4 ms·
The bulk of your logic makes sense, besides depending on taking "privacy is an inalienable right" as a premise. However, on a practical level... "Because we'
by andrewflnr 14y ago
The bulk of your logic makes sense, besides depending on taking "privacy is an inalienable right" as a premise. However, on a practical level...
"Because we're better than that"
In order to fight a war[0] from a "better than that" position, you have to have vastly greater power, enough to compensate for the hobbles you put on yourself to remain "better". Otherwise, whoever fights dirtiest wins. When people are trying to kill us, how do we make up for not listening to them, without letting people die?
[0] In a loose sense. Terrorists try to kill us, and the only way to stop them is with force. A lot of the same principles apply.
- dllthomas 14y agoThe only way to stop existing terrorists may be to kill them. The things that go into stopping prospective terrorists from becoming actual terrorists are more complicated.
- JohannL 14y ago"Everybody's worried about stopping terrorism. Well, there's a really easy way: stop participating in it." -- Noam Chomsky
- theorique 14y agoSomebody tell Al Qaeda. I'm sure they'll listen to a reasoned debate.
- JohannL 14y agoAbsence of terrorism doesn't imply absence of self-defense, so any point you might think you have, you don't. And hey, maybe that's just because Noam Chomsky thinks about the things he says; might want to try it yourself sometime.
- khuey 14y agoBut we do have vastly greater power. Terrorist groups definitely don't have a budget of 680 billion USD[0]. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States#Budget_for_2010 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_S...
- dllthomas 14y agoWhile I agree with the point, raw budget comparisons are not a valid way to make it; terrorists also aren't defending such a big piece of land (and sea), and are more narrowly focused in scope as well.
- padraigm 14y agoThe raw budget comparison is not the end of the United States' military superiority; the US has access to cruise missiles and aircraft targeting systems that allow them to put a precisely-measured dose of explosive through practically any window in the world at a few moments' notice. Meanwhile, the "terrorists" are strapping some fertilizer to a Nokia brick phone and laying it on the side of the road in the hopes that a truck will drive by so they can detonate it. The US so vastly out-matches the people it's fighting right now that they're having to write new strategic doctrine to be able to handle it. Are you really trying to make the argument that we don't have enough leeway to keep some principles in the process of defending ourselves?
- dllthomas 14y agoOf course the raw budget comparison is not the end of the US's military superiority; I said I agreed with the parent's general point: that while additional constraints may make it harder to achieve tactical objectives, we don't have any trouble achieving tactical objectives. My point was just that the metric being used was irrelevant to the comparison being made.
- andrewflnr 14y agoIn the intelligence battle, though, how much can we afford to cut ourselves off? A large budget is of little use, unless we can spend it on surveillance equipment...
- hcurtiss 14y agoLiberty creates risk. Yes, the terr'ists may get a few of us from time to time. It's not, IMHO, worth giving up our civil liberties to prevent that.
- janardanyri 14y agoA group of terrorists lucked into taking down two big buildings and so we have to debate whether we can afford civil liberties? The premise should be self-evidently absurd. If we'll kill thousands of Arabs to protect freedom, we shouldn't be so eager to walk away from it for the death of a few thousand Americans. I would also suggest that abandoning principle for expediency can be hobbling in itself. Wars aren't entirely fought by robots just yet. "Power" isn't a column in an Excel spreadsheet.