5 ms·
Do you realize that by suggesting to "keep your savings up" you are predicting stable purchasing power of US dollar? It's entirely possible for someone to play
by DenisM 18y ago
Do you realize that by suggesting to "keep your savings up" you are predicting stable purchasing power of US dollar?
It's entirely possible for someone to play it safe, stick to cash savings and then get burned if/when dollar is devalued by 75% simialr to Argentina 2001, Russia 1998 or Iceland 2008.
- jerf 18y agoIf massive inflation occurs, you're pretty much screwed no matter what. It is not currently possible to live fully, truly off the grid in the manner in which anybody posting to Hacker News is accustomed. Planning for events that you can do nothing about is a waste of time; the fact that that is unfortunate changes nothing. (Which is not to say some reasonable preparation for emergencies is a bad idea. I'm just saying that once you're proposing massive inflation, it's not like having a huge stash of gold in your basement is going to save you, or there's anything else you can hoard that can't be taken from you by force by a rampaging mob.)
- patrickg-zill 18y agoI am amazed at the hatred for gold among some HN'ers. This is the second thread I have seen where gold was mentioned, and the second time I have seen a vitriolic response about gold. Gold will always be valuable and it will always be part of a sane person's plan for dealing with a "things are going to crap" scenario. Along with some form of food storage to deal with logistic interrruptions and some form of personal defense (mace, pepper spray, knives, guns, etc.)
- fallentimes 18y agoGold will always be valuable... How do you know? While I'm all for world & class asset diversification, the whole reason is because I/we don't know.
- patrickg-zill 18y ago1. It is needed for industrial/electronics purposes. 2. It is internationally recognized as being valuable, regardless of culture. That is, cultures as diverse as India, China, England, Russia, pan-Arabic (i.e. non-Jews in the Middle East) have all viewed gold as having value, and that over at least 1000 years of recorded history each. 3. It does not corrode or rot the way paper money does. In Israel they recently found some Byzantine-era gold coins, aside from the obvious numismatic/collector value they still retain value for the gold itself. 4. Gold does not require a government to enforce its value. It's value is innate or intrinsic to the thing itself. As such if a government falls or decides to modify the value of a paper dollar (as Mexico, Argentina etc. have done in the past) then the value changes. Gold that you have in your pocket cannot have its value modified by a government order.
- fallentimes 18y agoGreat answer - thank you. If you have a blog/site you should definitely write about this.
- davidw 18y agoThe internet is full of gold bug blogs. Here's one response to the gold bug arguments, by Nobel prize winner Krugman: http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/goldbug.html http://web.mit.edu/krugman/www/goldbug.html Even libertarians like Arnold Kling don't really have much time for the gold standard: http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2007/01/the_new_deal_an.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2007/01/the_new_deal_an.... (and in other articles) Generally, it's not regarded as territory for "serious economists", although of course it is always possible that serious economists are wrong.
- bokonist 18y agoThe two most interesting posts I've read in defense of gold are these two: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2007/11/who-heck-is-benn-steil.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2007/11/who-hec... and here http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2008/02/return-to-castle-goldenstein-gold.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2008/02/return-... Both are much better than the Krugman piece.
- gaius 18y agoGold will always be valuable For varying values of valuable. Our bold leader Gordon Brown sold off the UK's gold reserves for about a third of the current market price. He even announced well in advance that he was planning to dump a load of gold on the market, so the price dropped even further. Gold's a great asset but it's not the be-all and end-all.
- Prrometheus 18y agoI used to keep a portion of my savings in foreign currency ETFs, gold ETFs, and foreign stocks because I was concerned about devaluation of the dollar. You're gambling if you do this, of course, because the dollar can go up, too. However, it does hedge your risk somewhat compared to keeping all of your savings in assets denominated by a single currency.
- daniel-cussen 18y ago>(Which is not to say some reasonable preparation for emergencies is a bad idea. I'm just saying that once you're proposing massive inflation, it's not like having a huge stash of gold in your basement is going to save you, or there's anything else you can hoard that can't be taken from you by force by a rampaging mob.) Citation needed. According to FerFAL, who actually lived through the 2001 Argentinian peso devaluation, a large stash of gold will save you because there won't be a rampaging mob robbing everyone, especially not if you own a gun. http://ferfal.blogspot.com/ http://ferfal.blogspot.com/ Ten kilos of gold should be enough to get you anywhere on the planet; after all, it should be worth 300,000 current dollars or so. The only scenario where that would be useless is a nuclear holocaust.
- DenisM 18y agoFalse choice fallacy: either "no hyperinflation" or "rampaging mobs". In fact several countries have survived hyperinflation without the mobs. Once again, Russia 1998, Argentina 2001, Icelad 2008. On the other hand USA 1930 and Nazi Germany saw confiscation of gold by the government and it might make sense to prepare for that as well by storing your gold abroad.
- jerf 18y agoActually, rather than a false choice fallacy, my real point is that no matter how prepared you are, you can always hypothesize a situation for which your preparation is insufficient. Concluding that therefore, any given action (in this case, saving dollars) is a bad idea because it "might not be enough" is an invalid argument. One must argue about probabilities. I personally do not rate a hyperinflation of the US dollar without massive upheaval a very strong probability; your other cited examples weren't the foundation of the global economy. (I rate it much lower than either no hyperinflation, or hyperinflation with massive upheaval. The people stealing your goods in the massive upheaval case is likely to be the government, so merely "a gun" won't cut it.)
- DenisM 18y ago>>I personally do not rate a hyperinflation of the US dollar without massive upheaval a very strong probability; your other cited examples weren't the foundation of the global economy. Well, I cited at lest some foundation to my argument - there were numberous cases where serious devaluation did not coincide with too much social disorder. I don't see how being "the foundation of global economy" makes Americans any more likely to riot and pillage. The only cases I can think of this happening in developed countries is an outright revolution, for which there does not seem to be basis in US right now. You're quite right to worry about government doing the pillaging though. While probability is low, the consequences would be disastorous and if one is hedging their bets might as well include this possibility. Hence why I suggested keeping your goods abroad - that way you are diversified across two political systems.