3 ms·
The problem is that peer review is primarily focused on results. Peer review should be done up to but not including the results. Provide motivation, explain you
by bachmeier 2y ago
The problem is that peer review is primarily focused on results. Peer review should be done up to but not including the results. Provide motivation, explain your methodology, explain how it will resolve issues in the literature, but don't say anything about your results. Papers should be conditionally accepted, subject to confirmation that the results you report are the results of the proposal that went through peer review.