6 ms·
Intel dismisses ‘x86 tax’, sees no future for ARM or any of its competitors
- mtgx 14y agoAnd what else would you expect them to say? Even if they actually believe it, they're still seeing everything from their own eyes, from their point of view, and their market, just like an incumbent of an "old" technology would.
- Symmetry 14y agoThere is nothing in the instruction set that is more or less energy efficient than any other instruction set Oh, come on. The problem with x86 is that it's a variable length instruction encoding that isn't self synchronizing. That is, you can start reading at byte 0 and read one set of valid instruction or you can start reading at byte 1 and read another completely different set of valid instructions. This means that the logic to decode more than one instruction in a clock cycle is really complicated, and complicated means power intensive. For instance, in AMD's Bulldozer chip the instruction decode unit uses more power than the integer execution cluster. Now, ARM has its troubles too (instruction predication on every instruction means another logical dependency, meaning that if you go out of order your scoreboard is more complicated) but they're not as bad and don't really exist in alternate encoding like Thumb2 or the 64 bit one. Intel is able to compete so well because they tend to have better fabs, they tend to reach a given node like 22nm before everyone else, and their performance on that node tends to be better than other players too. But x86 does have intrinsic disadvantages.
- Retric 14y agoThe relative overhead of x86 vs other instruction set's is meaningless next to intel's current process advantages. ARM is only viable when you have a similar investment in design AND operate on the same manufacturing process.
- callan 14y agoDisclaimer: I'm a software guy @ Intel. I feel that a lot of sw folks have a lack of imagination when it comes to hw. A lot of very smart people here work on making an efficient, fast front-end. There's lots of research in this area. To my eyes, the implementations are stunning. To say that a variable-length CISC instruction set can never be as fast or effecient as ARM is sort-of like saying that an interpreted language can never be as fast as C. And we all know how that goes over on HN.
- Symmetry 14y agoI'm sure the front end has had a lot of work and cleverness put into it, and I'm sure that it's able to, say, correctly guess where instruction boundaries are more than 99% of the time without knowing for sure and then remove those instructions from the queue if it turns out that the guess was wrong. But that just means that 4-wide decode is only on the same order of power consumption as execution, instead of being an order of magnitude more like if you'd done thing the naive way. I'm sure that the work they do _is_ stunning, but its work that doesn't even have to be done on more regular instruction sets. It's not a problem with being variable length or CISC, its a problem with the lack of self-synchronization. If you, say, had 8 or 16 bit blocks were first bit of each block told you whether it was the beginning of an instruction you wouldn't have this problem at all. I'd generally say that for a modern general purpose computer variable length instructions and a large number of op-codes are a good idea, though a large number of addressing modes seems to still be a disadvantage. Its probably no accident that ARM, the "CISCiest" of the RISC processors is so popular right now.
- phamilton 14y agoBut don't ARM/Marvell/Qualcomm/Nvidia have a lot of smart people working on making an efficient fast front-end? Overcoming an obstacle is great, but I feel like companies who don't have to overcome that obstacle can focus their energy on other aspects of the product.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoAndroid is no problem because of the Dalvik byte code engine but Apple is a whole other matter. Apple has over 600,000 apps in the App Store that are all coded for ARM. Moving to a new instruction set architecture is going to problematic. If Intel had taken low power seriously back in the days of the Newton and the StrongARM (which Intel actually owned for a while) they might have won the Apple business instead of ARM back in 2007 but now it is probably too late. Apple has switched CPU architectures before but never with the number of applications that they are currently dealing with in the App Store.
- jevinskie 14y agoI would think that there would be few problems porting your source from ARM to x86. Heck, if you use the iOS simulator, it compiles to x86! Maybe a Rosetta like shim could be used for apps where the authors do not update them.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoI don't think it would take much to recompile existing apps but there are so many apps, just approving them would take Apple years. Then think of the all the apps that are tuned to take maximum advantage of the platform. That code may work but it doesn't mean it will work optimally. Intel is going to have to do a lot better than "we win some, lose some" on battery and performance to convince Apple to switch.
- objclxt 14y agoThe last time Apple did this apps didn't have to re-compile - the Rosetta translation layer did a pretty decent job. If Apple were to switch architectures (rather unlikely, but still) I imagine they'd be providing a similar sort of translation layer for most apps to use.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoYou aren't going to use Rosetta style software on a battery constrained mobile device. There would have to be a huge benefit to switching to make that kind of problem for users. The iPhone is already bashed for having battery issues. What would be the benefit of switching to Intel for Apple?
- excuse-me 14y agoWho cares about a tablet/cell phone's CPU? It's the GPU that matters. So I buy an Nvidia Tegra2 chipset, it happens to have an ARM tucked in the corner. I buy an Atom and it has the latest in a long line of Intel embedded GPUS stuck int he corner as an afterthought
- dmm 14y agoThe latest Atom SoCs have PowerVR GPUs.
- mtgx 14y agoOld ones. Almost 2 generations old. They can barely get half of the performance of any other current high-end chip, and Mali T604 and Adreno 320 should be out in a few months with another 2-3x increase in performance.
- alecco 14y agoThis makes no sense. They are adding more CPU cores to newer models. Are you saying that isn't useful?
- excuse-me 14y agoIt depends what compute tasks you are using your mobile for If the heaviest tasks are playing HD video, using webgl or playing 3D games then the GPU matters most. If you are using your cell phone for massively parralel computation fluid dynamic simulation of nuclear weapons - then that's still the GPU. If you are using it for I/O bound limited multi-tasking like database access or payroll processing then a 4core CPU is best.
- seanalltogether 14y agoI completely agree. Pushing pixels is WAY more expensive then executing general code in a mobile app (and usually in desktop apps too). Deserializing a view structure and presenting it to the screen is going to be limited by i/o and gpu drawing. Data crunching just isn't a big thing on mobile devices, aside from game physics or potentially custom video/image processing.
- Codhisattva 14y ago_I begin to wonder what this means for Apple_ There is no doubt in my mind that Apple will jump to Intel mobile chips as soon as Intel can meet Apple's needs. Number one compelling reason: Samsung is Apple's foundry.
- thoughtsimple 14y agoI can see Apple going with Intel as a foundry for ARM SoC but I doubt they will switch to x86.
- spiralpolitik 14y agoGenerally when a company dismisses a competitor in this way it usually finds itself on the wrong end of a disruptive collapse in 5 or so years. See Nokia, RIM, Palm. While its difficult to bet against Intel, it will be interesting to see how quickly they can ramp up sales of their mobile processors as sales of their desktop processors decline. That will be the key to Intel's survival.
- adrianmsmith 14y ago"as sales of their desktop processors decline" Why will their sales of desktop processors decline?
- spiralpolitik 14y agoPeople switching from buying x86 laptops or desktops switching to buying tablets instead. If the iPad/Android/Windows 8 tablet doesn't have an Intel processor in it then that's money lost for Intel.
- rbehrends 14y agoOn a somewhat unrelated note, Intel's cleanroom ad [1] that is reproduced in the article really sets my teeth on edge because of the sheer level of misogyny involved (little girl with toys in a pink bedroom vs. grown men in blue high-tech room). Could it possibly send a stronger message that women don't belong in tech? (That the ad designers may not have intended that message does not mean that it's not there.) [1] http://cleanroom.net/?p=966 http://cleanroom.net/?p=966