3 ms·
you can't, to be frank. As a TL;DR: don't worry about saving the AAA or even AA productions. The biggest impact you can have is to buy indie games. And not just
by johnnyanmac 2y ago
you can't, to be frank. As a TL;DR: don't worry about saving the AAA or even AA productions. The biggest impact you can have is to buy indie games. And not just the few popular ones, really look into your favorite genre and seek out some solo/small team gems to pursue. Your $5-20 will go much much further there than $70 for any AAA GaaS. If comfortable, try to avoid Steam in lieu of other platforms so those platforms have a chance to flourish, since it'll let them grow and most other platforms take a much smaller cut than Steam; your dollar goes much further for devs on something like Itch.io, for example.
-----------------------
Look at the level of scale between EA (who's about as far on the "unethical scale" as you can get) and even mid-tier tech companies. There's just too much money in factors like ads to ever bridge that gap with "just good games". That's why mobile makes more money than console/PC. There just aren't enough of the latter to support an entire studio whlie expecting each devs to have cushy 6 figure salaries.
more napkin math: for a $60 game, every $100k/yr dev would need 2000 sales a year to break even on their labor. multiply it by 100* and that's 200k sales a year. add in platform cuts and health care and we're easily breaking 400k sales a year for this break even point. and of course we're talking about 4-5 years cycles of no game revenue, so you need 2m sales just to pay back the initial dev cost.
There's simply no "ethical" way to reliable hit those kinds of figures. So outside of "making a good game", the "ehitcal" choices are:
1. Make games more expensive
2. Reduce platform cuts
3. Make games faster (aka, smaller and/or leaner, if we're talking ethically)
4. Reduce costs of living (which can help justify lower dev salaries since they have less expenses)
1) already happened with the $70 price increase, and that's still irritating to gamers despite being a mere 16% increase after 16 years (an increase that doesn't even keep up with inflation). 2) happens behind closed doors all the time with platform holders so that does help alleviate some of the sales needs. 3) isn't popular in AAA productions but a few (like Obsidian, in this article) do employ this strategy of making smaller games between the big releases. 4) is basically a pipedream that's far outside the industry, unless the industry starts hiring in lower CoL areas.
But some of these do imply some grey area solutions:
5. make games with less people
6. make studios located in cheaper areas
5) is basically trying to happen right now with the same elephant in the room as the rest of tech: AI. Generative AI in the case of games. This can be exciting, but the way early adoption has happened so far isn't much better than all the lawsuits being brought forth due to OpenAI's reckless abandonment. Companies don't want to streamline their current talent, they want to replace them, and that only spells bad news if you don't like the current slop out there right now. It will get a lot worse before it gets better, and I can only hope that when the dust settles that there's at least some proper attribution solution (at a moral minimum, there'd be some sort of kickback/residual based on what the AI prompt sources to generate. But that's far from certain).
6) is the same. A great opportunity to not have this industry turn into Hollywood by expanding and nurturing talent nationwide or globally. But they aren't giving modest wages to lower CoL states, they are using it to drive costs down to salaries that high CoL states would barely be able to live on. There's
So yeah, it's a lost cause beyond the fault of even the industry, let alone a single gamer. But 5) does have a healthy caveat: actually smaller but more tightly made games. AKA indie teams or studios. 1m sales may be a bust for a AAA title these days, but it'd be absolutely life changing for a team of 5-10 devs staying lean. So take some steps to at least explore your favorite genres past the most popular releases. Support smaller teams whose individual sale goes a lot further (even $5 for a team of 10 is a more money than $70 for a team of 500. And the former doesn't usually ask for more money unless it's a decent expansion). Follow their feeds and wishlist and comment about your excitement for interesting upcoming indies. You can't help everyone, but collectively more attention and demand to indie productions would at worst show a path as a side hustle for more potential developers.
And as a maybe controversial piece of advice: try looking outside Steam as well. Steam has had a bit of an unhealthy counter effect as of late on indies, and their strategies make it clear that they are focusing on relieving AAA studios of platform cuts instead of smaller game. Basically the reverse model of what unity/unreal engine do with their compensation schemes. Many games are on Steam only, but it's another note of consideration that can put more money in an indie's hand. Itch IO has a "choose your own cut model" and its default cut is only 10%. GOG still has a 30% cut but they offer (or at least, used to) offer a few other payment options.
*(so a sizeable but still "small studio", compared to the hundreds in a AAA title. I believe Destiny 2 had at least 600 devs on boat at one point)