6 ms·
> suburbs work by siphoning resources from larger cities, sort of like a parasite. in turn they produce and encourage among the worst trends in US homes. acres
by bluGill 2y ago
> suburbs work by siphoning resources from larger cities, sort of like a parasite. in turn they produce and encourage among the worst trends in US homes. acres of irrigated lawns and uninsulated attics and windows arent a concern but a feature of their housing code malaise as the cities subsidize this largesse.
That is the narrative, but it doesn't stand up. Suburbs have existed for over 100 years now, and those older ones have managed to tear out the streetcars (on hindsight a mistake), put in sewer, water, phone, electric, cable tv - most of the above list has been replaced several times. They seem like they must be siphoning from the larger city until you realize that they are not replacing all of that every 20 years and so depreciation is not a clue as to the real long term costs.
There are exurbs where you get acres of land, those are generally surrounded by farms (at least for the first 30 years until the suburbs expand out that far - but then a developer will buy those acres and divide it for more houses) In the suburbs you are looking at more like 10 houses per acre - which is not very dense, but still much denser.
The US has good building codes. There is no place where you can get by with an uninsulated attic - except in the bad parts of big cities where houses from 1880 are still around and not upgraded.
edit: uninsulated attic
- telotortium 2y ago> There is no place where you can get by with an insulated attic Surely you mean “uninsulated attic” here?
- jandrese 2y agoI admittedly don't tour a lot of homes, but I'm pretty sure insulating between the attic space and the living space is close to universal in my area. Maybe if you live in Southern California or Hawaii and your home doesn't have A/C you could get away without it. Especially if you have a whole house fan that vents into the attic. But even then it is so cheap to blow in insulation that it seems foolish to not do it.
- robohoe 2y agoYep, it's pretty universal in the US. You insulate the attic floor (ceiling of your rooms). This also means that you need to keep your attic cold. You do that by letting air in from your soffit vents to either ridge or gable vent. Ridge vent is arguably better because it runs along the right of your roof allowing the air to travel between the trusses that holds your roof up.
- rconti 2y agowhy would you be able to "get away with it" specifically without A/C? Seems to me having A/C would make a house with an uninsulated attic at least somewhat less miserable.
- jandrese 2y agoIt's more because you'll have your windows open all the time because you live in paradise.
- rconti 2y agoOh. But I mean, you'd still be much better off with insulation. FWIW I wouldn't want to live in SoCal (hot) or Hawaii (hot and humid) without A/C. We don't have A/C here in the bay area, and I wouldn't want to live anywhere warmer without it.
- bombela 2y agoUninsulated attic: do you mean the attic is not part of the conditioned space? Or that there is no insulation at all? Because attics don't appear to be insulated in the bay area. There is usually insulation for the ceiling below though.
- bluGill 2y agothere is no insulation between the ceiling. Having the attic not part of the conditioned space is normal in the us. I wonder if that is what OP meant, if so it is a stupid requirement to add.
- philwelch 2y agoI've seen some convincing arguments (e.g. from Matt Risinger on YouTube) that the attic should be inside the conditioned space, even though this isn't the normal standard. Particularly if you have a slab foundation and your HVAC and ducting in the attic. Main reason is that if your HVAC ducts are up there, your attic is going to get really hot during the summer so you lose a lot of energy efficiency in your AC.
- shiroiushi 2y agoYes, but the ducts themselves are normally insulated too, so either you're getting heat through the insulated walls of the ducts, or you're getting heat through the roof and walls (on 2 sides) into a much, much larger volume of air, which you're now using more energy to keep cool. I'm not sure which one is going to be more wasteful. This does make the ductless ("mini-split") HVAC systems look more attractive, however those lose the advantage of economy of scale (having a bunch of small ACs instead of one big one), but might gain some back by making it really easy to not waste energy cooling all the rooms if you only want some of them kept cooler.
- philwelch 2y ago> Yes, but the ducts themselves are normally insulated too, so either you're getting heat through the insulated walls of the ducts, or you're getting heat through the roof and walls (on 2 sides) into a much, much larger volume of air, which you're now using more energy to keep cool. It's not an either-or though. If you have a vented attic, you're still getting heat through the roof and walls into the attic, and you're getting much more of it because it's not insulated (because it isn't a conditioned space). And then that heat is going to try and go through the relatively poor insulation of your HVAC ducts. At least in the south, it's common for a vented attic to get even hotter than the ambient outside temperature, going well above 120 degrees or more. Conversely, when you're going with a conditioned attic, you would insulate the ceiling of the attic, blocking as much of the heat from getting in as you can. And then your HVAC ducts only need to insulate against a gradient of maybe 74 to 50 degrees rather than a gradient of 120 to 50 degrees or even more on an especially hot day.
- gumby 2y ago> ... managed to tear out the streetcars (on hindsight a mistake) Having lived in places with OK (SF) or good streetcar service (Berlin, which is a nice A/B test case with East/West Berlin) I am a huge fan of streetcars. But my understanding is that in general the streetcars never made money in suburban developments. What I remember reading (on HN first!) was that they were deployed in early (post WWII) suburbs to entice urban people to move to a suburbs, but were operated at a loss. When the town eventually had to take them over they shut them down. Does the economics really work out when you don't have urban density?
- mantas 2y agoPretty much any public transit is operated at a loss very few exceptions usually make money off real estate, namely stations in prime locations.
- slaymaker1907 2y agoTo be fair, I think a lot of the benefits of public transit go to people who aren't even using it. When you make it easier to go somewhere, more people will go there which is good for business at that somewhere. There are also the benefits of reduced traffic for those who do end up driving.
- mantas 2y agoYes. Although my argument would be slightly different. Subsidizing public transit in many cases is cheaper than upgrading roads. There is also social element. Elders & kids, disabled, DUI crowd… Public transit helps a lot to engage them.
- stonogo 2y agoI will never understand why mass transit is held to profit-making standards but roads are not.
- bobthepanda 2y ago