3 ms·
Except that, as I point out, your explanation is neither obvious nor reasonable (frankly, I'd say it's flat wrong). Yet you introduced it without evidence anyw
by ajross 14y ago
Except that, as I point out, your explanation is neither obvious nor reasonable (frankly, I'd say it's flat wrong). Yet you introduced it without evidence anyway as a way of saying "What about this?". That's the same technique creationists use to "challenge" evolution. You can't make that argument, logically, with a flawed counter hypothesis.
The only reason I posted is that you got uppity in your final sentence, complaining about journalists lack of statistical sense. Frankly, yours is no better.
- saurik 14y agoAs I explicitly stated, the authors of the paper actually agreed that this was a sufficiently interesting selection bias to note (although not to bother refuting, as far as I can see; they just say that that if that were true then sperm TL would be an interesting marker, and then move on with a "regardless"). > It is possible that older men who volunteer to donate sperm have better reproductive health and longer sperm TL and that a similar selection bias results in men with longer sperm TL tending to reproduce at later ages. For more context on my general crusade against poor science reporting, I encourage you to read my comment history. (In which case, I will claim your snark about believing in evolution is ironic. I contend and argue that it is publishing summary headlines like this that makes people not believe in other science, such as evolution.) http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4082886 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4082886