5 ms·
How middlemen are gaming the H-1B program
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://archive.today/8f5UP https://archive.today/8f5UP Data: https://github.com/BloombergGraphics/2024-h1b-immigration-data https://github.com/BloombergGraphics/2024-h1b-immigration-da...
- downrightmike 2y ago"The outsize role of these (outsourcing/staffing) firms has distorted the H-1B program, which Congress conceived as a way to help American businesses get access to the world’s top talent. Instead, outsourcing and staffing companies bring in applicants with less-remarkable resumes, paying them lower wages and heightening the risk of undercutting American labor. The result is a system that fails US workers, shortchanges the economy, stiff-arms talented immigrants and enriches a class of middlemen."
- Dig1t 2y agoWhen congress created these laws they just fundamentally misunderstood the astronomical demand there was to enter the country. There is so much financial incentive to bring people in, for laborers, for companies looking to push wages down, and for politicians who stand to gain from additional votes, that any route to do so is bound to be abused any way it possibly can be.
- freetinker 2y agoIndeed. Ignore capitalistic forces at your own peril.
- convolvatron 2y agodid they? the us has long been a pyramid scheme where immigrants work hard for reduced wages so that their children or children's children can sit comfortably on a pile of workers two generations behind. h1b is just a white collar version.
- jarsin 2y agoAnother year another H-1B article exposing the truth. It might get fixed by the time we all retire.
- trhway 2y agoCan i venture a guess that you aren't an immigrant? Because otherwise you'd say "by the time we get Green Card" :)
- trueismywork 2y agoGetting a green card takes longer than retiring.
- wakasaka 2y agogot mine in 1 year employment based. I am not from India though
- Izikiel43 2y agoNot all immigrants are Indians with a 20 year wait
- bubblethink 2y agoHow did the middlemen get so much power in the US economy ? So much of the economy is just middlemen doing bullshit work and seeking rent. Staffing firms, real estate agents, car dealerships, attorneys, healthcare, etc. I don't think other countries have such a big problem with middlemen inserting themselves everywhere and seeking rent. Is there something unique about the US ?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- readthenotes1 2y agoYou have experience in other countries, or is this a grass must be greener on the other side of the fence type comment?
- eru 2y agoThe grass is greener on some other lawns and less green on some. There are lots of countries run worse than the US, and quite a few run better.
- xwolfi 2y agoMiddlemen are people who spent time specialising in a market and you pay them as guides. You never have to go through them, but you'll get your ass raped. There s nothing wrong about them, they work hard and are not rent seekers (a commission on successful deal is the exact opposite of a rent). Every countries has them (Im French, live in Hong Kong) and what you bemoaned is mundane in my experience.
- alvah 2y ago"a commission on successful deal is the exact opposite of a rent"? When the real estate lobby makes the whole industry a de facto closed shop, the real estate agencies themselves are full of middlemen picking each other's pockets, and the commission rate and total amount are far in excess of what you'd expect in a free market, and completely unrelated to any effort or expense on behalf of the agent? Sure, it's the exact opposite of rent seeking /sarc
- SoftwareEngNYC 2y ago[flagged]
- Arainach 2y ago"I did a project way beyond the highest of levels" is a not a claim anyone performing in the same ZIP code as "the highest levels" would ever make.
- BurningFrog 2y agoI honestly don't understand what you wrote here.
- vsskanth 2y agoStaffing companies are extremely profitable and mostly operate on the edge of the law, exploiting visa workers for maximum profit. Any attempt by USCIS to regulate staffing agencies use of H1B has been fought tooth and nail by armies of lawyers. With the fall of Chevron, I don't think there is a way out of this without legislative changes. The other side of the coin is the extremely arbitrary and capricious nature of the US employment based visa and immigration system. This naturally leads to middlemen who can navigate the system exploit it.
- bsder 2y agoThe simplest solution is to automatically give an H1-B a green card in 12 months--24 at the longest. Force the sponsoring company to pay for and complete all of the required background and security checks. Make failure to complete or shitty completion of those checks criminal liability directly on the CEO. This would immediately deprive these kinds of staffing companies of the economic incentive as they would have to pay for the legal costs of an H1-B every 12 months. This would remove the depressive impact that H1-Bs have on salaries as they would be free to compete in the market at large after 12 months. And the H1-B pipeline would be free to bring in people that we actually want. This could be done tomorrow. But it won't be.
- vsskanth 2y agoThis requires Congress to pass legislation, so cannot be done tomorrow. Legal immigration isn't a high priority in general and Congress hasn't moved on immigration in decades.
- bsder 2y agoI might stand corrected shortly. However, I was under the impression that almost all of this is directly under the purview of the Executive Branch (with the possible exception of the criminality). Apparently one of the bottlenecks is the total number of visas per country. Demonstrating that you're unblocking the H1-B to Green Card pipeline by fast-tracking those from countries that don't have a big backlog should send the body shops running for the hills and unblock the ones with a big backlog as well. Or shutting down any new H1-Bs from countries until their backlog is gone would also accomplish the same thing. The problem is that US companies like the multi-year indentured servitude of the H1-B program as it depresses salaries.
- vamsiraju 2y agoMultiple registration became an issue for a couple years but the root cause for the large number of applications this year which will continue to happen is because a small change USCIS made in their application process recently which made the application process more democratic and accessible. Prior to 2021, everyone had to submit a full application packet along with the application fees to enter the lottery. Which meant an IT staffing company had to spend ~2000 USD on immigration lawyers to prepare the application for one employee and another cheque of ~2500 USD to USCIS as application fees. The application fees would get refunded back from USCIS if the application was not picked in the lottery for 85,000 slots and the IT Staffing company would have to at minimum bear the costs they spend on lawyers preparing an application they had to submit to enter the lottery. From 2022, USCIS I believe made a change with a good intention to reduce burden on the large number of applicants whose applications were bound to not get picked in the lottery. USCIS always received about 225,000 applications typically every year and the 85,000 slots allocated for the full year would get filled in the first week itself. USCIS made a change to the application process and allowed IT staffing companies to pre-register for the lottery by paying a nominal fee of 10 USD. They now do not have to bear any lawyer costs to enter the lottery since they do not have to submit a full application upfront. This small change makes the whole process more democratic to a vast number of people who work at IT firms in India and allows them to apply now since they fully meet the specialized work conditions set by the H1-B visa system and the cost to enter is almost non-existent.
- eru 2y agoThey should just auction off those visas (and green cards etc) to the highest bidder. (And require the winners to pay cash up front.) An auction would cut out all the surplus any middle men could earn, and put it in the pockets of the taxpayer. It would also cut out political meddling, and replace it with an incentive to increase revenue. It would also give an incentive to hand out more visas, to 'make those foreigners pay for our public services' or something like that. We are doing such a cap-and-auction system for car licenses in Singapore. It works really well. (Our country is small enough that there's a cap of roughly one million cars.)
- elashri 2y ago> make those foreigners pay for our public services Do you realize that after a person gets H1B visa and start working they are still paying taxes. It is usually higher. My last experience was F1 visa and I was paying more taxes than my US colleagues earning same money. Also this suggestion wouls only benefit the big tech companies.
- eru 2y ago> Do you realize that after a person gets H1B visa and start working they are still paying taxes. It is usually higher. My last experience was F1 visa and I was paying more taxes than my US colleagues earning same money. I was talking about how to sell the visa auction to the voters. Yes, to bolster the argument further, you can mention that visa holders obviously also pay all the other regular taxes, too. Income taxes, sales taxes, etc. Despite a higher effective tax on those foreigners (normal taxation plus visa bidding), it's still a good deal for those that come: otherwise they wouldn't bid. > Also this suggestion would only benefit the big tech companies. No worries, banks and hedge funds and oil refineries and private hospitals etc can also bid a lot. Yes, the whole point is to hand the visas primarily to those people and industries that create a lot of economic value. The auction simultaneously makes participants reveal the economic value they expect the visa to confer and allows the fisc to efficiently tax that value for general revenue. Specifically, the auction removes any surplus from the middle man (see linked article), and puts it into government covers. You seem to think that this is a downside? (Just to be clear, I'm all for helping poor people. You can use some of the revenue raised from the auction and the extra income tax from getting highly paid migrants to finance any do-goodery the voters feel like.)
- SoftwareEngNYC 2y ago[flagged]
- deepsun 2y ago> less-remarkable resumes, paying them lower wages and heightening the risk of undercutting American labor. If the main problem is less skilled workers that take American jobs, then I would start with agricultural visas -- there a ton of low-skilled foreign workers coming to US totally legally and taking jobs from Americans. (Of course in my opinion, this is not a problem at all. If low-skilled immigrant without connections and safety nets can take someone's job at a lower pay, then that someone was too entitled on the first place).
- bastard_op 2y agoThe mega Indian outsourcers of indentured servitude such as Infosys, Wipro, Tata, etc all built their empires gaming the H1B system for the past 25+ years, nothing new here.
- Struyck363 2y ago[dead]