5 ms·
China is probably the best case scenario for high speed trains. They have high population density to support train networks, virtually no opposition from NIMBYs
by gruez 2y ago
China is probably the best case scenario for high speed trains. They have high population density to support train networks, virtually no opposition from NIMBYs, and low construction costs. Yet high speed trains there operate at a loss[1], and airplanes are still competitive there. If high speed rail doesn't work there, how could you seriously claim we should switch all air travel to high speed rail?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China#Profitability_and_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail_in_China#Profi...
- drewmcarthur 2y agothe problem with comparing these things by their ticket prices is that markets don’t consider externalities. making and fueling a plane might allow me to sell tickets cheaper than a train, but only if we ignore the cost of the carbon output (since neither the flyer nor the airline pay for this, but society at large does) i wonder how this comparison would shake out if you included a carbon tax that effectively measured the cost of these trips on the globe.
- gruez 2y agoA SF -> NY round trip direct flight costs $362 and emits 554kg co2e according to google flights. The price of carbon by various emissions trading systems vary from less than $10 to almost $100 per tonne[1]. Of course, you could argue that such systems aren't fully capturing the cost of carbon, and therefore using prices for those systems would be an underestimate. Direct air capture literally extracts carbon from the air to sequester underground, which provides an upper bound on the cost of carbon. Climeworks says it only costs around $600/tonne today[2], with them and various startups claiming they can get it down to $100-$200 in the future. Taking all those numbers into account, here's how much airline fares would increase if carbon cost is factored in: cheap ETS ($10): 1.5% expensive ETS ($100): 15% future DAC ($200): 31% current DAC: ($600): 92% Of course this doesn't factor in the cost of the electricity used to power the trains, which would at least partially be from carbon emitting sources. Given that, and the fact that building high speed rail is fraught with uncertainty and cost overruns, the highest fare increase you could plausibly argue for is the "future DAC" figure. This may be enough to advocate for banning air travel for short to medium length journeys, but I doubt long haul flights are going anywhere. [1] https://www.economist.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=1424,quality=80,format=auto/content-assets/images/20231007_FNC825.png https://www.economist.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=1424,quality=8... [2] https://www.carbonbrief.org/swiss-company-hoping-capture-1-global-co2-emissions-2025/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/swiss-company-hoping-capture-1-g...
- anonfordays 2y agoIs the concept of NIMBY even possible in China considering the state owns the land?
- gruez 2y agoNIMBY literally means "not in my backyard". Ownership has little to do with it. If you don't want a homeless shelter built next to where you rent, you're still a NIMBY, even if you don't own anything. Owning something might make you more inclined to object to developments, it's not a necessary factor.
- anonfordays 2y agoGuess I wasn't clear. Yes ownership isn't essential but does make you more inclined to object to perceived negatives. In China the state owns the land, not the municipalities, nor private parties, so even if you live there you don't have much of a say. The state makes plans at such a large scale. This is why the Chinese are so efficient at building high speed rail, there aren't smaller municipalities, property owners, etc. that can object.
- gruez 2y ago>In China the state owns the land, not the municipalities, nor private parties, so even if you live there you don't have much of a say. You're confusing cause an effect. The reason why people there don't have much of a say isn't because they can't own land. In fact both are caused by the same common factor: the country is communist.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- defrost 2y ago> In China the state owns the land, not the municipalities, nor private parties How do you explain nail houses in China then? https://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2014/apr/15/china-nail-houses-in-pictures-property-development https://www.theguardian.com/cities/gallery/2014/apr/15/china... Any chance your bold assertion is something you just pulled out of the air?
- growse 2y agoWhy does it matter that they operate at a loss? Does China subsidise its air industry like other countries (jet fuel is duty free in the UK)
- gruez 2y ago>Why does it matter that they operate at a loss? Because if it's massively subsidized by the state, and air travel is still competitive (at least for some journeys), I doubt high speed rail is good enough to fully supplant airlines on its merits alone. >Does China subsidise its air industry like other countries (jet fuel is duty free in the UK) Why is jet fuel being duty free a "subsidy"? High speed rail is powered by electricity, which as far as I know doesn't have duty applied either.
- growse 2y ago> Because if it's massively subsidized by the state, and air travel is still around, I doubt high speed rail is good enough to supplant airlines on its merits alone. Is annihilation of the air transport sector really your bar as to whether or not HSR is good enough? > Why is jet fuel being duty free a "subsidy"? High speed rail is powered by electricity, which as far as I know doesn't have duty applied either. When the government taxes all other transport fuels except jet fuel, it sure looks like a subsidy. Of course, fuel duty policy is not the only way in which a state can choose to support a private industry.
- gruez 2y ago>Is annihilation of the air transport sector really your bar as to whether or not HSR is good enough? "good enough" with respect to "Air travel should be for medical emergencies only"? Yes. >When the government taxes all other transport fuels except jet fuel, it sure looks like a subsidy. Of course, fuel duty policy is not the only way in which a state can choose to support a private industry. high speed trains in china run on electricity. I'm not sure how fuel duties are relevant here.
- 2y ago
- janalsncm 2y agoIt doesn’t matter to me that transportation operates at a loss. It’s a good thing that people can afford to go where they need to. Maybe a stronger argument is the fact that airlines are so popular at all. High speed rail is great but air travel is still 2-3x faster over long distances, and China is a big country. If we had high speed rail in the US, people would still probably opt for air travel a lot of the time. New York to LA would take 9+ hours.
- otabdeveloper4 2y agoSlow-speed trains compete with car trips, not airlines. They are profitable where people invest into trains like they invest into highways. Focus on that instead if you want trains. High-speed trains are only useful as a value-add to an existing slow-speed train network. Not as its own thing in itself.