4 ms·
The second amendment talks about a well-regulated militia. That doesn't sound like it's intended to be protection against one's own government, but against inva
by vacri 14y ago
The second amendment talks about a well-regulated militia. That doesn't sound like it's intended to be protection against one's own government, but against invading armies.
- noblethrasher 14y agoI'd like to point out, for the benefit of others, that the term well-regulated simply meant 'effective' or 'in proper working order'. It did not necessarily mean that it should be controlled by the government. Source:http://constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm http://constitution.org/cons/wellregu.htm
- vacri 14y agoWhat about the 'militia' part? Or the 'being necessary for the security of a free state' part? The second amendment is saying 'we're not going to restrict arms, because we need a body of men to call on who know how to use arms, in order to maintain our independence', not 'fear your government, be prepared to shoot its representitives'.
- noblethrasher 14y agoI am not arguing that the second amendment is a provision for overthrowing the government. I really did just want to make sure everyone knew how 'well-regulated' should be interpreted since it's easy to read it naively.
- vacri 14y agoFair enough, thanks for the clarification. I was reading it still in context to the parent comment.
- stinky613 14y agoIt's both. The second amendment is necessary to maintain the security of a free state against foreign invaders and against a government seeking to take the 'free' from the 'free state'.
- hcurtiss 14y agoTwo points: 1. Notwithstanding that language, it's an individual right. See Heller. 2. Militias were, almost exclusively, the province Of the individual states. There was not until relatively recently a standing federal army. The point was to keep arms in the hands of individuals. The Bill of Rights is a check on large centralized government. It's the whole point. Don't forget that these guys had just been through precisely such a revolution. There are some pretty striking quotes from Thomas Jefferson directly on point.
- dpatru 14y agoThe second amendment is explicitly written to secure a right of the people against infringement by their government: the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Protection against foreign armies is already provided for in Article 1 (Congress has the power to fund the military) and Article 2 (the President is the Commander-in-chief of the military.)