3 ms·
This thread already covered new releases pretty well, but as for old film, I'm wary of digital transfers that can be very sloppy with their "cleaning" by adding
by wahnfrieden 14y ago
This thread already covered new releases pretty well, but as for old film, I'm wary of digital transfers that can be very sloppy with their "cleaning" by adding too much sharpness or other filters, distorting the colors, etc. It's something you have little choice over when the available film stock is poor, but there are still ones where the film is in good quality but the digital transfer mutilates it.
I have a weaker opinion of vinyl, but from what I understand, it's a similar situation. Vinyl is probably a lot worse than film for retaining quality technologically but because of commercial interests, sometimes the vinyl release has far better mastering than the digital release. You can see this with older music, such as David Bowie's original releases on RCA and the later CD versions that are "remastered" such that they have a lot more dynamic compression. And you can see it in new releases as well with electronic music, where the vinyl release is targeted at DJ use and the CD one for listening at home, leading to different mixing. So while digital may be strictly better than vinyl in terms of retaining quality of input, due to cultural reasons the input is uneven depending on medium.