12 ms·
Site: "This website has no tracking or analytics." Privacy Badger blocked tracking from: googleads.g.doubleclick.net static.doubleclick.net play.g
by Animats 2y ago
Site: "This website has no tracking or analytics."
Privacy Badger blocked tracking from:
googleads.g.doubleclick.net
static.doubleclick.net
play.google.com
www.google.com
www.youtube.com
Because
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/_1Y8PwD5XDs"
title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer;
autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture"
allowfullscreen>
</iframe>
If you use anything from Google, you will be tracked.
- ghostwords 2y ago(I develop Privacy Badger.) Privacy Badger can replace YouTube embeds with "click to activate" placeholders. Faster browsing, better privacy, easy-to-use controls, at least when the replacement works properly. See "Pro tip #1" in https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/01/privacy-badger-puts-you-control-widgets https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2024/01/privacy-badger-puts-yo...
- CalRobert 2y agoThank you for developing an amazing tool!
- ghostwords 2y agoThank you for using Privacy Badger!!
- mattlohkamp 2y agoah thanks for this! youtube embeds disabled by default is an improvement I didn't even know I was looking for!
- ghostwords 2y agoYou're welcome!
- SushiHippie 2y agoFYI I just installed Privacy Badger to test this out, but this feature does not seem to work on Firefox for Android (at least on this page)
- ghostwords 2y agoYou have to move the toggle for youtube.com to red first. Main Menu > Extensions > Extensions Manager > Privacy Badger > Settings > Tracking Domains > search for youtube.com > tap to update the toggle for youtube.com to red
- SushiHippie 2y agoOoh I should have looked at your link before commenting, thanks!
- ghostwords 2y agoYou're welcome! I didn't make it clear that you have to opt into blocking YouTube for now.
- lovethevoid 2y agoThe embed has to be changed to YouTube-nocookie (which is what happens when you enable privacy enhance mode when sharing embeds). But that might not entirely comply with GDPR, as Google still does attempt other measures of tracking. So they should either introduce a cookie banner, find an alternative host that more strictly adheres to privacy concerns, or just host the video themselves in a video element.
- kragen 2y agoalso you could just embed a self-hosted image that links to youtube. presumably if somebody clicks on the image with the youtube logo on it they know they're going to youtube i mean peertube is a great alternative, and nowadays browsers are pretty okay at just playing bare mp4 files if you re-encode them with ffmpeg -movflags faststart -c copy, but if for whatever reason you choose to use youtube instead there are some harm-reduction measures you can take
- KronisLV 2y ago> also you could just embed a self-hosted image that links to youtube. I’ve done this in the past by literally grabbing a screenshot of the video thumbnail (and the play button) and adding a link to that image. Sure, it won’t play in the same page and won’t be up to date with thumbnail or other presentation changes but I didn’t care - it was a small image that also didn’t include any executable code or privacy risks.
- kragen 2y agoyes, exactly!
- Bluestein 2y agoPeertube. Now there's an idea whose time has come.-
- Animats 2y agoI'd like to see Peertube clients as widely available as Wordpress clients. They don't have to be federated. You can just host your own stuff.
- troupo 2y agoApparently there's http://youtube-nocookie.com/ http://youtube-nocookie.com/ that doesn't do that, but of course that's not the default. Someone just pointed out I have the same problem on my blog and I'm very pissed. It's not enough that their embeds break every Lighthouse metric and recommendation. It's all this, too
- vultour 2y agoOfftopic: that website is hosted on a webserver/proxy/LB that appears to have a wildcard certificate for dozens of Google domains. Don't they use SNI and separate certs? This wouldn't fly where I work and the security team is asleep half the time.
- Bluestein 2y ago> If you use anything from Google, you will be tracked Google's become a marketing-profiling engine, wrapped in ad-serving infrastructure, wrapped in the decaying remnants of a search engine.-
- devjab 2y agoIt’s been like that since August 2000 when they launched their premium sponsorship program, which was replaced by AdWords later that year. I’m not sure you can fully blame Google for what the web became though. Part of the reason search engines are close to useless here 24 years later is because most of the content people produce go to SoMe sites. Sites like Hacker News, sites like Medium and so on and because of how everything became a popularity matrix people are posting soooo much useless stuff online. Where it used to be you actually had to have something to say to bother putting it online, because it took an effort, we now live in a world where 90% or the talk people do is while they’re on the shitter. Those 90% is a number I pulled out my ass, but it would be hilarious to see an actual number on just how much internet “content” gets created by people on a toilet. It is what it is though. To make a functional search engine today which was on par with Google in 2000, you’d probably need access to browser bookmarks of the people you’ve ranked as having interesting taste in what they bookmark. Which probably isn’t really possible without breaking a lot of laws, if at all.
- Bluestein 2y ago> on just how much internet “content” gets created by people on a toilet. I'll pull out an equally haphazard guess: Up to 5%.-
- buyreddit 2y agoMakes sense. Tangentially, people always mention of spending time on the toilet, but I never could relate as its a max 2-3 minute activity for me, usually less. Only have enough time to read some Reddit posts. Maybe, as I get older, this will change. Edit: I am vegetarian, probably has something to do with it.
- 2y ago
- codazoda 2y agoI love their work. I’ve also been working on some video to teach people how to publish their own book (the first of which I’ll make available free when it’s ready). Anyway, I’d like to NOT embed YouTube. Maybe I will anyway, but I wonder if anyone has alternatives, especially if they are scrappy, tiny alternatives like those that I imagine 100r might produce. I’m considering MP4 or WebM in HTML and wilder ideas like an audio file and a few images that are started at the same time with JS.
- amy-petrik-214 2y agoYou should check out my book then. I realized that everyone was starting to, not write books, but that they were writing instructional books teaching about how people should write books. I said to myself, "well let's teach them how to do THAT instead". One step more metain the game. Anyway, my book is about how to make videos to teach people how to write books, things like marketing and profit-maxxing. There's a lot of great pedagogy in there. Also what kind of name is "100 rabbits". Reminscent of "50 blessing" from hotline miami
- Vegenoid 2y agoThe simplest thing would be to simply link to a Youtube video, perhaps with a small warning that it will take them to Youtube which uses trackers. You could even make the link an image that is the thumbnail of the video. Not the prettiest or purest solution, but very simple.
- lloeki 2y agoI've seen youtube embeds be overlaid and say things like "this embed carries tracking, click here to load inline at your own peril or here to watch on original site" or something to that effect. Can't recall where though.
- twojacobtwo 2y agoI believe duckduckgo offers a similar warning when playing videos from search results.
- culi 2y agoThat doesn't happen until you actually attempt to play the video though, right?
- tzs 2y agoNo, it happens when you load the page. As a test I made a simple web page that just said "This is a test" and included the Google embed and visited it in an incognito window in Chrome and looked at what happened in the inspector. I used an incognito window to ensure that I wasn't starting with any cookies already saved for Google. Just displaying the page with the embed hits those sites. All in all there were around 20 successful network requests made to load the site. There were another 7 or so requests the Ublock Origin blocked, to play.google.com/log, and then after the page loaded it continues trying those every second or so, although it seems to have slowed down after around 19 but is still ongoing. It leaves 5 cookies (4 persistent, 1 session) and also looks like it has something in IndexedDB. Similar with Firefox in a private window except it stores one fewer persistent cookies. On Safari in a private window it has similar network access, but no cookies.
- culi 2y agoThanks! I appreciate the effort to get us this info
- darby_nine 2y ago> This website has no tracking or analytics The "\u263Eoe\u2721is\u271E" of online politics if I've ever seen. Nearly meaningless but people place great emotional and identity-based weight on it (even if they've signed away all their data via TOS, as they likely have). Sidebar—why does hacker news fuck with arbitrary unicode codepoints? Strikes me as deeply user-hostile behavior.
- samatman 2y agoThis place would be utterly unbearable with emoji. The symbols you wanted to include are in the Dingbats and Miscellaneous Symbols blocks, which I expect are all banned because they contain some emoji and this was the cheap way to be rid of those, quick test: "" "", that's a Miscellaneous Symbol and a Dingbat of no emotional valence to speak of and certainly not colourful ones. As you can see, that's the deal: they're casualties. I wouldn't mind a more discerning filter, but then again, I wouldn't mind a dark mode, and here it is, years later.
- darby_nine 2y ago> This place would be utterly unbearable with emoji. Evidently they've blocked far more than just emoji—I was just using standard unicode.
- petesergeant 2y ago> \u263Eoe\u2721is\u271E This is meant to be a representation of this image https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coexist_(image) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coexist_(image) for people too lazy to copy and paste
- gwern 2y agoIt's an unfortunate use of Youtube embeds. Aside from letting people uncharitably dunk on them, the Youtube here isn't even doing anything. The YT video in question is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1Y8PwD5XDs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_1Y8PwD5XDs , which is 57s long, has 2 worthless comments, no description/metadata/playlist/closed-captions/categories, and a yt-dlp takes literally 5s for me to download the 1.5MB MP4. (Which I think may actually be about the size of the full weight of the YT embed container based on the last post I saw here whining about YT embeds...?) This is a perfect candidate to host yourself and just slap it in some <video> tags.
- slim 2y agoalso with <video> it does not get preloaded before you press play (in Firefox and chrome at least?
- deificx 2y agoDepends on what you set the preload attribute to https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Element/video#preload https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTML/Element/vi...
- whywhywhywhy 2y agothis could honestly even be a gif if you just showed the app without the desktop background
- USiBqidmOOkAqRb 2y agoGIFs are warts. There's no way to stop them, so they endlessly demand your attention.
- klvino 2y agoIt's possible to stop gifs if the domain framed them with the proper code. Unfortunately many people believe gif = png,jpg and exert zero effort to handle them differently.
- simpaticoder 2y agoOne solution is to add headers that forbid all includes (and therefore all tracking): Content-Security-Policy: default-src 'self'; frame-src 'self'; script-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline' 'unsafe-eval'; style-src 'self' 'unsafe-inline'; img-src 'self' data:
- donohoe 2y agoYeah, or as a META tag
- jesprenj 2y agoWouldn't this break the embedded video?
- simpaticoder 2y agoYes. The website publisher would add this CSP header to ensure that the browser only loads sub-resources come from the first-party domain. It does not prevent the publisher from writing markup that declares third-party resource loads. The header ensures that the site will "break fast". CSP headers are often more useful in sites that allow clients to write markup, however there is still utility in declaring your intention to not load third-party content in your markup.
- raverbashing 2y agoA lot of sites (that follow GDPR mostly) have a "turn on embeddings" switch so that you only see embedded content if you want
- scoot 2y agoThe same-origin policy prevents Google tracking in a iFrame from identifying the parent site, so technically "This website has no tracking or analytics." is correct. It does expose you to Google's analytics for the iFrame however, so it's down to how you define "this site"...
- scoot 2y agoThe same-origin policy prevents Google tracking in a iFrame from identifying the parent site, so technically "This website has no tracking or analytics." is correct. It does expose you to Google's analytics for the iFrame however, so it's down to how you define "this site", but as the owners of the site don't have access to that tracking information, the statement seems fair.
- louwrentius 2y agoIt makes me sad that this is the top comment for this link to Hundred Rabbits. I feel it’s such a “I am very smart gotcha” comment that isn’t helpful in any way. It distracts from the actual topic.
- pdimitar 2y agoIt calls out a bogus claim. The actual topic is diluted and deemphasized if the authors make bogus claims. So the distraction is on them, not on HN commenters.
- dewey 2y agoOne could also be a bit more compassionate and just realize that people make mistakes or just don't have every line on their website memorized if they decide one day to just share a YouTube video. I doubt they are actively trying to trick people into letting down their "adblocker" guard so they can retarget them with advertising...
- louwrentius 2y agoThis is indeed how I feel about it, thanks.
- pdimitar 2y agoCompassion has nothing to do with taking something seriously. I have compassion for their cause. Read 2 articles and was intrigued. At the same time, spotting such an obvious mistake does make me wonder if their articles have glaring mistakes in them as well.
- dewey 2y ago"Perfect is the enemy of good" really applies here. Someone is aware of the issue of online tracking and tries their best to get rid of all of these things (web fonts, analytics,...) and even states their intent "No tracking". One day they make a small mistake and don't realize that sharing a YouTube link on their website drops a cookie and immediatelly all the good they are trying to do is forgotten. I hope you never make mistakes.