3 ms·
The tax exclusive prices lets you know how much the government is soaking you, rather than hiding it and blaming it on the business.
by WalterBright 2y ago
The tax exclusive prices lets you know how much the government is soaking you, rather than hiding it and blaming it on the business.
- chowells 2y agoThat's irrelevant. Give me the total price, so I know how much something will cost. I don't care what percentage of it goes where. I only care about easily evaluating whether something is worth the price. Seriously. I don't care if the total price consists of 100% tax or 0% tax. I care only what it is. I don't ask to know how much you pay the cleaners, how much it costs to operate the pool, how much corporate profit you're booking, or how much the CFO is embezzling. The amount of tax is equally useless to me. I care what it costs me.
- sebastiennight 2y agoLooks like I'm not the only European that has seen a price tag of $9.50 on a product I wanted, only to find out that the $10 bill in my pocket was only two thirds of the amount needed! Look at us poor Europeans with our metric-system money-math
- chowells 2y agoI'm American, actually. I've just managed not to have my brain poisoned by Libertarianism. (The capital L sort.)
- dambi0 2y agoWas the markup just sales tax or did it include tips or extra fees? A 35% plus sales tax seems awfully high where in the US was it?
- thaumasiotes 2y agoA ~10% sales tax is normal, and that will bring $9.50 over the $10 limit.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tgma 2y ago> The amount of tax is equally useless to me. Not if you are voting someone in a political office in the next election.
- amanaplanacanal 2y agoThen you can look up how much the tax is when you are making your voting decision. This isn’t secret information.
- WalterBright 2y agoThe government routinely hides what you're paying in taxes. Case in point - the so-called "Employer's Contribution" to your social security taxes. There's no such thing. That comes out of your pocket, too. This is because employers have no interest in what your paycheck amount is. They care about "total compensation", which is what it costs the employer to employ you. Seattle added some "payroll taxes" and successfully sold the fiction that it was the businesses paying it. The businesses did indeed write the check, but it was the employee's money.
- taylorius 2y agoIndeed - UK the same. The government makes so much hay out of persuading the electorate that businesses are somehow entirely separate from them.
- razakel 2y agoDo you really think people don't know that the tax deductions on their payslip are actually their money?
- WalterBright 2y agoThe "Employer's Contribution" is not listed as a deduction on the payslip.
- tgma 2y ago
- jcranmer 2y agoEveryone always blames price movements on the government anyways. And when it is tax inclusive--gasoline--the government hasn't dared to change the rate in decades!
- WalterBright 2y agoWashington State added a 50c per gallon gas tax. They did it by taxing the oil companies, so when the pump prices went up 50c the politicians adamantly blamed the price increase on the oil companies.
- dpkirchner 2y agoThere's no reason they couldn't also list the tax as a separate line item. That's what they do in my state with liquor and cannabis.
- jimsug 2y agoDo shops usually show both prices, so you can see before you have it rung up "how much the government is fleecing you"?
- mkl 2y agoNo one would blame the business. Receipts should show sales tax clearly. I would very much blame the business for leaving out tax, concealing how much I'll need to pay to try to get me to overspend. Businesses claiming they don't want to be blamed for sales tax existing seems like misdirection from the real reason: it makes it look like you're spending less.
- tsimionescu 2y agoSo you believe that prices are set by supply and demand and nothing else in all of your other discussions, but when it comes to taxes, it's the government's fault? When a tax hike happens, businesses don't automatically have to increase prices they charge by the same amount: they can take a hit to their margin instead. So, the price they choose to charge is not "price + tax". It is "supply-and-demand price, of which we pay X to the state in taxes".
- WalterBright 2y agoTaxes are not set by supply & demand. > they can take a hit to their margin instead Not for long. Low margin businesses tend to go out of business. And if you can earn 5% buying bonds, why run a business that has an ROI of 4%?
- tsimionescu 2y agoThe point is that supply and demand works on the final price, not on "price before tax". Especially when taxes are proportional, so if you offer a lower price than your competitor, you also pay less of it to the state in taxes. So the tax level is irrelevant to the value of the market price, if you believe in supply & demand as the price setting mechanism. Showing price without tax is then obviously a scam to try to attack your psychology to think it's cheaper. They could just as well show price - marketing costs. Of course, if businesses actually set prices as cost + margin, then it does make sense to separate tax from the price, as the value "price before tax" is a meaningful part of the price setting algorithm. And lowering your margin is not the same thing as running a low margin business. If your margin was 20% at a tax level of 10%, and taxes go to 15%, then reducing your margin to 18% doesn't make you a low margin business now. Regardless, if you believe in supply and demand as the sole mechanism for price setting, this is all moot: the state increasing taxes won't increase demand or reduce supply with the exact same level as the tax increase, so the price can't move the exact same as the tax increase in this model. I'd also note that it's not strictly true that taxes are completely decoupled from supply & demand. States do compete on attracting businesses through lower taxation.
- 2y ago