2 ms·
That "unfairness" is pretty inherent to the equity-style model in any area. I mean, you give someone 5% equity due to their role as an early employee, and your
by _delirium 14y ago
That "unfairness" is pretty inherent to the equity-style model in any area. I mean, you give someone 5% equity due to their role as an early employee, and your company quickly gets bought out for $500m due to some stroke of good fortune; is it really "fair" to attribute 5% of that to just this one employee? Probably not, but that's how equity-based models work.
If anything, equity at scale relies on outsized profits from a few big winners, which is why VCs play the probabilities by funding a bunch of fences-swinging startups. Perhaps university funding would be similar? Of course, if someone is sure they're going to get rich, they wouldn't sign on to giving a university a percentage of future income. But a lot of people who eventually got rich had no idea, at the time of going to college, that it was likely they would. Similar situation as startups, really: if you knew that you were a shoo-in for a multibillion IPO in the near future, you wouldn't give away nearly the equity that you normally do in venture rounds.
It doesn't really seem any more unfair to me that universities would get outsized profits from their equity share in a few big winners, than the same situation with venture capitalists getting outsized profits from their few big winners. In retrospect, you can always say that less than 10% of John Smith's success came from his university; but in retrospect, you can always say that less than 10% of a particular startup's success came from a particular Series A backer.