5 ms·
Microsoft, Apple, Google sued over icon software patent
- kwamenum86 18y agoDoes anyone understand the purpose of patent law? It provides incentives to inventors to keep inventing. To denounce patent law because of a ptent troll is pretty silly. The system needs tweaking but there patent law (and intellectual property law in general) allows creators to monetize innovation easily, which is incredibly important.
- gommm 18y agoFor me patent law is like communism, the purpose/ideals of it might be nice, but I'd like to see an implementation that does not suck...
- jbjohns 18y agoThen step outside the US.
- gommm 18y agoI'm french and living in japan. Japanese patent law is not much better than the us one (or at least from the little I learned about it) and in europe we are constantly fighting to prevent software patents... Now in truth, while I used to be interested in this, I haven't looked much in the question in the last few years.
- jbjohns 18y agoI'm not surprised that Japan's solution isn't very good (especially considering their some-what toxic property/business ownership laws), but it's a big step from "all the ones I'm familiar with suck" to "they all suck".
- gommm 18y agoThat's why I said 'I'd like to see an implementation that does not suck', it means all the ones I've seen (= familiar with) suck... :-)
- mattmcknight 18y agoThese bastards deserve nothing. Their software looks like garbage. It also seems really foolish to include Microsoft in this suit, as they are the most likely to have a competing patent. The Cygnus interface looks a lot like the Powerpoint slide sorter.
- iamdave 18y agoPatent law inherently represents everything that is fucked up about how this country works when it comes to innovative rights and creative control. The ability to patent ANYTHING should have been killed decades ago.
- sachinag 18y agoAgain, this isn't patent law messing up - it's overworked USPTO examiners not finding the prior art. Furthermore, Google, Microsoft, Apple et al could have challenged the validity of the patent application when it was public, before it was awarded.
- noonespecial 18y agoGoogle's official founding date was September 7, 1998, two months after the patent application was filed. I doubt they were in any position to search all of the patents applied for and challenge the validity of all of the vague ridiculousness that was currently on file that may some day interfere with a 20% project that might possibly become a product! This is submarine-ary of the first order. It may be legal at this time but I'm ready to lean out and say that its immoral.
- iamdave 18y agoI don't know if immoral is the right word here, more incredibly irresponsible.
- qqq 18y agoYou're saying incredible irresponsibility is moral or morally neutral?
- anamax 18y ago> This is submarine-ary of the first order. The term submarine patent is typically used for a patent application where the applicant delayed issuance and kept amending the application until a worthwhile target appeared. Without looking at the application, I can't say whether that's true in this case. However, US patent law changed some time ago to limit the value of this strategy. It used to be that the 20 year term started when the patent issued. Now patents expire 20 years after application, even if they're not issued until 10-15 years after application.
- daniel-cussen 18y agoThis is excellent news in that it may make patent law look even sillier.