3 ms·
On the one hand this is genuinely cool: take existing Google Maps navigation log data, use it to identify ways traffic lights could be reprogrammed to reduce st
by simonw 2y ago
On the one hand this is genuinely cool: take existing Google Maps navigation log data, use it to identify ways traffic lights could be reprogrammed to reduce stop and starts, build dashboards of those recommendations and share them with cities. Love that.
But "Google uses AI to..." is such a frustrating way to frame it!
Sure, there are likely some traditional ML models and techniques involved in this work. It first launched in 2021 so it's unlikely there were any generative models (which, let's face it, is what many people in 2024 assume when they see "AI" mentioned).
It's not inaccurate to call it AI, but it adds about as much information to the story as saying "Google uses algorithms/computer science/data analysis to..."
The more interesting component here isn't the "AI", it's the vast amount of road usage data. Google has been able to collect from prople running Google Maps for navigation. Though maybe their PE team don't want to emphasize that as much!
- danans 2y ago> But "Google uses AI to..." is such a frustrating way to frame it! It's a product marketing article, not a technical article or research paper. The details of the type of models and optimizations they use is probably a trade secret, but you can likely make an educated guess. As you say, it's mostly about applying known methods to existing data and identifying a product and market for the result (or the other way around). 4 years ago, they would have used the term "ML" (which nobody outside of tech grokked anyway). The new term is AI, and it also is the term that the public broadly understands.
- nerdjon 2y agoI think that is the problem though. In a lot of people's views, outside of our tech bubble, when they think "AI" they are thinking things like. General Purpose AI, ChatGPT, or this almost magic thing that this single thing is what is doing all of this. When the reality is thats not the case for the vast majority of this. It isn't like they are feeding this data into Gemini or another LLM and just tell it, process this data. Or its some magic single "Google AI" that is suddenly doing all of these tasks. But that is the public perception that is being painted for non technical people. Which is dangerous, it just further fuels this idea that ChatGPT and similar is a general purpose AI. Its a standard ML model that we have been building for many years. Whats even more concerning is ML and Machine Learning are no where in this article. Yeah its marketing, but its frustrating seeing how much we are now just calling everything "AI" as this magic term.
- TremendousJudge 2y agoI imagine the person who wrote the article would respond like "Machine learning? That's so 2010s, get on with the times."
- recursive 2y agoNothing would stop us from explaining the relationship between ML and LLM to this hypothetical author.
- teeray 2y ago> "Google uses AI to..." is such a frustrating way to frame it! s/frustrating/profitable
- plorkyeran 2y agoOr unprofitable if the other recent articles about mentioning AI in marketing being a negative signal are true.
- whimsicalism 2y agoi think the back reaction against AI/ML has gone too far if this phraseology becomes the locus of your criticism. > Sure, there are likely some traditional ML models and techniques involved in this work. It first launched in 2021 so it's unlikely there were any generative models (which, let's face it, is what many people in 2024 assume when they see "AI" mentioned). I don’t think you have a correct mental model of the history of the field. “Generative” is not a very clear technical term and most ML from this era is not going to be “traditional”/classical - it’s almost certainly still DL
- simonw 2y agoDoes the term "traditional" not imply deep learning? Genuine question, I wasn't aware that "traditional" had a specific meaning - I'm using it here to reference pre-current-spike-in-generative.
- whimsicalism 2y agoI don’t think the distinction between “generative” vs deep is a super defensible/technical one - compared to the normal distinction made between classical & deep - where deep is about high parameter multilayer networks (around since 2016) and classical refers to linear models and tree based models preceding them. There is a classic distinction between generative and discriminative models but it does not fully map on to what people mean when they say “generative” nowadays
- sib 2y agoThe study / field of AI goes back decades further than deep learning, so, no, I would say that "traditional" AI does not imply deep learning.
- simonw 2y agoIf we are going by the original definition of AI from 1956 that's "make machines use language, form abstractions and concepts, solve kinds of problems now reserved for humans, and improve themselves". I don't think that applies to this Google project: no human could perform the work needed to optimize traffic lights to reduce stop/starting, the dataset they would have to consider is way too large.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoBack in the time we called those "optimization alhorithms", where you would search for a global minimum/maximum of an equation with a set of input variables. Somehow everything is AI now... a washing machine with a water hardness sensor that adds some extra washing detergent if the water is hard? AI! PIR sensor activated lights? AI! Everyting is AI!
- parpfish 2y agoIt would be better to say “Google uses math to…” People understand “math” as well or better than they do “AI”, but the perception is way different “Doing math” makes you think that google is filled with curious little scientists doing some good will hunting stuff on a whiteboard to help you out. “Using AI” makes you think that google is using its proprietary algorithm to do something mysterious that’ll probably benefit google and/or have unintended consequences for your town.
- nerdjon 2y agoWhen I saw the headline I came here to say the exact same thing. 2ish years ago, this would just be another ML tool that Google released. Would be interesting, but it wouldn't be "we did this magic AI thing" as if ML didn't exist a couple years ago. It is honestly getting really frustrating seeing this drastic shift in branding from ML to AI, that outside of LLM's (mostly) is the same thing we have been doing for several years anyways.