3 ms·
Do you think that ChatGPT can reason? – Machine Learning Street Talk
- keepamovin 2y agoNo, unfortunately I don’t think it can. I think because it’s dealing with strings it hasn’t abstracted away to meanings, in categories - it hasn’t or, cannot with its current structure, learn symbolic computation. so I think reasoning is impossible with this versions structure. It just has an incredible memory bank of string completions, With a kind of rough and low level, symbolic substitution, to enable it to create innovative sentences, but that doesn’t lift to a full categorical, generalization ability to really create hierarchical, or networked graphs of meaning, nor to compute over the symbols of those graphs.
- DHPersonal 2y ago> Now OpenAI has announced that it has created a "five-level system" to track development toward Artificial General Intelligence and "human-level problem-solving," a non-story that should be treated with deep suspicion. > According to Bloomberg, these five levels go from Level 1 ("Chatbots, AI with conversational language") to Level 5 ("Organizations, AI that can do the work of an organization") and, somehow, Bloomberg credulously accepted an OpenAI spokesperson's statement that it is "on Level 1, but on the cusp of Level 2," when GPT can do "human-level problem solving" without any explanation of what that means, how that's measured, or how GPT, a model that probabilistically guesses the right thing to do next, will start "reasoning," a thing that Large Language Models cannot do according to multiple academics. https://www.wheresyoured.at/put-up-or-shut-up/ https://www.wheresyoured.at/put-up-or-shut-up/