3 ms·
(edit:) As quite rightly pointed out by stiff, this summary article is actually not lying to us, as its final sentence does explicitly and correctly pointed out
by saurik 14y ago
(edit:) As quite rightly pointed out by stiff, this summary article is actually not lying to us, as its final sentence does explicitly and correctly pointed out that this paper's goal was actually not to attempt to establish any kind of causation here. I will not delete or edit the rest of my comment here, but I would recommend disregarding it.
People who live longer are more likely than people who die young to have children while they are old. People who are children of people who genetically live long are more likely to themselves genetically live long. Thereby it would be surprising--downright shocking (in the scientifically-exciting "time to reevaluate what kinds of traits can be passed down by genes" sense)--if we did not find the statistically significant correlation that people born to older people tend to be genetically able to live longer than people born to young people.
FTR, The paper even admits the possibility of this selection bias, but then seems to just disregard it with a "regardless" as, despite this headline and summary, the paper seemed more excited by the increased evidence that TL was a good marker of longevity. I hate the way people describe science. :(
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ajross 14y agoIt's all well and good to question statistics, but: > People who live longer are more likely than people who die young to have children while they are old. That's a statement with pretty poor support. Certainly the median childbearing age is well within the lifespan of even short-lived people. The relative population of fathers who have children at 40 is not meaningfully increased by the number of people who died before 40 of correlating/age-related illness (staying with the hypothesis from the article: people basically don't die before 40 because of the length of there telomeres). Frankly my intuition says that the effect you posit is going to be near-zero. Do you have any numbers? If you're going to criticize, do it right.
- saurik 14y agoActually, no: I will contend I am "doing it right". I am not arguing that my explanation is true (if I were, I'd be just as bad as these people I'm ranting about); I only will claim that my explanation is obvious and reasonable and thereby has to be considered and explicitly countered or controlled for before you can just assume that it is due to something else. I totally accept that it /might/ be true that if you are older when you have children, the children will live longer, but this paper does not demonstrate that. That said, I don't even think the researchers of this paper were /really/ attempting to demonstrate that, and so I will put the blame squarly on this "Extreme Longevity" site for not paying enough attention. (edit:) Actually, while I maintain that ajross' commentary was unhelpful (as I stand by my first paragraph in this comment), as pointed out by stiff this article does conclude with an explicit note discounting the notion that this article is establishing causation.
- ajross 14y agoExcept that, as I point out, your explanation is neither obvious nor reasonable (frankly, I'd say it's flat wrong). Yet you introduced it without evidence anyway as a way of saying "What about this?". That's the same technique creationists use to "challenge" evolution. You can't make that argument, logically, with a flawed counter hypothesis. The only reason I posted is that you got uppity in your final sentence, complaining about journalists lack of statistical sense. Frankly, yours is no better.
- saurik 14y agoAs I explicitly stated, the authors of the paper actually agreed that this was a sufficiently interesting selection bias to note (although not to bother refuting, as far as I can see; they just say that that if that were true then sperm TL would be an interesting marker, and then move on with a "regardless"). > It is possible that older men who volunteer to donate sperm have better reproductive health and longer sperm TL and that a similar selection bias results in men with longer sperm TL tending to reproduce at later ages. For more context on my general crusade against poor science reporting, I encourage you to read my comment history. (In which case, I will claim your snark about believing in evolution is ironic. I contend and argue that it is publishing summary headlines like this that makes people not believe in other science, such as evolution.) http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4082886 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4082886
- whacker 14y agoIn the Heinlein (SF, eg. "Time enough for love", and related books) universe, long life is achieved by paying children of long lived parents too marry each other. Ultimately the program is so successful that they are persecuted by the rest of the earth of being so long lived that they have to flee the earth!
- myth_drannon 14y agoOr in Larry Niven - Ringworld , breeding people for luckiness
- Spooky23 14y agoI think that statement only makes sense if people who live longer also have higher fertility rates.
- stiff 14y agoIt's just the headline that is stupid (altough note it says may), the article itself states in the last paragraph: This study was unique in showing that telomere length determination by paternal age was generationally additive. It was not designed to determine if older paternal age translates into longer lifespan. The bibliography in the actual paper cites lots of articles concerning the impact of telomere length on various health-related issues, so it seems that this really was not the point of this study.
- saurik 14y agoI actually had just noticed this, and was about to add an "edit: actually, the journalists did note this". Thanks for pointing it out, however. It is then quite silly of me to have spent time reading the paper but not adequately reading the journalistic summary ;P. (I will even then further defend Extreme Longevity by saying that "May" is maybe pushing it, but not unreasonable.)