4 ms·
Feh, just be honest with people. If they get defensive, they get defensive, so what? I'd love to hear you tell me "I just don't think you have what it takes,"
by mindcrime 14y ago
Feh, just be honest with people. If they get defensive, they get defensive, so what?
I'd love to hear you tell me "I just don't think you have what it takes," as that's just going to pour fuel on my fire and motivate me to work that much harder just to spite you.
I love negative feedback like that... fuck all ya'll, because when I'm running a billion dollar company and rocking up to your shitty office in my Maserati to ask "how's it going?" I'll be laughing to myself at how pathetic and stupid you were to doubt me.
- kposehn 14y ago> rocking up to your office in my Maserati This only works if you're in a white MC Stradale with gunmetal wheels. ;)
- sgrove 14y agoAnd this is a perfect reason why it'll never happen. What does the other side gain from telling you the truth and burning bridges like this? Best to give a vague, non-committal reason so there's always a chance they can talk with you again in the future. Investors (to take one example) are fallible and scared. They're driven by fear, and by greed - fear that they might miss out on the next facebook (it'll go on their public record, usually, because of what you're proposing), and greed at the upsides are if they can get in before others on the next facebook. Notice I didn't say "before anyone else." That's best, but barring that, you want to be able to get in later because you have a good relationship with the founder. And touchy founders that would be vindictive about being rejected are tough to keep a good relationship with, and most entrepreneurs are emotionally heavily invested in their own startup so it's easy to be touchy and vindictive, so it's "best" as an investor to not upset anyone. "best" is in quotes because this is a trend that might slowly be changing, in large part because of the pressure from groups like YC.
- mindcrime 14y agoOh, no, no, no... at least in my case, I certainly didn't mean to imply that I'd take any bridges as having been burned. When I say "fuck ya'll" I mean that in the best possible way... I want to have that chip on my shoulder, I'd take it as them having done me a favor if somebody tells me that they think I can't hack it. I feed off that shit. Best to give a vague, non-committal reason so there's always a chance they can talk with you again in the future. I'd talk to the OP again, after I make it bigtime and roll up in the Maserati, with a 6' tall, red-headed supermodel with a Scottish accent on my arm... and I'd say "fuck you, dude" and then buy a round of beers and sit back and laugh about the whole thing. Of course, that's just me... :-)
- heretohelp 14y agoYou write and think like a cocky 13 year old.
- joering2 14y agoBut yet you couldn't even check basic facts like this guy has karma above 3,800 for over 4 years, +500 linkedin connections, tons of software engineering experience, and 19 job recommendations [1]. Sure; he writes and thinks like a kid. Let me ignore him! [1] http://phillip.onlinked.in/ http://phillip.onlinked.in/
- jbooth 14y agoQuote: " I'd talk to the OP again, after I make it bigtime and roll up in the Maserati, with a 6' tall, red-headed supermodel with a Scottish accent on my arm... and I'd say "fuck you, dude" and then buy a round of beers and sit back and laugh about the whole thing." He might be a professional success but based on this sample size, yeah, writes and thinks like a cocky 13yo until proven otherwise. No offense intended to anyone, of course. Maybe it was satire.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- 3pt14159 14y agoYou have no idea how common this method of thinking is, even by successful startup founders. Granted, most are more concerned about building a product people love, but some people thrive on proving people wrong, and that drives them to success.
- heretohelp 14y agoI beat a lot of odds to get to where I am now. Doesn't mean I act like a cock about it.
- 14y ago
- jbreinlinger 14y agobtw, I love being proven wrong as well. It gives me incredibly important data. I always reflect on past decisions, good and bad. It helps minimize the bad ones and maximize the good ones.
- mindcrime 14y agoHeh... hopefully you got the spirit of my reply, unlike some people in this thread.
- carsongross 14y agoI agree with the honesty part, but if you are basing your self-worth on the ability to roll up on someone in a Maserati... I'm not much of a Rand guy, but I think Roark's response is the best: "But I don’t think of you."
- mindcrime 14y agoI agree with the honesty part, but if you are basing your self-worth on the ability to roll up on someone in a Maserati... Of course I'm being partially facetious here. The point is to take negative feedback as a challenge and use it as motivation. I'm not much of a Rand guy, but I think Roark's response is the best: "But I don’t think of you." Yeah, ya know, I was just watching The Fountainhead again last week and that scene really jumped out at me. I do admire that outlook, but I also find value in choosing to use doubters doubts as motivation. I know it seems contradictory but it works for me.
- Jitle 14y agoThis response perfectly demonstrates the need to lie as stated in the article. As an investor, you say "no" A LOT. I can't have the 99% of people I talk to walking away with an attitude. I received the introduction to one of our best investments from a CEO we said no to. Do you think that CEO would have made the introduction if I had told him he doesn't have what it takes to be a founder at a VC backed startup?
- mindcrime 14y agoDo you think that CEO would have made the introduction if I had told him he doesn't have what it takes to be a founder at a VC backed startup? Maybe, who's to say?
- rexreed 14y agoHow many times a day do you think successful startup founders hear "no" and get on with it? How many times a day do you think successful startup founders say "no"? A lot. Learn to be successful. Say no and learn to accept no. It's surprising how dishonesty permeates the financial services industries (of which venture capital is one).
- tomjen3 14y agoThat is properly why YCs rejection letter are so nice. Otherwise too many people would get that bit of extra fuck you moral boost (and as PG keeps pointing, start ups are run on morale).
- moron 14y agoTelling people like you your faults is like talking to a brick wall. Why bother? I don't blame them for lying.