3 ms·
The Four Theories of Truth as a Method for Critical Thinking
- gcanyon 2y agoI was pleasantly surprised -- I was expecting something far more esoteric and less approachable than this ended up being. Honestly I'm fascinated by the simplicity of this. But I'm left wondering whether there is much of a practical application for distinguishing the four methods? For example, are there circumstances where you might reasonably be expected to use the consensus method, but you'd be better off using the pragmatic method? Another thing it leaves on the table is the actual consensus used -- is it possible to judge the functionality or utility of a given consensus vs. another? There's a lot to think through here and I wanted more. But it's a great start -- a much better start than I expected.
- snowpid 2y ago" But I'm left wondering whether there is much of a practical application for distinguishing the four methods? For example, are there circumstances where you might reasonably be expected to use the consensus method, but you'd be better off using the pragmatic method? " One case would be, where you disagree with the experts because you can think there aren't good experts at all. There have been many disagree if psycho analysis is a good approach of therapy.
- blueflow 2y agoThe coherence theory is testing against the human understanding, not against reality itself (the map vs territory thing). And the consensus and pragmatic theories are not about truth, they are about consensus and usefulness, which are different things.
- curo 2y agoWould "pragmatic-universal" and "pragmatic-consensus" count as a fifth and sixth? I.e., "what's useful for the group?" and "what the group thinks is useful for them?" An example of the first category might be a parent deciding it's better for their kids to believe in Santa Claus. An example of the second is to create a society on some maxim that's rendered true by group-consensus, "everyone should have an equal say."
- psychoslave 2y agoWhat a consensus has to say about truth is that people that endorse the consensus will act, at least to some degree, as if they take the consensual claims as truths. But this is as real as an actor performing the role of a judge. You can make videos of both, and for spectators this will look like there is no fundamental distinction that can be pointed to. And yet, we all understand that they're fundamental differences with significant differences in outcomes.
- Firadeoclus 2y agoWhat makes a judge a "real" judge is that a sufficient number of people capable of enforcing judgments share the view that the judge is a real judge.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rhelz 2y agosigh hello downvoters... There is no coherent, constant theory of truth for any language which has the word "truth." This was proven by Tarki ages ago. The reason is the Liar's paradox. It blows up any such theory of truth. For example, the correspondence theory of truth is blown up with this version of the liar sentence: "This sentence does not correspond to reality". Ok, does that sentence correspond with reality, or not? :-) This is a genuine problem, which nobody has ever found a solution for. See the Stanford encyclopedia article on the liar paradox. The good news is that we don't need to define truth at all. Just like we don't have to define "point" or "line" in geometry, or "set" in mathematics. These are, as it were, "axiomatic" concepts, which we use to define everything else with. They cannot be defined in terms of anything more basic or simpler, because they are the most basic, simple concepts we have.
- dredmorbius 2y agoAre there examples of self-contradictory statements which aren't strictly self-referential? That is, a statement which expresses a statement about something other than itself, or a small set of closed relations. Forms I've encountered of the liar's paradox or similar constructions are not deterministically true or false, yes, but they're also not particularly useful. This is problematic if you're trying to come up with a closed, consistent, axiomatic logical system (as Gödel and Russell were each attempting, independently AFAIU), but not so much if you're simply looking to assess statements about the real world, or even a simulation.
- rhelz 2y agoThe paradox doesn't depend on self reference at all, e.g.: Alen: What Bob is about to say is true. Bob: What Allen just said is false.
- sickofparadox 2y agoThe paradox is the entire block after your colon, and it is still referencing itself.
- zarathustreal 2y agoFor a more thorough treatment of the subject, I suggest Baudrillard’s “Simulacra and Simulation”
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- illuminant 2y agoThe "Truth" is a perturbation of Existential Reality. The "truth" is a figment of mind, of which "integrity" is a measure of consistency between the two. From this one may say that any "truth" (you say so) that is somehow not consistent with Truth (as reducible by our perceptions, then sense of logic, then best motive, etc.) exists only in the void of lie. Anyone may tell themselves anything, until it is in conflict with feedback from existential reality. A mistaken interpretation of the first model of truth given, is the distinction that Truth is True whether or not a human perceives it. Philosophy then wonders if our human minds have the ability to conceive it (true truth).
- dredmorbius 2y agoFor those interested in further exploration, Wikipedia has a good section on theories of truth (there are more than the four mentioned at imfeld.dev here): <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth#Major_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Truth#Major_theories> And of course the Stanford Online Encyclopedia of Philosophy, which has an extensive article on Truth: <https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/truth/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/truth/> (As noted at the link, Truth was substantially revised on Thursday, 16 August, 2018, which absolutely tickles me.)