4 ms·
Off topic, but does anyone know why we use subdomain.domain rather than domain.subdomain? It's always felt backwards to me. I think it would make more sense to
by simias 14y ago
Off topic, but does anyone know why we use subdomain.domain rather than domain.subdomain? It's always felt backwards to me.
I think it would make more sense to use com.ycombinator.news or de.google.www. From general to specific, like IP addresses.
- SeanLuke 14y agoI believe UUCP mail did it that way. At any rate, this is an address. There's a convention here. Do I write addresses as "1600 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Washington DC, 20006, USA", or "USA, Washington DC, 20006, NW, Pennsylvania Avenue, 1600"?
- Jacqued 14y agoI've always felt like physical mail addresses were written backwards too. As it is, every word is meaningless until you have read what follows. It would make a lot of sense with internet subdomains, too. Although to me, WWW seems far more general than DE, so it would we www.de.google. Which they will probably take when this goes live, so...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pixelbath 14y agoI suppose it's the way your brain maps it internally. To me, it makes sense to have the most granular things first, as those become what's important. To use physical addresses as an example, say I'm delivering a letter (I'm delivering this letter end-to-end by myself in this hypothetical scenario). Once I know the country, I don't need to check that information again. Once I'm down at the city level, that then becomes useless information, and so on. I'll grant that prepending "www" on every site doesn't make a great deal of sense, but when the "World Wide Web" came into existence as such, it made slightly more sense on the surface.
- jgrahamc 14y agoSort of... UUCP worked by specifying the route the message had to take by a chain of machines that were connected to each other. So you'd have something like mainvax!bigserver!otherserver!theirvax!john
- pm215 14y agoHowever, that's not the only convention for postal addresses. In Japan they write them the other way around, starting with the prefecture and working down through city, subarea, block/building number and finally the addressee's name. I don't think it's the only country using major-to-minor order, although minor-to-major is more common.
- justincormack 14y agoAnd most of Europe does "rue Blah 1600"
- SeanLuke 14y agoWell... the building number appears after the street, but beyond that it follows the standard address convention, does it not? Piazza di San Cosimato 63, 00153 Rome, Italy Also, I'm don't know if Japanese addresses are reversed in Japanese, but when the Japanese express them in latin scripts, they are always in standard address order clear down to floor numbers and room numbers. Here's Sony Computer Science Laboratories: 3-14-13, Higashigotanda, Shinagawa-ku, Tokyo, Japan Straightforward address ordering. At any rate, the IP address scheme was invented by Americans, so it seems natural that it'd use an American (and generally worldwide it seems, at least in roman scripts) address ordering.
- pm215 14y agoYes, I skipped the detail that Japanese addresses in Latin scripts are written the other way around. SCSL's address in native script as quoted on their webpage is 東京都品川区東五反田3-14-13 高輪ミューズビル (ie Tokyou-to Shinagawa-ku Higashigotanda 3-14-3 Takanawa Muuze biru).
- jgrahamc 14y agoFor those of you too young to remember and not from the UK... we used to do it that way here. It was called the JANET Name Registration System and we had addresses like UK.AC.OX for a machine at Oxford. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JANET_NRS http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JANET_NRS The DNS system from the beginning has the names the other way around (see RFC 882 from 1983). Since JANET and ARPANET were largely disconnected from one another the systems were able to develop separately. Ultimately, TCP/IP beat out X.25 and the Internet protocols took over. One side effect of this is the the ccTLDs are drawn from ISO 3166 which would have the UK specified as .gb. But since we already had a whole addressing system based around UK. it was easier to switch to .uk and ignore the ISO 3166 standard. Worth noting that for a while there were mail gateways between JANET and the Internet that did all sorts of fun flipping addresses so that someone at Stanford say could email foo@cam.ac.uk which would turn into foo@UK.AC.CAM at the gateway and vice versa.
- macavity23 14y agoNot only like IP addresses but also like the path part of the URL. Interestingly, Tim Berners-Lee now thinks the same: http://www.w3.org/People/Berners-Lee/FAQ.html#etc http://www.w3.org/People/Berners-Lee/FAQ.html#etc