3 ms·
Not if the state funds housebuilding, for the common good, rather than relying on private developers who only have profit motive. Rent controls need to be comb
by snjsisi 2y ago
Not if the state funds housebuilding, for the common good, rather than relying on private developers who only have profit motive.
Rent controls need to be combined with long-term social housing policy to be effective.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoIn the United States, social housing is the least popular form of housing and faces the fiercest opposition from NIMBYs. It would also require trillions of tax dollars to do at scale. For this and other reasons, it is a political nonstarter. Yes, developers are profit driven and this a good thing. So are grocery store owners for that matter and that is also a good thing. Since developers (usually) turn a profit, they attract investment dollars, and in turn convert those dollars into new homes. These new homes, especially if built in desirable areas, give wealthier people options to buy, who are now less likely to bid up the price of older homes as they do now.
- bryanlarsen 2y agoRent control reduces development, state funded housebuilding increases development. So state funded housebuilding ameliorates the effect of rent control, it doesn't eliminate it. State funded housebuilding without rent control would maximize new development, and the additional housing would put downward pressure on rents providing much of the benefit of rent control without the drawbacks.
- pydry 2y agoThe effect is very very muted though, which is why the fastest rate of NYC homebuilding in the 1950s coincided with the strictest rent controls. Like raising the minimum wage it is a very profit hostile policy though. Thats probably why marginal revolution despises both policies so much. Tyler Cowen takes koch money and the laws of supply and demand work the same way for the market for faux academic legitimacy in economics as they do for housing: if you have the cash, it can be bought.
- Jensson 2y ago> Like raising the minimum wage it is a very profit hostile policy though Does it really reduce profits, or does it increase prices? In general the economy balances out so ROI is the same everywhere so profits only decrease temporarily, so all costs comes from other sources long term, like reduces development or increased prices. If rent control only resulted in minimally less construction, then it just resulted in minimally less profits as the two are linked in the private sector.
- pydry 2y agoIncreasing the minimum wage primarily reduces profits: https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/staff/mdraca/minwage_profits.pdf https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/economics/staff/mdraca/minwage... >In general the economy balances out so ROI is the same everywhere so profits only decrease temporarily The only industry where is is "true" is small restaurants, where profit margin get hit short term but stay steady at 10% over the long term. This is because real restaurant profits are mostly consumed by their landlords, and it's their landlords who suck up the difference long term. This doesn't apply to big corporate restaurants like McDonalds because they have pricing power and often are their own landlords. Even so the SME restaurant industry hates the idea of raising the minimum wage more than most because it tends to lead to a wave of restaurant bankruptcies until rents adjust.
- alephnerd 2y ago> Not if the state funds housebuilding Chicago, Detroit, and NYC all tried that and abandoned it due to cost overruns, corruption, high liabilities, and the limiting of eminent domain powers following the civil rights movement - most urban housing projects were built by demolishing historically African American neighborhoods, and the resulting structures were segregated (as James Baldwin eloquently pointed out in 1963 during the height of the civil rights movement) The same thing happened in Western Europe as well with France and the UK abandoning similar urban housing projects. Singapore and HK are unique in that the governments are authoritarian and can kick people out with minimal notice or recourse if they really want to. The biggest blocker is always going to be land acquisition - either we reject the entire notion that you have property rights and the right to recourse, or you accept that these basic civil liberties are a requirement for a democracy and thus building will have to be done by the private sector because unlocking public funds would take 3-5 years on top of 2-3 years of construction. For a more recent example, look at China's urban renewal projects in the 2000s and 2010s, and how local governments would use forced evictions as well as minimal compensation and occasionally shooting protesters [0][1][2] or the mass evictions in Beijing in 2017-18 [3] - this was how Housing Projects were built across America from the 1930s-1960s. Opposition to that policy was also a major reason why Xi Jinping was initially quite popular, because he was opposed to these kinds of projects at scale, and Fujian never saw the kind of mass demolitions that you'd see in other Chinese provinces. [0] - https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A6968-2004Oct4.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A6968-2004Oct... [1] - http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4507130.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/asia-pacific/4507130.stm [2] - https://www.reuters.com/article/olympics-evictions-idUSPEK5747220080807/ https://www.reuters.com/article/olympics-evictions-idUSPEK57... [3] - https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/30/world/asia/china-beijing-migrants.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/30/world/asia/china-beijing-...
- Agentus 2y ago“ The biggest blocker is always going to be land acquisition - either we reject the entire notion that you have property rights and the right to recourse, or you accept that these basic civil liberties are a requirement and thus building will have to be done by the private sector because unlocking public funds would take 3-5 years on top of 2-3 years of construction.” Reflecting on the conflict of Israel and also in the show “yellowstone” basically originates from land ownership issues, i really think this human constructed abstraction and entitlement is fundamentally flawed. I really think it needs reworking and needs to be held as less sacred in America. Besides do people really own land when the government demands rent in the form of property taxes? So long as housing is so fundamentally stressful in current systems with resulting pervasive homelessness and rent seeking capitalism applied to shelter thats long paid for its investment yet still inflates in costs applying pressure on low income residents: i dont think mostly inalienable rights to property ownership in many cases is a public good.
- readthenotes1 2y agoI don't know know what heavenly state you live in, but in mine, if there is money there is corruption.