3 ms·
Is there a more open reviews platform not associated with a company? OpenReviews sort of thing or perhaps an open POI database associated with OSM, with reviews
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
Is there a more open reviews platform not associated with a company? OpenReviews sort of thing or perhaps an open POI database associated with OSM, with reviews as attributes?
Somewhat silly we’re still relying on big companies to collect this data when they then gate it. The timing is right with LLMs that can make maintaining and rating reviews less burdensome on human labor (“moderation” broadly speaking). It’s just text blobs and possibly images linked to people and places.
- null0ranje 2y agoI’m not sure that this is something that scales. Online reviews seems to attract only the worst in mass media (e.g., gamed reviews, complaint box for influencers who don’t get “VIP” treatment). The traditional restaurant reviewer filled this role much better. His role as a trusted arbiter was closer to what people want from a site like Yelp, but it’s very labor intensive and obviously doesn’t scale.
- etrautmann 2y agoBut then reviews are heavily biased by the taste of a tiny reviewer pool, which prevents breakout surprises and new ideas etc.
- ghaff 2y agoI'm honestly not sure how big a problem that was. If anything, critics tend towards the the new and unusual because they're bored. The problem is much more that no one is willing to pay for them.
- brookst 2y agoI love the idea but anything like that that got successful would be such a target for gaming that the people working on it would have to focus more on anti-bot work than the core product. And whack-a-mole with bots is just not a fun hobby. Only ways I could see it working at scale are Wikipedia model, which is labor intensive for a large number of people, or some kind of web of trust / reputation system, which is complicated and attackable.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe Wikipedia model is close to what I had in mind. One way (there are others) identity can be solved for using Stripe Identity or something where you same for a gov credential to identity proof. It costs you $1.50 per request, but is no match for bots. Assuming you bind passkeys or other strong auth factors at account provisioning, and there are only so many high quality reviewers, you’ve got a reasonable limit to effort required. High quality people want to be helpful, they just need a platform where curation and distribution takes place. See: here. I’m just tired of seeing startups and other companies build and kill these knowledge and community based third spaces, and the intangible value inherent to them. (customer identity is a component of my work in fintech as an infosec lead, I get paid to squash bots and fraud)
- freedomben 2y agoMy thoughts as well. I can envision a platform where you can review anything from specific make and model of a product to a restaurant to anything else. I think it could be immensely useful. But it would quickly become a victim of its own success as people start using it and the database gets big enough to be useful. bots and spammers would swarm the platform to try to game it. That would require a constant cat and mouse game that would not be fun. Without significant ongoing attention, the site is going to become worthless. In order for a site like this that is labor intensive and not fun to exist, it would need to be monetized at least to the extent it can pay salaries. That's the point at which I don't see any realistic solution. In order to maintain neutrality, it would need to be supported by users, meaning users would need to pay. I don't see very many people paying for something like this. And even if some would, there would have to be some benefit or reason for paid users to pay, and that seems like it would open the door for more cat and mouse games and abuse. Just a hard problem I think.
- kragen 2y agowikipedia depends on citations to reliable sources and has a policy prohibiting original research. this is why
- ghaff 2y agoWhere "reliable sources" tends to mean traditional media. Which makes it both more reliable (for many purposes) and much more limited. For restaurants, I do tend to trust newspaper restaurant critics more but there's also far less of that especially at a small-scale non-urban local level.
- windthrown 2y agohttps://lib.reviews/ https://lib.reviews/ is one I've used but none of the open options seem to be able to gain significant traction.