3 ms·
The Myth of the Open Source Business Model
- mechanical_fish 18y agoEither way, the developers of World of Goo are still screwed. "Screwed" relative to what? The cloud-cuckoo-land business model where they have the same development and distribution costs and the same marketing effectiveness but a 0% piracy rate? That plan only works in your imagination. Seems to me that the World of Goo developers might be doing pretty well by their business model. They've got 10% of their users paying $15. If they'd made an iPhone app 100% of their users would be paying something... but how much smaller is the universe of users, and would they have built as big an audience in that universe if they had charged $15 for a game? Here's something claiming to be a bestseller list: http://thumblounge.com/topapps/ http://thumblounge.com/topapps/ SimCity for iPhone seems to be pulling in $10 a unit... but SimCity is a legendary existing brand with no marketing problems. Somewhat obscurer games -- which nonetheless have pretty well-known existing brands -- are Enigmo and Bejeweled, which are charging $2 each. So: much less revenue per user, smaller potential universe of users, but a much lower piracy rate. Does it pay off? Should every new game be exclusive to the iPhone, now? Now factor in this: Which game developers are now in a great position to get some big game company to sign a contract for the Wii, PS3, or XBox rights -- or to port their game to iPhone and leverage their piracy-built brand to get lots of people to pay $4.99 to play it again? Is it worth allowing pirates to copy your game onto half the machines in the world if one of those machines happens to be sitting near a manager at Electronic Arts? I don't know the answers to these questions. But they would be interesting to explore. Without doing so, sitting around and complaining about the "unfairness" of a 90% piracy rate is just an unenlightening fantasy exercise, like imagining how much better you could fight if you were Colossus from the X-Men.
- nailer 18y ago"For developers of shrinkwrapped software, Open Source only turns piracy from a problem into a benefit if you're willing to forego building consumer software and you have software that is either too complicated to use without handholding" I've worked in the largest bank & largest telco in a country, and the largest hedge fund in the world. All three paid substantial licenses to Red Hat. In no case was that license paid for hand holding. Either my experiences over the last decade are completely unusual or the author is talking out of his ass. "OR you can scare a large percentage of your customers into buying traditional software licenses by using the GPL instead of the BSDL." How does the GPL scare customers in a way that the BSDL does not? This is a big claim to make without supporting arguments. That the author doesn't seem to be bothered to spell 'Red Hat' correctly points in the same direction as the other two points. This article is trash.
- brl 18y ago"How does the GPL scare customers in a way that the BSDL does not? This is a big claim to make without supporting arguments." That's easy to support. The GPL wing of the free software movement is famous for being unreasonably prone to solving conflicts with litigation. They are also famous for going to extreme lengths to dig up evidence that somebody is committing a 'crime' against their licensing ideology. The academic license community (BSD, MIT, etc) on the other hand rarely if ever enforce their licenses in any formal way. They especially don't end up in court over it!
- nailer 18y agoYou are provably wrong on every point you just made. 1. The GPL is not a wing of a movement. It is a license. 2. The license isn't an ideology, it's an agreement willingly entered into by people who wish to use the FSF's copywritten creations. If people don't wish to use the FSF's copywritten creations, they do not have to license the software. 3. The majority of conflicts have been resolved without litigation - in fact you'll find the FSF has only recently litigated a company for the first time ever, despite existing for a couple of decades. Even in that case (Cisco Systems), this was after years of attempting to negotiate out of court. BSD and MIT licenses have only provided a wealth of 'do what you want' source code with a license requiring little more than attribution. The major beneficiaries of BSD licenses have been Sun, Microsoft, and NetApp. If BSD licensing were a successful basis for growing software, every startup wouldn't be running on Linux, as Linux wouldn't exist. But it isn't, so they nearly always are. In short: grow up hippy, I ain't giving you source code for free.
- olefoo 18y agoDare Obasanjo is a developer and technical evangelist for Microsoft Web Services; so it's not too surprising that his understanding of the application of Open Source in the rest of the world is a bit skewed. That said he is correct in that Open Source is not conducive to big product companies like Microsoft. That you can use open source infrastructure to build a platform for big product services (Google, Red Hat, Facebook, etc.) is not really in question at this point. As for the World of Goo guys. My take is that the gaming industry is going through a similar transition as the music industry although they do have some options that don't make sense for the music industry; like selling subscription based participation in multiplayer universes. Actually, a musical equivalent to World of Warcraft would be awesome; I just have a hard time picturing how it would work or if Myspace is already inhabiting that space sufficiently to prevent competition. If the World of Goo guys want to maximize their take from this game they should make the physical package more attractive to gamers; throw a t-shirt with game artwork into the box, or some special trading cards or something to make the tangible possession of the game worthwhile. Either that or have the standalone version be an ad for their subscription service. Piracy sucks for creators; it really hurts to see other people taking your hard work and using it without giving you any return. But that is the current reality and suppressing IP piracy effectively would have negative social consequences and impacts that nobody in their right mind wants; like outlawing general purpose programmable computers. But facing up to that reality is something that anybody who wants to achieve any level of success in the content industries has to do.