wrote a lot of text and spoken with people for hundreds of hours. Which beginner, intermediate or advanced resources you learned on the way does not matter much. > If you can't tell, I'm a bit cynical about general audience language apps. I learned two foreign languages up to fluency - enough to be able to use them in work, life, internet, to converse with people, use them to learn new things.
- Arch485 2y ago"too autistic"? What does that even mean? And for the record, "learn Spanish" also doesn't imply fluency to me... I feel like anyone would be able figure out it takes more than an app to make you fluent in another language.
- djeastm 2y agoIndeed, it's a beginner course, but they market their app as if they've discovered some secret algorithm to learning languages when any of their students would get just as much value out of any number of other independent learning methods. But at least it's not University courses which are, dollar for dollar, ridiculously overpriced.