3 ms·
I'm not surprised. You can market your product as being "cheap" in the sense "you as a customer don't have to pay much", people like not spending money. You c
by ben_w 2y ago
I'm not surprised.
You can market your product as being "cheap" in the sense "you as a customer don't have to pay much", people like not spending money.
You can't market a product as being "cheap" in the sense of "no expense spent", people look at that and think "then why are you charging me for this?"
We've all seen the failure modes of LLMs and art generators, so AI comes across as the latter rather than the former. And that's despite the success examples: it isn't sufficient to point out that AI can do some things better than any human, as those things are very narrow domains like chess and protein folding and millisecond stock market trading; and it isn't sufficient to argue about the difference between the average human and AI because of our division of labour, because, for example, it may be better at architecture than an accountant and better at accountancy than an architect, but you wouldn't hire someone for either role unless they were skilled at that role.
- pjc50 2y agoIndeed. There's an older distinction between "handmade/artisinal" vs "mass produced" which matters here. At first thought, shouldn't the machine made version using modern statistical process control be better? What actually happens is that the process control version uses that predictability to dial down the average quality while keeping the product just above total failure level. AI takes this a step further: it allows cost cutting by replacing human processes with nondeterministic uncontrolled statistical processes. Some percentage of AI users will just be given a dud experience. For which they will, not unreasonably, blame the AI. So AI becomes a negative quality signal. I've already observed "uses AI generated images" being interpreted as "product is obviously fake and/or bad". (consumers are very much complicit in this by always choosing the cheaper option - but see Akerloff "Market for Lemons", that may be economically rational if you can't properly distinguish quality!)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cyanydeez 2y agoI think the negative petception is more cultural in the last 50 years than recency. AI has rarely been shown as good in all media.
- tivert 2y ago> I think the negative petception is more cultural in the last 50 years than recency. > AI has rarely been shown as good in all media. I disagree. The negative depictions in past media were typically very capable, and nearly perfect AI (perhaps except for one small vulnerability that let the plucky protagonist win). That's very, very different from the current negative impressions of AI: mediocre quality, erratic, requiring constant human supervision, and frustrating.
- MiddleEndian 2y agoPeople also hear "AI" and think "chatbot." So they not only think of the recent, post-chatGPT experiences, but also remember every shitty automated phone system or automated chatbot on every website that's ever tried to push something or avoid giving you support.
- tivert 2y agoYeah, exactly. The incentives in capitalism aren't to make consumers happy, it's to keep them from being so unhappy they switch to a competitor, which is a very different thing. There are huge incentives for all large businesses to adopt these automation technologies, despite the negative customer experience. Customers know they're getting mistreated, but there's not a lot they can do about it. The competitors are probably doing the same thing, and those that aren't will do it eventually (certainly once the MBA's inevitably gain control).
- cyanydeez 2y agoI dont buy yhe recency argument. Culture is long tail and AI simply isnt evwt depicted as good. As such, labeling all this stuff with AI triggers negative branding and has little to do with how poor current tech is. Yall are using your narrow focus to cast a wide net and thats foolish.
- QuantumGood 2y agoAI has a "not ready for prime time"/"bleeding edge" problem. Releasing features that too often work poorly or not at all reduces customer satisfaction. AI as a feature too often works poorly at too much of what it is intended for. Non-technical customers who try "AI feature" often become frustrated, but most of them won't try it. Technical customers don't need AI built into a feature, and know more about what can be wrong with it.