4 ms·
If you went to school before about 1990 (?) you would get marked down in any writing assignment for using "they" in a singular sense. I did and I still notice i
by SoftTalker 2y ago
If you went to school before about 1990 (?) you would get marked down in any writing assignment for using "they" in a singular sense. I did and I still notice it when reading. Sometimes the context allows only a singular interpretation but often it doesn't and it causes a mental stumble trying to figure out what the author means.
We learned that "he" is neutral unless the subject is already known to be male. I agree that using "she" in a neutral sense is somewhat distracting.
- vundercind 2y agoGraduated early 2000s. Gender neutral “he” was taught as correct throughout primary and secondary school, neither “they” nor “she” was permitted. “She” didn’t become common in writing-in-the-wild until after 2010. You’d see it in academic writing occasionally before then, or explicitly feminist pieces maybe. “They” was more common but came off as very informal or low-register (to those taught the other way, at least). It did take me a long time to stop going “wait, who? I missed who we’re talking about” and start searching backwards in the text when encountering gender-neutral “she”. Did indeed make things hard to read for years.