4 ms·
> Economies of scale. It’s cheaper to build lots of identical things. It is important to note what parts the identical is important and what you can vary. You
by bluGill 2y ago
> Economies of scale. It’s cheaper to build lots of identical things.
It is important to note what parts the identical is important and what you can vary. You can buy cars in many colors because it turns out black is no longer an advantage, manufactures can change paint quickly. (the reason you only get about 6 choices is sales wants to keep each color in stock so you can drive it home, there is no savings in manufacturing to have 6 colors choices as opposed to 60,000)
In the case of houses the identical thing is 8 or 9 foot tall walls with mostly 90 degree angles. You have a lot of options to make walls longer or shorter as you desire and so houses get great scale factors despite not being very identical.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> black is no longer an advantage, manufactures can change paint quickly Those systems and inventory still add to cost. Most consumers just don’t care about that marginal cost when buying a car. > have a lot of options to make walls longer or shorter as you desire and so houses get great scale factors despite not being very identical This is still more expensive than having them be identical. Fundamentally, uniqueness and cost are related due to economies of scale.
- bluGill 2y agoNo it isn't - while you could make a jig for a specific wall, even if all houses used that same size wall, transport fees would more than the cost of building the wall manually as we do now. The above is why pre-fab never took off. Sure you can build a house in a factory, but transport costs are much harder than bringing the materials and factory to the house site. The wall height matters because most of the boards in the wall are pre-cut in a factory already and that is something your factory built house cannot improve on (unless you want a weird wall height)
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> while you could make a jig for a specific wall, even if all houses used that same size wall, transport fees would more than the cost of building the wall manually as we do now But one is still cheaper! > why pre-fab never took off Same reason we have more car colors. It’s more expensive. But we value variety more than that marginal cost. That doesn’t change that producing one costs more than the other. (There is also a massive difference between consolidating fabrication and consolidating construction. Developments work because you have one team doing a similar set of tasks at the same location repeatedly.)
- toast0 2y agoIt's all about small changes. Getting a whole prefabbed house is a thing, but not the nicest. But pre-fabbed roof trusses are very common now. It's more work to ship those than the pieces, but on-site labor savings and consistency make it valuable. Pre-hung doors with doorframes are also the norm. I'm not in the industry, but I could imagine there's some possibility for pre-fabbed wall panels, but I don't know how much that really saves, because I wouldn't think you want to pre-hang the drywall, it'll get damaged in shipping. Maybe you could prehang exterior sheathing. But it's a big increasing in shipping volume to save only a little bit of time and have a much less flexible layout.
- formerly_proven 2y ago> there is no savings in manufacturing to have 6 colors choices as opposed to 60,000 This isn't really true. At the peak of car customizability an OEM had an astronomic number (something like 10^180) of possible configuration combinations for a single model, with very few cars having actually identical configurations and like 80% being unique configurations. Adds a huge amount of complexity to the supply chain and shop floor management. There's a reason why OEMs have been greatly reducing the number of individual options since then.
- bluGill 2y agoThe reason is mostly that sales wants to someone who walks in the door the first time to walk out. If someone wants to custom order a car the 10^180 possible combinations isn't that big a deal, but there is no way to have that many cars on every lot and so sales demands it. Yes less different models does save a little but of cost, but it isn't that much overall.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThere is actually a huge savings to have fewer colors because it reduces the complexity of skus and the horror of color matching defects.