5 ms·
In the 1920s being Jewish in Germany was perfectly legal. Not long after it was not. That's the only example I need to convince me that the government does no
by jgrahamc 14y ago
In the 1920s being Jewish in Germany was perfectly legal. Not long after it was not.
That's the only example I need to convince me that the government does not need to know everything about who am I and what I do and what I think.
- bornhuetter 14y agoI honestly don't know how anyone can, with a straight face, ignore this.
- mattmanser 14y agoProbably because people just don't believe it will ever happen to their country, to them or their children.
- mduerksen 14y agoSadly, people do, even here in Germany. When I use this example to illustrate how an information that was once "clean" can become "dirty", they don't seem to understand. They act like that "incident" is soo far away, some sort of horror story(!) that has nothing to do with today. Everything will stay like it is now. I guess the idea of something like 1933 happening again is so frightening or detached that they just dismiss it. EDIT: I should add that people who actually lived in the time of Nazi-Germany might have a very different reaction to jgrahamc's argument. I made my observation above mainly with young people.
- Elte 14y agoBeat me to it with this comment, a very solid point. Having nothing to hide now doesn't mean you'll never have something to hide in retrospect.
- eigenvector 14y agoThe number one reason for the government to create a comprehensive register of something is enable later legislation to ban it. We've seen this several times in Canada with firearms - first a law requiring registration of a certain class of firearms, and then once the government knows where they all are, a new piece of legislation requiring them to be surrendered. The more information the government has, the more it enables future oppressive action.
- afterburner 14y agoLet's try to keep the gun control debate separate from the privacy debate. Despite the shared aspect of the individual, these are entirely separate issues. I can't extremely easily kill someone with my private information. Private information is not a direct tool for committing violent crime, or for that matter, hunting game.
- rmc 14y agoNot to mention that some countries have radically different gun laws from the USA, and some people who support privacy don't want to be seen like those crazies over there who think everyone needs more guns.
- eigenvector 14y agoYou seem to have misunderstood my point. I'm not commenting on whether or not it is appropriate to ban guns. I'm merely using information /about/ guns (not the actual possession or use thereof) as an example. I think it's a salient point no matter how you feel about the ownership of firearms. Registering a person's lawful property or activities (whatever they may be) is a great way to target them in the future. If the government decided to outlaw, say, baking soda, it would be prohibitively difficult to enforce because there is no existing mechanism for tracking the sale, ownership and transfer of baking soda. Persons owning baking soda could easily bury it in their backyard and claim they never had it. Not so if the gov't has an inventory of all of your property (or access to your credit card statements, for example). So my point is in line with the OP: simply because an activity is lawful doesn't me we should accept unlimited government surveillance of it.
- afterburner 14y agoThis speaks exactly to the general point I wanted to make: why should I put so much trust in the government? I'm not anti-gov by any means, but government is a large group of people, and among any large group, there are going to be some untrustworthy people, some liars, some stupid people, some irresponsible people, some committing crimes, some covering up crimes (which is just another crime)... And certainly, in government, there are going to be some people who have agendas, and some people who have only their interest or their small group's interests in mind. So turning over everything to this large group, with all its power is... risky to say the least.
- thomasluce 14y agoI agree 100%. Furthermore, privacy is an issue of trust, not an issue of guilt. These very lines of reasoning (and the laws that stem from them) cause me to not trust those people and institutions, and so I won't trust them with my information, weather or not I feel that information is damning. They have shown their untrustworthiness, and so I must expect, in order to protect myself, that they are untrustworthy people who will do untrustworthy things with that data.
- pnathan 14y ago100% agreed. I would also extend my distrust to corporations. While I don't have a ready-to-mind example, I am sure that, humans being human, gross abuses of power by corporations based on certain datapoints being available exist. I am pretty sure the LGBT community has a slew of great examples there, as well as other outsider communities.
- lunarscape 14y agoSince you mention LGBT issues I can give one example from my country. In Ireland being gay is legal and generally well accepted. LGBT groups exist on every campus, we have openly gay politicians and (limited) civil partnerships. However one of the reasons some people keep their sexual orientation private is to avoid employment problems if they work in education. Under the scope of "ethos" religious schools can deny employment to whomever they see fit as they have a opt-out in equality laws[1]. Obvious examples would be discrimination against non-Catholics, divorced and LGBT people. Unfortunately the Catholic Church controls 93%+ of primary level schools and the vast majority of second level schools. Although this law is being openly debated, challenged legally and expected to change soon, it still leaves people living in fear. I personally know one person in this unfortunate position. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_Republic_of_Ireland#Discrimination_protections https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_rights_in_the_Republic_of...
- bstpierre 14y agoTo Americans who argue "not in my country": * In the 1930s being Japanese in the USA was perfectly legal. After 1942 it was not. * Prior to 1947, Americans had freedom of association. Starting in 1947, numerous people were denied employment, and some were jailed ("Hollywood Ten") because of their association. This was a campaign of both government and corporate intimidation. * Over the past decade or so, numerous people have been denied a certain amount of freedom of movement without any sort of due process because their names generated a match on the TSC's No Fly List. Those are three very easy examples taken just from the USA. You could generate a much longer list with a bit more effort and expanding to other countries.
- jusben1369 14y agoSo there wasn't widespread persecution of Jews and horrible crimes against them as a people before there was a government database? As horrible as the events were, and they were truly despicable, the logic is flawed. The conclusion is eradicate government census work and we'll eradicate racial persecution.
- jgrahamc 14y agoThe conclusion is that government statistical work should be limited to exclude data that is sensitive. For example, French law prevents the collection and processing of sensitive information on individuals where sensitive is defined as "the person’s racial or ethnic origins, political, philosophical or religious views, and trade-union membership, health and sexual life"
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rmc 14y agoBeing gay, while never totally legal, was not strictly enforced in 1920s/30s Germany. Several German gay films from that era exist ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandoras_Box_(film) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pandoras_Box_(film) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%A4dchen_in_Uniform_(1931_film) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M%C3%A4dchen_in_Uniform_(1931_f... ). Not long afterwards, those people were sent to the gas chambers.