3 ms·
Microsoft backs down over rivals' Vista access (2006)
- justsomehnguy 2y ago[flagged]
- scott_w 2y agoI find it interesting how history can sometimes determine our legal and technical frameworks. The Crowdstrike issue we see is essentially a foreseeable consequence of this decision. As another comment pointed out, Apple don't provide the same level of access for app developers for iPhones, yet don't have the same scrutiny. I'd wager this is partially because antivirus vendors for iPhone never existed, which weakens their standing in a legal sense. Unlike browser and antivirus vendors for Windows, you'd be demanding the courts create a new market for you, as opposed to preventing a monopoly from removing one. I don't have an answer, or even a specific opinion, to this. Just making an observation.
- kalleboo 2y agoThe difference is that Microsoft, as an Operating System Vendor, wanted to get into the Security Software Market, with exclusive access to their operating systems that none of the existing security software had. Apple does not sell security software so they don't have the same conflict of interest. Microsoft could have responded to the EU request by creating a secure, sandboxed API (like the one Apple has for macOS) and used that both for their own security software and also let third-party software use it. That would have been fair market dealing. But they took the lazy way out and just gave the third party software access to the kernel the same way their own software already used it, so they didn't have to rewrite their own solution.
- supriyo-biswas 2y agoHooking into NT kernel syscalls were already a thing before the introduction of Defender; Microsoft may have felt that it was easier to continue a similar setup (albeit isolated to device drivers) instead of facing regulatory scrutiny. Apple's responses to the DMA/DSA and Google's Privacy Sandbox have already attracted such scrutiny despite providing alternative APIs. I assume Microsoft Legal could already foresee such a situation arising, and just assumed it was better to leave the system as-is until there was a compelling data point to prove otherwise.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pjmlp 2y ago> Apple has for macOS kexts are still available, yet this misformation keeps being repeated. https://developer.apple.com/documentation/apple-silicon/installing-a-custom-kernel-extension https://developer.apple.com/documentation/apple-silicon/inst...
- nar001 2y agoKexts are being phased out, and are only changeable if you "reduce security" though, so obviously not something that Apple is supporting, it's more "at your own risk" so not really the same as what Microsoft is doing (Supporting people plugging into the kernel itself)
- pjmlp 2y agoTrue, and as long as they are around, they can be used.
- TillE 2y agoEndpoint Security is a user framework, that's the point. You can write a driver in macOS. You have to write a driver for Windows, there is literally no other solution for real-time protection.
- pjmlp 2y agoAs long as they are available, they are a possible usage scenario, regardless of what people on HN think companies might be using instead.
- zokier 2y agoI don't think MS particularly wanted to enter security market, they cared far more about making sure that all Windows computers had some level of baseline security solution. The constant virus epidemics were hurting their reputation and they wanted to address that; improving Windows security was pretty major theme for early 00s MS. Indeed I imagine especially then they would have been happy to be completely rid of the AV market instead of entering it as a player. The Vista era Defender product was extremely rudimentary, it's almost certain that the major commercial offerings were doing far more intrusive and complex stuff in kernel. Thus I don't think simply forcing everyone to downgrade to Defenders level would have made anyone happy. Calling MS lazy for not coming up with new novel set of APIs overnight is pretty disingenuous.
- Nullabillity 2y agoMicrosoft has been selling Forefront (the commercial version of Security Essentials/Defender) since 2007[0], 2 years before Security Essentials was released. [0]: It's hard to track down a specific date since they've been going through a bunch of rebrands, but https://www.csoonline.com/article/545304/cisco-subnet-whatever-happened-to-microsoft-forefront-endpoint-protection.html https://www.csoonline.com/article/545304/cisco-subnet-whatev... seems like the earliest date I can find, with a bunch of other sources from 2009 talking about new updates.
- paulmd 2y ago> As another comment pointed out, Apple don't provide the same level of access for app developers for iPhones, yet don't have the same scrutiny. I'd wager this is partially because antivirus vendors for iPhone never existed, which weakens their standing in a legal sense. I think the Intel thing is another interesting case of this. Once those overclocking controls exist, it's pretty hard to actively take them away from people (and partners) without looking like a jerk in the process, even if they are now dangerous in a way they weren't previously. NVIDIA got a ton of heat for this back when Turing launched. You heard all the excuses: "electromigration doesn't happen on modern processors, unless it's like 4.7 GHz sandy bridge" etc. https://x.com/Sebasti66855537/status/1816955349636710535 https://x.com/Sebasti66855537/status/1816955349636710535 You almost need one of these kinds of incidents to get people to take a step back and realize what's at stake. Because people will keep living in 2007 forever - you see this with gpu pricing and economics too. And in turn this does create a perverse incentive to just not offer these things in the first place, I think that’s correct. That’s the way we’ve written the laws, it’s worse to take it away than to never offer it. And there’s valid logic supporting that too - now other people’s livelihoods depend on your indulgence, and they get the business equivalent of tenant rights. (although there are instances where it has been successfully rolled back, notably the third-party chipset market no longer exists, intel locked that down and AMD immediately followed.)
- paulmd 2y agocontemporary discussion (as they say: "thanks, macro-expanded:") https://old.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/9ge8t0/rtx_2080_voltage_limit_boost_40_oc_interview_w/ https://old.reddit.com/r/nvidia/comments/9ge8t0/rtx_2080_vol... https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/9gedcf/gamers_nexus_interview_w_tom_petersen_rtx_2080/ https://old.reddit.com/r/hardware/comments/9gedcf/gamers_nex... https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/9gedbj/rtx_2080_voltage_limit_boost_40_oc_interview_w/ https://old.reddit.com/r/pcmasterrace/comments/9gedbj/rtx_20...
- maxehmookau 2y agoI like that articles like this in 2006 referred to Microsoft as "Redmond" - like Microsoft was an entirely country in its own right. "Washington said" when referring to the US government is common, but I don't think you see "Cupertino said" when referring to Apple these days.
- dao- 2y ago> I don't think you see "Cupertino said" when referring to Apple these days. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41098886 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41098886
- maxehmookau 2y agoAlright, I'll qualify that with "journalists don't do this as often" as they did in 2006.
- rvnx 2y agoRight below for example, in the comment that was posted 30 minutes ago before yours. Such companies like Microsoft or Google have so much power in the city that they usually influence a lot the local police or mayor. For example, Microsoft, their street is called "One Microsoft Way", and Google, the HQ is protected by the Google's police instead of the municipal police.
- snowpid 2y agoWhat do you mean by Google Police? Can they use force? Throw me into prison? What are their laws? (If you can't answer that, can you me some hints for direction?)
- vel0city 2y agoI don't exactly know the situation at Google, but it's not entirely uncommon for orgs with large campuses to hire licensed peace officers instead of basic "security guards". A licensed peace officer is essentially the same as a police officer, with the power to arrest and carry weapons and what not. So instead of your security guard only being able to call for police, they can take police-like action immediately. Ever drive past a large event or like a church after Sunday service and see cops out in the street directing traffic? Often those are off duty cops serving as paid peace officers. In Texas, to have a large event where you serve alcohol (like say a wedding reception) you legally need to hire a peace officer for your security. Often people hire off duty cops, but you could hire someone who isn't a cop day to day. Anyone with a valid peace officer license can do it. I've known people who went through all the training and decided being a cop wasn't for them. They then took jobs like "security guard" but we're paid a lot more because of their peace officer license.
- tanepiper 2y agoI know this is being used by Microsoft and other voices in tech to bash the EU, but I really don't buy that argument. For a start it would only cover the decision within the EU, yet Microsoft chose to do this at a global level - likely also pressured by previous anti-monopoly rulings in the US. The main fall down here was a lack of rigor on their part, and Crowdstrike's. Thorough testing of all configurations of Windows is likely impossible - but it's clear this one affected so many it was a common one - why was this not caught? As for the EU - I'd say where their problems lie is in applying rules and regulations, but only in the context of that time and space - there is no regulatory follow-up from the initial conditions to ensure that software continues to be safe, and few certifications offered outside private companies own certification. It's just been announced they are diverting budget away from FOSS projects towards AI ones in their Horizon 2025 budget, once again weakening the software ecosystem in favour of the-popular-thing-at-the-moment. For their own sake they should be funding independent Red/Blue teams, and securing the internal supply chain of software - both to protect it from current threats, and future geo-political changes. But this is where they leave it up to market forces and this is why this situation will absolutely happen again and again.
- intern4tional 2y agoWindows does have the ability to have sovereign builds (and has had this since 2016?), but the capability wasn't present when the decision was made (in 2006). Windows build is complex and tightly coupled with performance testing, telemetry collection, etc and at the time this decision was made, not feasible to do. Reversing a change from 2006 would likely bring anti-trust action from the remainder of the world immediately, as that change from 2006 is relied on by everyone else globally today. The EUs stance isn't bad either, as MS has a competitor in this space that also relies on a kernel driver (MDATP does use a kernel driver) and it is unlikely MS would remove its own competitor from the kernel (at least this item was not discussed during my time at MS and I was in the security space of Windows).
- zokier 2y ago> The EUs stance isn't bad either, as MS has a competitor in this space that also relies on a kernel driver (MDATP does use a kernel driver) The Vista era Defender was pretty limited though, very different breed from current MS security products
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- yjkk 2y ago[dead]