4 ms·
> household income is a predictor of both Household income is a predictor[0] of a lot of things. It strongly correlates zip code (almost identical) and from t
by godelski 2y ago
> household income is a predictor of both
Household income is a predictor[0] of a lot of things.
It strongly correlates zip code (almost identical) and from these you can make good predictions of race and even politics. A naive mistake a lot of people often make is thinking that removing explicit race data removes race from your model. It's still there, but now only expresses itself indirectly. This is not just true for things like race or politics, but for a lot of factors, which is why causal statistics is such a different (and harder) ball game.
[0] Predictor means correlates with, not causal. I see some people confusing this in the comments. I've never liked the word because of this result.
- goatlover 2y agoI don’t understand the racial part, since there are plenty of trailer parks and poor rural areas. Zipcodes in the Appalachias for example.
- ruined 2y agoit's scale-invariant and self-similar. pick a big city or a sundown town, the demographics change but you're measuring a consequence of modern/historic systems larger and longer-lived than either place
- timetopay 2y agoIt just is a thing, tbh. It manifests in the data pretty clearly. In aggregate, in large data sets, race comes through - especially with a few datapoints. For example, when I worked at a fintech company: with household income and zip code, we could accurately target race with >80% accuracy [0]. Add a few more datapoints, and this would very quickly get closer to 95% accuracy. That was an _actual_ party-trick[1] demo we did, alongside also de-anonymizing coworkers based on car model, zip code, and bank name. [0] I worked as a SecEng and were trying to prove that we were(n't) inadvertently targeting race, for compliance reasons. In the end, the business realized the threat and made required changes to prevent this. [1] We were doing this to make a case for stricter controls and stronger isolation/security measures for storing non-PII data. The business also saw the light on this. Sometimes we'd narrow them down to 30 or 40 people in their zip code, and sometimes (such as a coworker with an old Bentley), it was an instant hit.
- sandworm101 2y agoNot accounting for race comes up in scary ways. I was part of a program that used a totally neutral database (race/gender were not in the database). People were selected by criteria and then emailed asking them to attend an introduction meeting online. Only when the webcams were turned on did we realize nearly every volunteer was none-white female. It was a very bad look. It seemed that we had selected them based on race/gender when in reality that data wasnt availible until the first video call. By ignoring race/gender we had somehow made it the most obvious selector. (The program involved having children who were in regular contact with the criminal justice system.)
- _heimdall 2y agoDid it turn out that the selection process actually didn't represent the makeup of the target audience? If the participants did represent a subset of the target audience, I don't really see what the problem is if that audience happens to be heavily weighted towards a particular race, sex, etc. It seems like you'd be doing a disservice to the program to purposely control for those factors and end up with a population that physically looks more diverse at the cost of missing people who actually most need the program.
- pessimizer 2y agoA lot of people have gotten into a weird place where they think that acknowledging that the descendants of slaves in the US are in a dire situation is a form of racism. Acknowledging that being injured has caused an injury has become either extreme right-wing bigotry (if you're a liberal who demands that every subset of people be a racially representative mix), or "the soft bigotry of low expectations" (if you're a conservative who can't admit to yourself that you inherited hundreds of thousands of dollars from a parent who also paid for your private school, car, and rent, then found you your first job.)
- _heimdall 2y agoSure, there are a lot of interesting and compelling angles to consider why these kinds of things happen. In such a specific case as the parent comment here, it really is more interesting in my opinion to see what was found. For example, it stood out to the team that they group of people that were on the call paint a certain picture when considering how similar they were (specifically by surface-level factors like race or sex). Is that response justified when they dug in and found that the group didn't represent a similar makeup of the total population despite having completely ignore sex and race? Or did it turn out that the population is actually that homogenous? If it is that homogenous there are great questions to dig deeper on, like why that happened and what may be done to help correct that.
- godelski 2y ago> Zipcodes in the Appalachias for example. You're overconstraining what I've said. You're perfectly right that zipcodes in Appalachias account for many poor people that are also white. But actually, you're correctly inferring that you can still infer race out of this, because you're inferring that the majority of these zipcodes are also white. Right? White people are also a race. You're correct that zip code is also able to strongly indicate poor white people. In fact, it is also even able to strongly indicate rich black people. Though you might guess not to the same degree as the overall rate is lower, but people do congregate. Think about it in a different framing: zipcode strongly correlates with people congregating together who are culturally and economically similar. I think this version should make sense (especially as the locality affects the culture), and that from here you can extrapolate to recognize that people of varying demographics aren't homogeneously distributed among zipcodes of similar economic bins. I part of this is easily explained by a simple fact: when people move, they like to move to where they have friends, family, or other connections.
- eddd-ddde 2y agoYou are obviously not gonna get rich by moving to a rich zipcode, but rich people move to rich zipcodes. In that sense it is very much a causal relationship.
- more_corn 2y agoIf you move to a rich zip code your child goes to a well funded school, hangs out with rich kids behaves like a rich kid. Moving to a rich zip code (and supporting your child’s education) is a fantastic way to get your family on the path to generational wealth.
- godelski 2y agoIt really is. In fact there's some good studies that suggest that this is even true with race, where you don't need to move zip codes but simply move schools (a la "Everybody Hates Chris"), if the kids are young enough. But clearly the causal connections here are not zipcode, but schooling, culture (or rather the knowledge to understand and navigate a culture), social connections, etc.
- godelski 2y agoNo, that does not make it causal. 1) Causal relationships are directional. Which then follow your own logic. You can reason that it is directional because you can see that there are many ways to get into rich zipcodes without being rich. 2) You can find many rich people that don't move into wealthy zip codes. So actually, it is just correlating. If we use Judea's ladder, then it is causal in that sense, but that's the lowest rung and not what we'd call causal in a colloquial (or even statistical) sense other than to be pedantic.