3 ms·
Heavy metal analysis of dark chocolate and cocoa products in the USA
- neals 2y ago[flagged]
- gslepak 2y agoI could not find where their data is. No mention of what products and what respective concentrations. Anyone know?
- cyrnel 2y agoNot the same study (I think) but there are brands and concentrations here (expressed as % above California's limits) : https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/a-third-of-chocolate-products-are-high-in-heavy-metals-a4844566398/ https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-safety/a-third-o...
- wumeow 2y agoI was eating ~handful of dark chocolate chips a day for a couple years as my only dessert. Wonder how many IQ points that cost me.
- SoftTalker 2y ago"97.2% (70 of 72) fall below US FDA IRL limits established for Pb" So you're probably fine but you might want to do more research on the particular brand(s) you're buying.
- hammock 2y agoI assume the heavy metals are coming from the soil. Arsenic is a common one in a lot of crops because of historic use of arsenic pesticides. Where is the lead and cadmium coming from? Road dust?
- saltcured 2y agoI've read a previous hypothesis that quite a bit of cocoa pod processing is done outside and beans may collect such dust during drying or fermenting stages.
- fitzgera1d 2y ago"Notably, 'organic' products were significantly more likely to demonstrate higher levels of both lead and cadmium" Bummer. How widespread is this problem in other organic foods?
- hammock 2y agoI found this reddit comment. It may be that West African cocoa is all conventionally grown (by a cartel) while American cocoa, where heavy metals are more common, is more likely to be organic. You are falling for a scam. The truth is that West Africa retains a monopoly scaring you consumers with talk of “lead” and “cadmium”. To begin with, Cadmium is not heavily present in West Africa. It is very common in volcanoes soil like Guatemala, Ecuador, Peru, Venezuela, and Colombia. That said, this fear is conveniently promoted by big chocolate companies because their cocoa is all from West Africa. As for “lead”, this is from pesticides or private aviation. That said, cocoa pods are thick and it is questionable how much of this actually gets into your final product given the thick skin of the cocoa pod. Our concerns should be more focused on the poor farmers many of which are children that get sprayed or exposed to the pesticides and not so much the end consumer in this case. You might want to buy better chocolate. That Lindt is definitely west African cocoa and it is conventional so it gets sprayed. You don’t need to buy organic to get pesticide free chocolate. You just need to buy chocolate from chocolate makers who work with small family farms.
- scottlamb 2y agoThat seems not entirely persuasive. In particular: > As for “lead”, this is from pesticides or private aviation. That said, cocoa pods are thick and it is questionable how much of this actually gets into your final product given the thick skin of the cocoa pod. The commenter might have been discussing a different study, but this one appears to have tested the final product. If it found lead, people are eating lead.
- hammock 2y agoI saw that. I’m not sure it invalidates the rest of the comment
- dosman33 2y agoI think this was the plot of an episode of CSI (don't recall which sub-series, maby Miami?) in the 2000's. Eventually they determine a guy dies of lead poisoning and they figure out he ate massive amounts of chocolate candy. Conclusion: leaded gas used in other countries caused lead buildup on coco plants there and eventually gets shipped back to US chocolate makers.
- quwert95 2y agoYup, this is Season 3 Episode 1 of CSI Vegas, titled: "Revenge is Best Served Cold."
- perihelions 2y agoCouple of other HN threads perhaps of interest, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34014515 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34014515 ("Research reveals ways lead and cadmium in chocolate may be reduced", 82 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38038465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38038465 "A third of chocolate products are high in heavy metals", 201 comments)