14 ms·
Lawyer attacking The Oatmeal shocked by big mean Internet’s reaction
- meepmorp 14y agoOh Jesus. The dumbass is trying to get IndieGoGo to shut down the fundraiser for a supposed TOS violation. I can't imagine what world you live on where, after the reaction that he's gotten from the legal threats, going after a $100k charity fundraiser seems like a good course of action.
- mfringel 14y agoIf all you have is a battle-axe, everything looks like hours of fun.
- tankbot 14y agoThis will elevate (lower?) him to Jack Thompson status quickly.
- lukejduncan 14y agoreference?
- glesica 14y agoLinked-to from the article: http://digitallife.today.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/12/12187665-cartoonist-turns-lawsuit-threat-into-100k-charity-fundraiser http://digitallife.today.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/06/12/1218... > He also explains that he believes Inman's fundraiser to be a violation of the terms of service of IndieGoGo, the website being used to collect donations, and has sent a request to disable the fundraising campaign.
- fleitz 14y agoInteresting, tortious interference might be a good counterclaim after an action like this. The lawyer and his client don't have standing to interfere with the business relationship between IndieGoGo and Oatmeal. (eg. if there is a violation what does it matter to FunnyBusiness)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rogerbinns 14y agoLawyers bill by the hour and by the action (eg writing a letter). How exactly does the lawyer lose out?
- WanderingEnder 14y agoIs the fundraiser a billable event to FunnyJunk? If I were FunnyJunk's accounts receivables department, I would not want to be paying for him going after something that isn't involved my case. The fundraiser is just a spite, it isn't tortuous towards FunnyJunk.
- mkopinsky 14y agoHe loses out by looking like a dumbass in public and losing future business. Free market version of ethics for ya, if nothing else.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoFunkyJunk and this lawyer are the types that Anonymous needs to be bringing down. What a bunch of waste of space douche-wagons.
- dhechols 14y ago"Space douche-wagons" is now officially in my vocabulary. Thank you.
- TeMPOraL 14y ago> "Space douche-wagons" is now officially in my vocabulary. Thank you. I think it was supposed to be grouped the other way, i.e. "What a (bunch of (waste of space) douche-wagons)" but hey, "space douche-wagons" is a nice phrase too :).
- emilnewton 14y agoI made a picture of one just for your perusal: http://plus.google.com/photos/107137383545242155370/albums/5754119721562574033 http://plus.google.com/photos/107137383545242155370/albums/5...
- engtech 14y agoI've uploaded your picture to FunnyJunk, because that is exactly the kind of stuff they are looking for. Thank you.
- Evernoob 14y agoThis guy should really be sued for malpractice.
- drpgq 14y agoI do enjoy watching the lawyer who drafted the letter squirm. Hopefully other lawyers will take note.
- officemonkey 14y agoAre you kidding? He's laughing all the way to the bank. Let's say Inman sent the $20,000 check. The lawyer would get _at the most_ $10,000. Now, he's known as the "lawyer whose mother loves bears," appears on MSNBC, and has his station elevated to an "legal expert on matters of the internet." You can't pay for that kind of publicity. His indignation is probably tempered with a good dose of gratitude.
- Karunamon 14y agoBuddy you haven't seen anything yet.
- NathanKP 14y agoFirst of all I think the lawyer is clearly wrong to take such a foolish case, yet I don't think it is right that so many people chose to attack him personally. Ultimately he's just doing the job he was hired to do. If he can make some money off FunnyJunk pushing obviously doomed-from-the-start legal action, then the only loser is FunnyJunk. And realistically FunnyJunk probably did it for the press coverage and extra traffic that will result. The Oatmeal wins reputation and traffic, FunnyJunk gets lots of traffic (and more bad reputation as a troll), the lawyer gets money. Welcome to how the internet works.
- glesica 14y ago> then the only loser is FunnyJunk. I'm not so sure this is the case. The Oatmeal also loses since it has to defend itself against a garbage lawsuit, were one to be filed, or pay tens of thousands of dollars to prevent such a filing. In fact, we all lose if you consider that pointless lawsuits are a drain on our court system. So I see good reason to be angry with lawyers who do things like this. I don't necessarily condone the harassment, but I think you've greatly underestimated the scope of the problem. This stuff affects everyone. Edit: typo
- epoxyhockey 14y agoUltimately he's just doing the job he was hired to do. That's only a good excuse for people who can barely find work and would otherwise not be able to put food on the table. I (and I'm sure a lot of other people) have turned down work of similar/questionable nature.
- ajuc 14y ago> Ultimately he's just doing the job he was hired to do. Being paid for doing evil is not an excuse.
- timwiseman 14y ago"Ultimately he's just doing the job he was hired to do." "I was just following orders" never makes a good excuse for doing something that is patently wrong. It is even less so for an independent lawyer who has tremendous discretion to refuse to take a case.* *Just to be clear, once a lawyer begins working on a case for a client there are ethical rules that (within limits) require him/her to follow the client's directives and work for the clients best interests. The lawyer also may not be always be free to cease representation once it has begun. But an independent lawyer can generally freely refuse to accept a case.
- brokentone 14y agoIt's disappointing that our legal system accepts obvious abuse like this (the underlying case). I do hope that this idiot lawyer doesn't try and do something with "inciting mob action" simply by posting the details of this case to a loyal fanbase. Time to enact significant penalties for those who engage the legal system for frivolous lawsuits.
- jcromartie 14y agoThe legal system is probably not even involved at this point. The lawyer simply asked for $20K under the threat of a further lawsuit.
- MartinCron 14y agoExactly, it's not like lawyers have to run their aggressive threatening letters past judges before they go out. Most "law" doesn't really touch the legal system.
- Silhouette 14y agoDepending on the relevant jurisdiction, the legal system might not accept this kind of behaviour, or it could be walking a very fine line. IIRC this is all based in the US, in which case maybe barratry and SLAPP rules are relevant? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_%28common_law%29#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Barratry_%28common_law%29#Unite... I'll leave it to the real lawyers to comment on any details, though.
- christiangenco 14y agoThis lawsuit may be the first piece of original comedy to have been produced by funnyjunk.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoWhile in some senses it's pretty clear, in other's it's a tough one . I'm not wild about mob rule (which this is getting elements of) but I'm not wild about law suits by arseholes who in a reasonable world shouldn't have a leg to stand on, and a legal system which will drown Inman in red tape and legal bills. The best course of action is probably for funny junk to get try and wring some minor concession out of Inman (that he'll inform them of any issues directly before publishing them on his website or something similarly trivial) and drop the whole thing. Right now they've got some publicity and the cost of some of their (basically crappy) reputation. I don't think it gets any better for them from her so they'd be wise to cut and run. Whatever they may win if they did continue is unlikely to be worth the grief.
- EvilTerran 14y agoThe thing about the mob rule aspect is, well... this: http://theoatmeal.com/blog/funnyjunk2 http://theoatmeal.com/blog/funnyjunk2 "The owner of [funnyjunk] sent this mass message to every member of his site: The Oatmeal wants to sue funnyjunk and shut it down! He thinks we're nothing more than dirty content thieves. That FJ doesn't have any real members, it's just a bot that steals content. [...] Contact Oatmeal any way you can! As you can imagine, my inbox and Facebook page were slammed with thousands of messages from FunnyJunk users who believed that I was trying to get their community shut down. I think they set the land speed record for the highest number of "OMG ur a gayfagness!!!11" Facebook comments in a single day."
- miles 14y agoThe best course of action is probably for funny junk to get try and wring some minor concession out of Inman They repeatedly stole his work. How does it make any sense for him to offer some sort of concession? he'll inform them of any issues directly before publishing them on his website He did just that in this case.
- Tyrannosaurs 14y agoBecause ultimately he wants it to go away and regardless of the rights and wrongs they can still keep him busy dealing with this nonsense rather than drawing cartoons.
- dkhenry 14y agoHi internet vigilantes lets have a chat, I know this lawyer has done something we think is both morally wrong, legally dubious, and unintelligent. However the real life harassing of this individual is not something a civil society should condone. I would hope that at least the mob of individuals who frequent this web site would be a little classier then both Matthew Inman ,and the internet at larges response. Why does it appear the internet only has two modes, Blind Adoration and Violent Lynch Mob ?
- Symmetry 14y agoThe people on the internet have more modes than that, but only the people who fall into one of those modes bother to write email.
- swalsh 14y agoI find the phenomenon of internet lynch mobs both fascinating and deeply disturbing.
- Silhouette 14y agoI would hope that at least the mob of individuals who frequent this web site would be a little classier then both Matthew Inman Matthew Inman's response to this whole sorry affair seems to be primarily that he wants to write comics and not play at being a lawyer, and he'd prefer it if people just let him get on with that and enjoy the results. Given the flagrant copyright violation of the other site involved here, and the nature of the lawyer who is chasing Inman right now, I think he's been remarkably classy. I suspect a lot of people in his position would instead have lawyered up, gone after the other site for a retirement-level scale of statutory damages, and gone after the other lawyer personally with the intent of ending his career. Frankly, I wouldn't blame them, and I almost wish Inman would do that as a matter of principle. However, I have to admire his focus on doing the work he wants to do and his choice to do something socially useful to make his point instead.
- dkhenry 14y agoI don't mean what he said I mean how he said it. The picture of the bear is petty and juvenile.
- themstheones 14y agoPeople need to stop applauding the internet retaliation mobs. Flaming this lawyer's email won't have any positive effect. If you want to show your support, donate to the charity, don't engage in anti-social behaviour. Generally speaking vigilantism and mob-vigilantism are negative. Whether or not the target in this reddit / 4chan / whatever pile-on deserves it, taking part isn't good internet citizenry.
- white_devil 14y ago> If you want to show your support, donate to the charity That doesn't affect the way this shitbag lawyer goes about conducting his chosen profession. This actually might.
- Wilya 14y agoYou can do both. And actually, since the charity fundraising in question[0], which had an initial goal of 20K$, is up to 160K$, my guess is that fueling this issue, giving it press, and making people excited/angry about it ends up, as a side effect, raising even more money for the charity. Works for me. [0] http://www.indiegogo.com/bearlovegood http://www.indiegogo.com/bearlovegood
- theorique 14y agoCitizens are encouraged to send one on one communications to their congressman, senator, member of parliament, and so forth. Many activist groups encourage citizens to send such communications. How does this differ from expressing disapproval directly to this lawyer for participating in a meritless and baseless extortion request?
- MultiRRomero 14y agoIt's hard to understand and celebrate the glories of the Internet as a vehicle for "freedom and free speech" and all that good stuff, when all too often large communities within it participate in acts that are all too banal and primitive as is mob vigilanteism. So is the Internet truly a pinnacle of a civilized and free society, or the regression into a barbaric state? Cause this seems pretty barbaric to me... (I am not condoning the lawyer's or FunkyJunk's actions. I think they are wrong. I just think there are better and more civilized ways of reacting to and handling this).
- EvilTerran 14y agoAlternatively, there's no higher proportion of mobbish vigilantes now than there has been in the past, they can just form into fewer, larger groups thanks to instant global telecommunication, and you can come across them more easily for the same reason. Just like there aren't any more natural disasters than there were 100 years ago, we just hear about more of them because it's so much easier to send the news now; and there aren't any more... say... underwater-basket-weavers now than then, they're just easier to find now because they're gathering on facebook and etsy.
- scotttobejoking 14y agoI don't think you properly take into account some of the internet factors that actually make a higher proportion of mobbish vigilantes: 1 - Visibility, which you yourself mention. We get to see injustices that we would never see before. Also, like you say, we get to see mob reactions that we would never see before and so we have many more chances to join mobs in a day. 2 - Ease of response. It's easy to post vitriol. It hardly takes any time at all, and you don't even have to walk to someone's house or disrupt your plans for the day. This is a direct result of internet tools that make communication easy, which didn't exist before. 3 - Anonymity, and lack of physical presence. People say things anonymously on the internet that they would never in a million years say to someone in person. Basically, it's just easier to be in a mob these days...
- dllthomas 14y ago> [...] threatening to sue The Oatmeal for $20,000 for defamation [...] This is incorrect. As everyone here probably knows, they demanded $20k to refrain from suing, they did not file a lawsuit asking for $20k.
- overgard 14y agoWhat I'm curious about if anyone here is a lawyer is this: wasn't that demand -- from a legal standpoint -- extortion?
- ceejayoz 14y agoI'd imagine it's essentially a settlement offer.
- falcolas 14y agoWhich sounds a lot a legal extortion to me.
- dllthomas 14y agoFrom every standpoint but legal, yes.
- Cushman 14y agoNaively, it seems like a settlement offer should only be legal if you have actually filed suit. Filing requires you to put your cards on the table, and opens you up to countersuits for wasting everyone's time. Otherwise, you're essentially trying to claim support from the legal system without involving the legal system. Is there a reason that wouldn't work out well?
- slapshot 14y agoBecause it would be nothing other than a subsidy for lawyers and a further drain on the court system. There are many thousands of disputes every day that are settled with informal settlement offers, and many hundreds that are settled with formal settlement offers. Most of these never make it to court. For example, if a tree from your yard falls into your neighbor's yard, they might have a claim against you. Instead of forcing them to file a lawsuit, you offer to pay for a new fence and landscaping to replace the stuff that got squished. (Or, the neighbor demands that you pay for the fence and landscaping instead of filing suit.) There's no reason for the neighbor to have to actually file a lawsuit against you in order for you to work out the issues. The threat of a lawsuit is always there, but making a lawyer actually fill out the paperwork and pay the filing fees is a pure subsidy to lawyers.
- rhizome 14y agoLawyer attacking The Oatmeal shocked by big mean Internet’s reaction He's just playing dumb.
- kgosser 14y agoI wonder what the hacker community and Inman's fan base collective reaction would have been if FunnyJunk downloaded Inman's work off of Pirate Bay instead.
- saraid216 14y ago"Damn, FunnyJunk is stupid. Couldn't they have just grabbed the image files off Inman's site?"
- ktizo 14y agoI suspect that this is more about funnyjunk demanding $20,000 for him publicly complaining about them hosting his work without asking. A more accurate metaphor would be if the pirate bay tried to sue HBO for calling them names, which I doubt would sit well with even the most ardent of tv torrent fans.
- vacri 14y agoIf you look at Inman's articles, he lists hundreds of URLs, with scores of them being repeats of the same comic. This is a systematic problem, not a 'whoops, one accident' issue.
- darkarmani 14y agoWhat and then sued him $20,000 after downloading? What exactly is your point?
- planetguy 14y agoInternet vigilantes do seem to have a somewhat confused reaction to copyright law. The Oatmeal trying to get its content taken down from FunnyJunk: good. Most other copyright holders trying to get their content taken down from almost anywhere else on the internet: bad. It isn't even about the legal niceties of the situation, it's about the vibe, man.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoThe only distinction I can think of is that in this case, copyright claimant is the original artist, and not a corporation. In cases of movie & music piracy, the copyright claimant is a corporation. I suspect that copyright violators will rationalize the act as something that has negligible effect on the artist.
- MartinCron 14y agoSo, the distinction is self-serving and intellectually dishonest rationalization? Not exactly surprising.
- fleitz 14y agoI believe this is the same distinction the movie/music industry uses between what they rip off and what their potential customers use. I mean I'm sure right now the RIAA is taking down most of their electronic back catalog until they figure out how to compensate the original artists behind the Amen Break sample.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoFor anyone with 20 minutes to spare, here is a great video explaining the prevalence of the "Amen Break" sample. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SaFTm2bcac http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5SaFTm2bcac
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- trustfundbaby 14y agoWhen you come out with someone with a knife, you make certain assumptions that can prove to be brutally wrong when your opposition whips out a shotgun.
- demian 14y agoFor some lawyers, lawsuits are just "business transactions". They move in an eviroment where lawsuits are just amuniton in a game. They believe it's ok to use them, so they get suprised with this kind of response.
- grellas 14y agoLawyer attacking The Oatmeal shocked by big mean Internet's reaction The reaction of the lawyer is understandable, it being the sole prerogative of lawyers to bully hapless victims into submission and, if not bully, at least to trick and cajole them into giving them what they want and, if not that, in extremis, to get a true day in court for their client in which the victim can finally speak up, and might even win, but then the client on whose behalf the bullying is done pays in spades for the privilege of financing a futile process in which everyone loses except, of course, the lawyers who invented a system dating back at least to Jarndyce v. Jarndyce (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarndyce_and_Jarndyce http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jarndyce_and_Jarndyce) for the betterment of society and only incidentally for those who might take a modest profit from their humble efforts in the service of humanity.
- StavrosK 14y agoHoly hell, that was one sentence.
- Shenglong 14y agoI'm more surprised, that it was actually comprehensible.
- sliverstorm 14y agoTry German, I hear sentences can go on for pages and pages.
- 14y ago
- anujkk 14y agoWhile the response by oatmeal in form of blog post and fund raising campaign was funny and comical in nature, he has got a legal counsel in Venkat Balasubramani and here is the legal response : http://www.scribd.com/doc/96850920/FunnyJunk-The-Oatmeal-Response http://www.scribd.com/doc/96850920/FunnyJunk-The-Oatmeal-Res...
- esbwhat 14y agoInteresting that in a conflict involving only men, somehow there's still a cheap image of an unattractive woman being tossed around by the Oatmeal. Feels kind of mysoginistic. Would the image have the same effect if it was a man? Doubt it.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoWhile it probably would have carried the same emotional sting if he'd said, "Here's a picture of your dad trying to get some dolphin love", there is a time honored set of jokes entirely devoted to disparaging another person's mother... many of which involve some over exaggerated take on their mother being fat and/or ugly. Although I am not aware of any that involve bear love. For more information you might check if Google has any suggestions for "yo' mama jokes".
- esbwhat 14y agoI know it exists, but my point is that it's mysoginistic.
- jack-r-abbit 14y agoMisogyny: The hatred or dislike of women or girls I know it exists, but I don't see it here.
- flogic 14y agoNo, it's there. It's just so ingrained most people don't notice it. Insults like that are almost always targeted at the target directly or the women around them. That's because society places women on a weaker level. Also notice the emphasis on fat and ugly. It implies that if a woman isn't pretty she isn't to be valued. In terms of misogyny in our society, it fairly mild. However, it still qualifies because it exploits the general power imbalance.
- jack-r-abbit 14y ago
- tibbon 14y agoMaybe this is just me, and is taking things too far... but it would seem that perhaps, just perhaps, we should consider de-barring lawyers who make too many frivolous claims against others and fail in court? Currently, it takes you getting to a Jack Thompson level to get booted from being able to sue and threaten others. The net effect of this is that fewer lawyers would be willing to take on frivolous claims and there would be less litigation overall. Of course this would only apply to plaintiffs, as everyone needs to be able to defend themselves against as many claims as needed.
- javert 14y agoI personally thought the illustration was in very poor taste, and I can't comprehend someone finding it entertaining. (If anyone wants to talk about how Americans don't get humor, please just spare me.)
- DigitalSea 14y agoJust wait for Anonymous to get involved if FunnyJunk's lawyer tries stopping the charity fundraiser, whoa. Then he'll witness an army being marshalled.
- skore 14y agoYeah, they'll DDOS his site for, like, a whole week or so. shrug
- darkarmani 14y agoIsn't this actually libel: "I really did not expect that [The Oatmeal] would marshal an army of people who would besiege my website and send me a string of obscene e-mails,"